EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Hopa lide

Jana Belišová

Ethnomusicology · 01.07.2026 · 70 (2) · 327-329

DOI: 10.5406/21567417.70.2.13 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Ethnomusicology, online erschienen am 01.07.2026. Verfasst von Jana Belišová.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitieren

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Hopa lide is a film directed by Czech visual ethnomusicologist Petr Nuska—an interdisciplinary researcher working at the intersection of anthropology, visual studies, and musicology. Nuska holds a doctorate in ethnomusicology and visual culture from Durham University (2022), where he focused on the musicality of the Roma in Slovakia. Currently based at the Institute of Ethnology and Social Anthropology of the Slovak Academy of Sciences, his work aims to merge academic research with visual storytelling, with a particular emphasis on collaboration with the studied communities. He has made several documentary films, including Hopa lide (2023), which was screened at eight international film festivals and received an honorable mention from the International Council for Traditions of Music and Dance Documentary Film or Video Prize in 2024.Hopa lide offers an original contribution to contemporary visual anthropology and ethnomusicology. This ethnographic film follows the process of shooting three music videos featuring Roma musicians from the Gemer region in Slovakia. In his film, the musicians actively participate in the creation of the clips therefore moving beyond more traditional modes of observational filmmaking and instead taking on the character of participatory research.Gemer is a musically distinctive region situated between eastern Slovakia, where Roma musicians predominantly play for their own audiences, and central Slovakia, where the performance of Slovak folklore has a strong tradition. Hopa lide does not present a homogeneous picture of Roma culture in Slovakia; rather, it portrays only a few of its many expressions. Regional specificities, social affiliation with the middle class, and music as a form of gainful activity are what the musicians featured in the film's chapters have in common, but they differ in their relationships to traditional Roma music, Slovak folk music, and popular music.The film is divided into three parts, each focused on a different artist. The first part follows Barna and his son Martin. While Martin earns his livelihood performing on cruise ships in the Netherlands and Germany, Barna prepares at home a musical video of his favorite song by Freddie Mercury, “I Want to Break Free,” for which he wrote the lyrics in Romani and Slovak. Although the father and son come from a musical family, they do not identify with the Roma musical tradition. While listening to jazz, Barna declares, “This is our music! We don't like Roma songs.”The second part introduces the young dulcimer player Dalibor, who comes from a background with a long-standing tradition of performing Slovak folk music. Dalibor represents a younger generation of Roma musicians seeking to bridge the boundaries between traditional and modern music. Philosophical and spiritual motifs appear in his reflections—for example, his belief that “faith turns fear into a voice” and his desire to bring joy to people through music. He also distinguishes between gig work and concerts. While gig work requires musicians to play everything (and he “never wants to be put to shame”), concerts are, for him, a space of creativity, where he incorporates elements of jazz and other genres.The third part focuses on Vladimír, a singer, musician, organizer, and activist who has evolved from a regional “wedding musician” into an internationally recognized figure, whose charisma and talent have helped many other Roma, especially musicians, from the region. His dynamic personality is also reflected in the film's rhythm: the swaying camera, jump cuts, and apparent chaos mirror his dynamic lifestyle. Vladimír has extensive performance experience both in Slovakia and abroad and has appeared previously as a protagonist in several film projects, for example, with director Jaro Vojtek in Cigáni idú do volieb (Gypsies go to the polls) (2012), Malá domov (Little home) (2008), and the nine-part road movie series Sendreiovci (The Sendreis) (2006). Vladimír is proof that talent, diligence, and determination can transcend regional boundaries and stereotypes.The most striking feature of the film is its participatory and reflexive character. Its reflexive dimension lies in its acknowledgment of the filmmaking process itself—the camera is visible and acknowledged and sometimes interacts directly with the protagonists. The participatory aspect, meanwhile, is evident in the musicians’ active involvement in determining how they are filmed and in shaping the conception of particular scenes. Thus, the film becomes a dialogue about representation and not merely the product of it.The use of natural lighting (candles, lamps, spotlights) enhances the intimacy of the setting and the atmosphere of the musicians’ everyday lives. The composition frequently juxtaposes domestic or informal spaces with public stages, thus visually contrasting private and public life. The editing is rhythmically shaped according to the musical sequences. Long, unbroken takes allow the music to unfold as a process rather than functioning merely as illustration. The audio track preserves so-called “ethnographic impurities”—microphone noise, the performers’ breathing, and camera movements. These elements are not technical flaws but deliberate traces of reality that contextualize the environment.Hopa lide may be interpreted as a visual form of research, as a cinematic window into the everyday lives of musicians. Director Nuska applies a modern ethnographic approach that rejects the traditional model of the camera as a window into culture and instead foregrounds the interaction between researcher and community. In interviews, such as one with Jana Gombošová, published in November 2025 in the online publication Romano forum, the director has noted that in an era of accelerated academic production influenced by artificial intelligence tools, visual forms of research acquire new value. Film, as an output of ethnographic inquiry, can convey knowledge in ways that text cannot—through emotional and sensory experience.Despite its undeniable qualities, the film has certain limitations. A viewer unaware that the project's aim was to produce music videos may not immediately infer this from the film itself. The degree to which the work can be described as collaborative is also debatable. The protagonists are codirectors of their individual clips but not of the film as a whole. A similar approach can be observed in other Slovak documentaries, for example, Zvonky šťastia (Bells of happiness) (2012), directed by Marek Šulík and Jana Bučka, in which a Roma couple films a video message for their favorite singers.The film's improvisatory style and the disorderliness of some of its sequences lend it a distinctive feel, enabling viewers to immerse themselves fully in the atmosphere of particular scenes and environments. At times, however, they may lose the narrative thread. Such an ethnographic approach may present challenges for a broader audience, but it will undoubtedly appeal to ethnomusicologists and anthropologists.Hopa lide represents a contribution to contemporary documentary filmmaking and visual ethnomusicology. It is characterized by methodological innovation and by its effort to transcend traditional models of minority representation. Here, the musicians are not passive objects of study but active cocreators of their own cinematic image.Nuska's film may thus be understood as an interdisciplinary experiment at the intersection of film, music, and anthropology. It will be of particular interest to audiences and researchers concerned with musical culture, ethnomusicology, minority studies, and nonmainstream documentary cinema. It is a work that demands focus and openness to a less linear and more reflective film form.

Zitieren

APA

Belišová, J. (2026). Hopa lide. Ethnomusicology, 70(2), 327-329. https://doi.org/10.5406/21567417.70.2.13

Vancouver

Belišová J. Hopa lide. Ethnomusicology. 2026;70(2):327-329. doi:10.5406/21567417.70.2.13

BibTeX
@article{Beliov2026,
  author = {Belišová, Jana},
  title = {Hopa lide},
  journal = {Ethnomusicology},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {70},
  number = {2},
  pages = {327--329},
  doi = {10.5406/21567417.70.2.13}
}
Kostenlos starten →