Issues Concerning the Management and Common Elements of Mixed-Use Condominiums : Focusing on the Determination of Limited Common Elements and Their Management Bodies
Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law · 30.05.2026 · 58 · 103-139
DOI: 10.55029/kabl.2026.58.103 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law, online erschienen am 30.05.2026. Verfasst von Min-ju Kim.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper examines legal issues surrounding the management of mixed-use condominiums in Korean law, focusing on two interrelated problems: the determination of the scope of limited common elements and the establishment of their management bodies. In mixed-use condominiums — where residential units, commercial spaces, and offices coexist within a single building or complex — disputes over the management of common elements such as parking facilities, staircases, and rooftops arise with considerable frequency. This paper locates the structural cause of such disputes in a cyclical deadlock produced by the combination of two factors: the absence of guidelines suited to the management of mixed-use condominiums, and the voluntary establishment principle governing sub-associations for limited common elements under Article 23(2) of the Korean Act on the Ownership and Management of Condominium Buildings (hereinafter “KCA”). Building on this diagnosis, the paper first analyzes the criteria for determining limited common elements under Korean case law, and identifies a recent trend among lower courts toward a stricter interpretation of the statutory “obviousness” requirement, driven in part by concerns over the fragmentation of decision-making authority. It then reviews the standard management rules promulgated by the Ministry of Justice and regional governments, revealing that no existing model provides formats applicable to mixed-use condominiums or criteria for delineating limited common elements. The paper further examines the establishment requirements for sub-associations, demonstrating that the combination of substantive and procedural conditions — the obviousness of limited common elements, a three-fourths supermajority resolution, and the adoption of separate bylaws — operates as an independent barrier to forming a management body even where the scope of limited common elements has been determined. As a comparative reference, the paper turns to Japanese law. The Mixed-Use Type Standard Management Rules issued by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism classify common elements into three categories — whole-building common elements, residential limited common elements, and commercial limited common elements — specifying their concrete scope in annexed schedules and standardizing cost-sharing formulas accordingly. Article 3 of the Japanese Act on Building Unit Ownership adopts the principle of establishment by operation of law for both the whole-building owners’ association and the sub-association for limited common elements, requiring no separate constitutive act. The paper confirms that this combination of mandatory establishment and detailed standard rules has effectively forestalled disputes over the very existence of sub-associations, redirecting litigation toward questions of cost allocation. On the basis of this analysis, the paper offers proposals at two levels. At the interpretive level, it proposes that the sub-association for limited common elements be characterized as a partnership-type entity subordinate to the whole-building owners’ association. Such a characterization does not produce decisive differences from the unincorporated association theory in terms of representative authority, standing to sue, or property attribution, yet it carries practical significance in clarifying the allocation of liabilities and the distribution of management costs for limited common elements. At the legislative level, the paper proposes, first, the introduction of a mixed-use category in the standard management rules under Articles 28(4) and 28(5) of the KCA, and second, a conditional shift toward mandatory establishment of sub-associations limited to cases where the scope of limited common elements has been predetermined through standard management rules or bylaws.
Zitieren
APA
Kim, M. (2026). Issues Concerning the Management and Common Elements of Mixed-Use Condominiums : Focusing on the Determination of Limited Common Elements and Their Management Bodies. Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law, 58, 103-139. https://doi.org/10.55029/kabl.2026.58.103
Vancouver
Kim M. Issues Concerning the Management and Common Elements of Mixed-Use Condominiums : Focusing on the Determination of Limited Common Elements and Their Management Bodies. Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law. 2026;58:103-139. doi:10.55029/kabl.2026.58.103
BibTeX
@article{Kim2026,
author = {Kim, Min-ju},
title = {Issues Concerning the Management and Common Elements of Mixed-Use Condominiums : Focusing on the Determination of Limited Common Elements and Their Management Bodies},
journal = {Korean Institute for Aggregate Buildings Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {58},
pages = {103--139},
doi = {10.55029/kabl.2026.58.103}
}
EUVIMED