Using a Self-Directed Learning Technique for Learning Suturing Skills: Does Medical Student Self-Assessment Agree with that of Faculty Observers?
Health Professions Education · 01.01.2025 · 11 (3)
DOI: 10.55890/2452-3011.1354 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Health Professions Education, online erschienen am 01.01.2025. Verfasst von Divya Srinivas und 6 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine if students’ self-rating of suturing skills learned in a self-directed manner was concordant with physicians’ ratings.
Methods
Second year medical students were provided a video-based, self-directed curriculum, and a suture pad to use over eight weeks. Each student rated their performance of placing three simple interrupted sutures using a Global Rating Scale. Video recordings of the students’ performance were then assessed by three faculty using the same rating scale. The students’ self-assessments were compared to the average of faculty assessments to test for bias, correlation, and concordance.
Results
A total of 71 students participated in the study. Three faculty raters had strong agreement on total scores (intraclass correlation coefficient=0.91). No bias was evident between total performance scores based on student self-rating (25±6 on a 10–40-point scale) or the mean faculty ratings (26±6, p=0.353), but correlation between faculty and student total ratings was low (r=0.26).
Conclusion
Students’ self-ratings were weakly correlated with faculty ratings, and were without evidence of systemic bias, suggesting the presence of both under- and over-estimation of suturing skill during self-assessment. Self-directed instruction and practice should be accompanied by faculty-guided practice and feedback.
Zitieren
APA
Srinivas, D., Gilbird, R., Bennett, J., Bilgrami, M., Pankey, S., Tumin, D., & Robey, W. (2025). Using a Self-Directed Learning Technique for Learning Suturing Skills: Does Medical Student Self-Assessment Agree with that of Faculty Observers?. Health Professions Education, 11(3). https://doi.org/10.55890/2452-3011.1354
Vancouver
Srinivas D, Gilbird R, Bennett J, Bilgrami M, Pankey S, Tumin D, et al. Using a Self-Directed Learning Technique for Learning Suturing Skills: Does Medical Student Self-Assessment Agree with that of Faculty Observers?. Health Professions Education. 2025;11(3). doi:10.55890/2452-3011.1354
BibTeX
@article{Srinivas2025,
author = {Srinivas, Divya and Gilbird, Rebecca and Bennett, Jennifer and Bilgrami, Mehdi and Pankey, Samuel and Tumin, Dmitry and Robey, Walter},
title = {Using a Self-Directed Learning Technique for Learning Suturing Skills: Does Medical Student Self-Assessment Agree with that of Faculty Observers?},
journal = {Health Professions Education},
year = {2025},
volume = {11},
number = {3},
doi = {10.55890/2452-3011.1354}
}
EUVIMED