Indian Position on Undervalued Transactions: Analysing the ‘Material Facts’ Required to be Pleaded and Proved
National Law School Business Law Review · 2025
DOI: 10.55496/ifgg5868 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift National Law School Business Law Review, 2025. Verfasst von Malak Sheth.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Companies approaching insolvency often transfer key assets at undervalued rates, potentially to the detriment of creditors. Therefore, to remain true to its purpose of value maximization for the creditors, insolvency laws in general and the IBC, in particular, contain provisions to claw back the assets so transferred for inadequate or no consideration under section 45 (‘undervalued transactions’). However, a quick review of the scheme for avoiding undervalued transactions in the IBC reveals that adequate balancing measures to differentiate between the depletion of assets arising from genuine business cycles and those caused by malfeasance have not been implemented. In fact, the principles enshrined in globally respected sources for national legislations, such as the UNCITRAL and the World Bank Guides, have not been given due consideration. In this backdrop, the Supreme Court’s mandate in Anuj Jain, IRP for Jaypee Infratech Ltd. v. Axis Bank Ltd to ‘plead’ and ‘prove’ material facts’ —a term not defined by the Court—for impugning undervalued transactions allows for some play in the joints to rectify this legislative omission. The present article aims to posit the possible content of 'material facts' that are to be pleaded under Section 45 of the IBC by drawing on a comparative analysis of laws from the United Kingdom, Canada, the United States of America, and Singapore. Finally, based on this analysis, it would be recommended that the status of the company as solvent during the alleged undervalued transaction, the role of the transaction in the insolvency of the company, and the debtor’s intent are the ‘material facts’ that must be considered by the tribunals.
Zitieren
APA
Sheth, M. (2025). Indian Position on Undervalued Transactions: Analysing the ‘Material Facts’ Required to be Pleaded and Proved. National Law School Business Law Review. https://doi.org/10.55496/ifgg5868
Vancouver
Sheth M. Indian Position on Undervalued Transactions: Analysing the ‘Material Facts’ Required to be Pleaded and Proved. National Law School Business Law Review. 2025. doi:10.55496/ifgg5868
BibTeX
@article{Sheth2025,
author = {Sheth, Malak},
title = {Indian Position on Undervalued Transactions: Analysing the ‘Material Facts’ Required to be Pleaded and Proved},
journal = {National Law School Business Law Review},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.55496/ifgg5868}
}
EUVIMED