A Quantitative Reconstruction of the Dialogic Structure of the Analects and the Standing of Its Questioners : An Exhaustive Coding of the 93 Questions Put to Confucius and a Two-Mode Network Analysis
Barun Academy of History · 31.10.2026 · 34 · 267-303
DOI: 10.55793/jkhc.2026.34.267 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Barun Academy of History, online erschienen am 31.10.2026. Verfasst von Sohyun Park.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The Analects records the exchanges between Confucius, his disciples and the rulers of his day. This study codes all 498 chapters (following Zhu Xi's chapter division) by utterance type and analyses the 93 chapters in which someone puts a question to Confucius, asking whose questions the text preserves and what they are about. The object of each question is taken from the text itself: for 63 chapters it is the object made explicit by the wen 問formula, and for the remaining 30 it is the core argument of the question predicate extracted by dependency parsing (UD-Kanbun) and matched against a fixed dictionary of seven topic groups. The rules were calibrated on the 63 explicit chapters (κ = .88) and checked against the restatements found in the commentaries of Huang Kan, Xing Bing and Zhu Xi. Dialogic chapters are concentrated in four books, Xianjin, Yan Yuan, Zilu and Xian wen, rather than in the second half of the text as a whole. What was asked of Confucius differs from what he said on his own: government and judgements of persons belong to the questions, learning and knowledge to the sayings (V=.31). Questioner type is significantly associated with question object (V=.40). Rulers concentrate on government, disciples range across virtue, judgements of persons, learning and conduct, and outsiders ask about ritual, persons and conduct; the contrast between disciples and rulers is confirmed on the axis of government, and since rulers also ask about filial piety and humaneness the difference is one of weight rather than exclusion. The association holds under alternative coding criteria and category constructions. The study thus shows that the dialogues of the Analects open a different range of questions to questioners of different standing, and offers a procedure for determining question objects from the text alone.
Zitieren
APA
Park, S. (2026). A Quantitative Reconstruction of the Dialogic Structure of the Analects and the Standing of Its Questioners : An Exhaustive Coding of the 93 Questions Put to Confucius and a Two-Mode Network Analysis. Barun Academy of History, 34, 267-303. https://doi.org/10.55793/jkhc.2026.34.267
Vancouver
Park S. A Quantitative Reconstruction of the Dialogic Structure of the Analects and the Standing of Its Questioners : An Exhaustive Coding of the 93 Questions Put to Confucius and a Two-Mode Network Analysis. Barun Academy of History. 2026;34:267-303. doi:10.55793/jkhc.2026.34.267
BibTeX
@article{Park2026,
author = {Park, Sohyun},
title = {A Quantitative Reconstruction of the Dialogic Structure of the Analects and the Standing of Its Questioners : An Exhaustive Coding of the 93 Questions Put to Confucius and a Two-Mode Network Analysis},
journal = {Barun Academy of History},
year = {2026},
volume = {34},
pages = {267--303},
doi = {10.55793/jkhc.2026.34.267}
}
EUVIMED