The Criminalisation of the Right to Protest in South Africa: Limiting Dissent in a Post-Apartheid Democratic State
Erasmus Law Review · 2025-12 · 18 (2) · 56-67
DOI: 10.5553/elr.2025.21 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Erasmus Law Review, 2025-12. Verfasst von Omhle Ntshingila und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The Criminalisation of the Right to Protest in South Africa: Limiting Dissent in a Post-Apartheid Democratic State The right to protest is the cornerstone of most democracies. With the recent rise in protest action and civil unrest in South Africa, brought about by a culmination of political developments and state failures, the state’s response has been to silence dissent through instructive tactics of repression designed to dictate the expression and execution of the right to protest. The contradiction is that the political situation in South Africa keeps deteriorating, causing weakness in state organs, which is slowly seeping into the judicial system, despite its ability to remain independent in post-apartheid South Africa. This is clearly demonstrated in contemporary issues currently posing a threat to the right to protest, such as strategic litigation against public participation (SLAPP), unlawful municipal by-laws and collusion between state and corporate actors against the principles of public participation. These dynamics are reminiscent of colonial and apartheid-era laws, where voices of dissent against a demonically oppressive legal system were fiercely suppressed. Legal mobilisation has and still plays a pivotal role in safeguarding the right to protest in South Africa, even as the political situation continues to challenge state institutions and public accountability. This presents a stark contrast between the law/theory set out in the Constitution and enabling legislation, versus the practical situation and enforcement of the law. This article, therefore, argues that such measures undermine democratic principles and the rule of law and concludes by setting out recommendations to avoid the erosion and decay of the principles of public participation. The right to protest is a cornerstone of democratic governance, sustaining accountability and adherence to the rule of law. In South Africa, however, a recent rise in protest and civil unrest – driven by political developments and state failures – has been met with repressive state responses aimed at silencing dissent and controlling the exercise of this right. At the same time, deteriorating political conditions and weakening state institutions increasingly affect the broader legal system, despite the judiciary’s post-apartheid tradition of independence. These tensions are reflected in contemporary threats to the right to protest, including strategic litigation against public participation, unlawful municipal by-laws, and collusion between state and corporate actors that undermine public participation as a constitutional principle. Such dynamics recall colonial and apartheid-era practices of suppressing dissent. While legal mobilisation continues to play a crucial role in protecting the right to protest, a stark gap remains between constitutional guarantees and their practical enforcement. The article argues that these developments undermine democratic principles and the rule of law, contributing to the gradual erosion of public participation. It concludes by offering recommendations to counter this trend and safeguard democratic freedoms. Overall, the article analyses and critiques the state of the right to protest in South Africa, highlighting the growing tension between constitutional protections and restrictive governmental responses.
Zitieren
APA
Ntshingila, O., & Mkhize, S. (2025). The Criminalisation of the Right to Protest in South Africa: Limiting Dissent in a Post-Apartheid Democratic State. Erasmus Law Review, 18(2), 56-67. https://doi.org/10.5553/elr.2025.21
Vancouver
Ntshingila O, Mkhize S. The Criminalisation of the Right to Protest in South Africa: Limiting Dissent in a Post-Apartheid Democratic State. Erasmus Law Review. 2025;18(2):56-67. doi:10.5553/elr.2025.21
BibTeX
@article{Ntshingila2025,
author = {Ntshingila, Omhle and Mkhize, Sithuthukile},
title = {The Criminalisation of the Right to Protest in South Africa: Limiting Dissent in a Post-Apartheid Democratic State},
journal = {Erasmus Law Review},
year = {2025},
volume = {18},
number = {2},
pages = {56--67},
doi = {10.5553/elr.2025.21}
}
EUVIMED