Why Does Christmas Feel Sadder Over Time? An Economic—Relational Theory of the Christmas Paradox in Developing Societies
Journal of Economic Development, Innovation and Policy · 26.05.2026 · 2 (2) · 111-131
DOI: 10.55578/jedip.2605.007 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Economic Development, Innovation and Policy, online erschienen am 26.05.2026. Verfasst von Emmanuel A. Onsay.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Despite rising income and material abundance, many individuals report declining happiness during Christmas (Pasko), particularly in developing societies. This paper addresses this paradox by proposing the GAMAW–GAPOH Model (Pasko Paradox Model), a culturally grounded economic framework that reconceptualizes festive well-being as a balance between relational capital (GAMAW) and burdens and losses (GAPOH) rather than as an outcome of consumption alone. Departing from neoclassical utility theory, the model formally integrates social presence, cognitive burdens, and accumulated relational loss into a multidimensional utility function. Pasko Utility (PU) is specified as PU=αln(C)+βR-γB-δL, where Cdenotes consumption, Rrelational connectedness, Bcognitive burdens, and Laccumulated relational loss, with parameter restrictions β>αand δ≥γ. To operationalize festive well-being, the study introduces a normalized Pasko Contentment Index (PCI): PCI=R/(R+B+L)×ln(1+C), bounded between 0 and 1. Using 384 individuals from Lagonoy Gulf, Philippines, results show that while consumption increases monotonically across income groups, both PU and PCI peak at middle-income levels and decline sharply at higher income brackets. This decline is driven by weakened relational connectedness and rising work-related burdens and accumulated losses, which outweigh the diminishing marginal utility of increased consumption. Individuals in the highest income group exhibit the lowest PCI despite the highest festive spending. The findings demonstrate that Christmas functions as a relational public good, not a private consumption good. Festive well-being depends primarily on who is present, the weight of adult burdens, and the loss of important relationships, rather than on income or spending alone. The GAMAW–GAPOH Model thus offers a culturally sensitive and analytically rigorous explanation for declining festive happiness amid economic progress.
Zitieren
APA
Onsay, E. A. (2026). Why Does Christmas Feel Sadder Over Time? An Economic—Relational Theory of the Christmas Paradox in Developing Societies. Journal of Economic Development, Innovation and Policy, 2(2), 111-131. https://doi.org/10.55578/jedip.2605.007
Vancouver
Onsay EA. Why Does Christmas Feel Sadder Over Time? An Economic—Relational Theory of the Christmas Paradox in Developing Societies. Journal of Economic Development, Innovation and Policy. 2026;2(2):111-131. doi:10.55578/jedip.2605.007
BibTeX
@article{Onsay2026,
author = {Onsay, Emmanuel A.},
title = {Why Does Christmas Feel Sadder Over Time? An Economic—Relational Theory of the Christmas Paradox in Developing Societies},
journal = {Journal of Economic Development, Innovation and Policy},
year = {2026},
volume = {2},
number = {2},
pages = {111--131},
doi = {10.55578/jedip.2605.007}
}
EUVIMED