EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Two Horizons of the Methodology of Korean National Historiography: A Comparative Study of Sin Chae-ho's General Theory of Joseon Sanggosa and Han T'ae-dong's Methodology of History

Simon Kim

Barun Academy of History · 30.06.2026 · 32 · 253-276

DOI: 10.55793/jkhc.2026.32.253 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Barun Academy of History, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Simon Kim.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This paper aims to compare and analyze the nationalist historiographical methodology found in the general introduction to Sin Ch'ae-ho's (Tanjae) Joseon Sanggosa (Ancient History of Joseon) and the cognitive-structural historiographical methodology established by Han Tae-dong in his 1956 Princeton Theological Seminary doctoral dissertation and subsequent works, with the purpose of proposing a direction for overcoming the colonial view of history and establishing an academically justified Korean historical perspective. The study takes Yi Man-yŏl's scholarship on Tanjae's historiography as its primary academic reference. Sin Ch'ae-ho's theory of the “struggle between the self (我, a) and the other (非我, bia)” constitutes a practical methodology that negates the colonial view of history on the grounds of historical justice and declares the subjecthood of the Korean nation, with the particular strength of providing concrete guidelines for the reconstruction of historical sources. It is, however, relatively limited in its capacity for self-reflexive critique of the methodology itself. Han Tae-dong's cognitive-structural analysis, by contrast, functions as a meta-methodology that elucidates the epistemological foundations of historical writing and possesses the depth to critically examine the historian's entire cognitive framework, though it is not readily translatable into concrete practical guidelines for historical narration. The two methodologies are structurally complementary in their respective strengths: practical directionality on the one hand, and self-reflexive critical inquiry on the other. This paper argues that their dialectical integration provides the methodological foundation through which nationalist historiography can secure academic legitimacy without falling into new forms of dogmatism.

Zitieren

APA

Kim, S. (2026). Two Horizons of the Methodology of Korean National Historiography: A Comparative Study of Sin Chae-ho's General Theory of Joseon Sanggosa and Han T'ae-dong's Methodology of History. Barun Academy of History, 32, 253-276. https://doi.org/10.55793/jkhc.2026.32.253

Vancouver

Kim S. Two Horizons of the Methodology of Korean National Historiography: A Comparative Study of Sin Chae-ho's General Theory of Joseon Sanggosa and Han T'ae-dong's Methodology of History. Barun Academy of History. 2026;32:253-276. doi:10.55793/jkhc.2026.32.253

BibTeX
@article{Kim2026,
  author = {Kim, Simon},
  title = {Two Horizons of the Methodology of Korean National Historiography: A Comparative Study of Sin Chae-ho's General Theory of Joseon Sanggosa and Han T'ae-dong's Methodology of History},
  journal = {Barun Academy of History},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {32},
  pages = {253--276},
  doi = {10.55793/jkhc.2026.32.253}
}
Kostenlos starten →