Judges, Speaking Of Death: Criminal Sentencing As A Socio-Cultural Practice In India’s Trial Courts
Socio-Legal Review · 2026 · 22 (1)
DOI: 10.55496/skqc8620 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Socio-Legal Review, 2026. Verfasst von Ashna Devaprasad.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
What role does language play in legitimising the exercise of judicial discretion during sentencing? And what can a judge’s linguistic choices tell us about the wider sentencing culture of a criminal justice system? Sentencing outcomes have long attracted considerable attention in criminal law scholarship, but the process of sentencing – the logics judges use, the narratives they construct, and the audiences they seek to persuade – has received much less empirical scrutiny. Building on ideas from “law and culture” and organisational sociology literature, this Article proposes studying sentencing as a “socio-cultural” practice; one that qualitatively examines the judicial function of “meaning-making.” Using 147 trial court judgements from death penalty cases in India decided between 2018 and 2020, I show how judges rely on various forms of justificatory rhetoric to externalise an image of fairness. In the process, they present contestable reasoning as legally sound, perform their version of a “just” outcome to multiple audiences, and lower the justificatory threshold in a sentencing framework already oriented toward punitive results. Situated in a Global South jurisdiction underrepresented in criminal law scholarship, this Article contributes to a growing body of interdisciplinary research on how punishment is enacted in non-Western legal systems. Administering capital punishment less arbitrarily (if at all possible) cannot happen without first interrogating a sentencer’s discursive logic and routines more closely. Left unchecked, judges’ meaning-making practices risk reproducing arbitrariness, diminishing institutional accountability, and dangerously legitimising the state’s most extreme exercise of legal authority: to take a human life.
Zitieren
APA
Devaprasad, A. (2026). Judges, Speaking Of Death: Criminal Sentencing As A Socio-Cultural Practice In India’s Trial Courts. Socio-Legal Review, 22(1). https://doi.org/10.55496/skqc8620
Vancouver
Devaprasad A. Judges, Speaking Of Death: Criminal Sentencing As A Socio-Cultural Practice In India’s Trial Courts. Socio-Legal Review. 2026;22(1). doi:10.55496/skqc8620
BibTeX
@article{Devaprasad2026,
author = {Devaprasad, Ashna},
title = {Judges, Speaking Of Death: Criminal Sentencing As A Socio-Cultural Practice In India’s Trial Courts},
journal = {Socio-Legal Review},
year = {2026},
volume = {22},
number = {1},
doi = {10.55496/skqc8620}
}
EUVIMED