Westgard Rules versus Sigma Metrics: Which Better Reflects Analytical Quality? — A Comparative Review
ICME JOURNAL OF LABORATORY MEDICINE · 2026 · 16-22
DOI: 10.54646/icme.2026.15 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift ICME JOURNAL OF LABORATORY MEDICINE, 2026. Verfasst von Anush Nazar und 3 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
Internal quality control (IQC) underpins the analytical reliability of laboratory results. Westgard multirule QC and Six Sigma metrics are the two dominant frameworks used to evaluate analytical quality, yet they are frequently, and inaccurately, presented as competing alternatives rather than as tools that answer fundamentally different questions.
Objective
To critically compare Westgard Rules and Sigma Metrics as reflections of analytical quality, and to determine whether either framework, alone, adequately captures it. Main findings: Across precision, accuracy, total analytical error, error-detection capability, false rejection, cost, automation and applicability, the two frameworks address complementary rather than overlapping dimensions of quality. Sigma metrics quantify the inherent analytical capability of a method relative to a defined total allowable error (TEa), enabling cross-laboratory benchmarking and evidence-based allocation of quality-control resource, but cannot themselves detect an out-of-control run. Westgard Rules provide real-time, run-level monitoring with a well-characterised statistical basis, but applied uniformly across a test menu they are statistically inefficient, over-controlling high-capability methods and under-controlling poor ones. Published evidence, spanning clinical chemistry, haematology, coagulation and blood-gas analysis, consistently shows that Sigma-based selection of Westgard rules, control frequency and control numbers improves the efficiency and defensibility of IQC programmes, while unresolved variability in TEa sources continues to limit cross-study comparability.
Conclusion
Neither Westgard Rules nor Sigma Metrics alone fully reflects analytical quality. Sigma metrics evaluate what a method is capable of; Westgard Rules monitor whether that capability is being sustained from day to day. The strongest evidence, and current international guidance, supports their integration within a risk-based quality control plan rather than treating either as a stand-alone indicator of quality.
Zitieren
APA
Nazar, A., William, S., Thomas, R., & Anush, J. (2026). Westgard Rules versus Sigma Metrics: Which Better Reflects Analytical Quality? — A Comparative Review. ICME JOURNAL OF LABORATORY MEDICINE, 16-22. https://doi.org/10.54646/icme.2026.15
Vancouver
Nazar A, William S, Thomas R, Anush J. Westgard Rules versus Sigma Metrics: Which Better Reflects Analytical Quality? — A Comparative Review. ICME JOURNAL OF LABORATORY MEDICINE. 2026:16-22. doi:10.54646/icme.2026.15
BibTeX
@article{Nazar2026,
author = {Nazar, Anush and William, Simi and Thomas, Rajesh and Anush, Jasmin},
title = {Westgard Rules versus Sigma Metrics: Which Better Reflects Analytical Quality? — A Comparative Review},
journal = {ICME JOURNAL OF LABORATORY MEDICINE},
year = {2026},
pages = {16--22},
doi = {10.54646/icme.2026.15}
}
EUVIMED