Warranty Liability for Defects in Condominium Buildings: Issues of Statutes of Limitations and Legislative Reform
Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law · 30.05.2026 · 58 · 203-228
DOI: 10.55029/kabl.2026.58.203 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law, online erschienen am 30.05.2026. Verfasst von NAJIN CHOI.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The warranty liability imposed upon developers under Article 9 of the Korean Act on the Ownership and Management of Condominium Buildings (the “Condominium Buildings Act”) is generally understood as a statutory liability established by law rather than a contractual liability arising from a sales agreement. Accordingly, claims for damages arising from such liability are subject to the ten-year statute of limitations under Article 162(1) of the Korean Civil Act. This framework reflects the mandatory and protective nature of Article 9, which is intended to safeguard unit owners by maintaining the developer’s liability over an extended period. By contrast, a developer’s right of recourse against a contractor is generally characterized as a commercial claim arising from a construction contract and is therefore subject to the five-year statute of limitations prescribed by Article 64 of the Korean Commercial Act. Korean courts generally regard the limitation period for such claims as commencing upon the occurrence of the defect. Consequently, a dual limitation structure arises in which different limitation periods apply to liabilities originating from the same defect. Such asymmetry may create a structural imbalance in the allocation of liability between developers and contractors. This article examines the practical implications of this asymmetrical structure through an analysis of the Seoul Central District Court decision rendered on February 19, 2020 (2018Gahap547861). The case demonstrates that, with respect to defects existing prior to the approval for use, the commencement of the statute of limitations may effectively be linked to the date of approval for use, thereby creating a situation in which the contractor’s liability becomes time-barred while the developer remains exposed to ongoing liability arising from claims brought by unit owners. Korean case law has consistently held that, in indemnity claims arising from joint tort liability, the statute of limitations begins to run when the indemnifying party actually compensates the injured party. However, this principle has not been extended to recourse claims arising from contractual warranty liability under construction contracts. One possible interpretive approach would be to recognize a special rule under which the statute of limitations for the developer’s recourse claim commences upon actual compensation to unit owners. Nevertheless, interpretive solutions alone may not adequately resolve the structural inconsistency. If the contractor’s contractual warranty liability has already become time-barred under the Commercial Act before such compensation is made, the developer’s recourse claim may likewise become unenforceable. As a legislative solution, this article proposes introducing a special provision into Article 9 of the Condominium Buildings Act providing that, notwithstanding Article 64 of the Commercial Act, the contractor’s warranty liability to the developer shall also be governed by the ten-year statute of limitations prescribed in Article 162(1) of the Civil Act. Since the Condominium Buildings Act already functions as a special statute that independently establishes exclusion periods under Article 9-2, adopting a corresponding special rule concerning limitation periods may further enhance legislative coherence and systematic consistency. Ultimately, this study suggests that the existing dual limitation structure warrants reconsideration in order to achieve a more balanced allocation of liability between developers and contractors while preserving the protective function of the Condominium Buildings Act.
Zitieren
APA
CHOI, N. (2026). Warranty Liability for Defects in Condominium Buildings: Issues of Statutes of Limitations and Legislative Reform. Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law, 58, 203-228. https://doi.org/10.55029/kabl.2026.58.203
Vancouver
CHOI N. Warranty Liability for Defects in Condominium Buildings: Issues of Statutes of Limitations and Legislative Reform. Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law. 2026;58:203-228. doi:10.55029/kabl.2026.58.203
BibTeX
@article{CHOI2026,
author = {CHOI, NAJIN},
title = {Warranty Liability for Defects in Condominium Buildings: Issues of Statutes of Limitations and Legislative Reform},
journal = {Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {58},
pages = {203--228},
doi = {10.55029/kabl.2026.58.203}
}
EUVIMED