How to Use Examples in Philosophy: A Response to Paul C. Taylor
Journal of Aesthetic Education · 01.09.2026 · 60 (3) · 106-115
DOI: 10.5406/15437809.60.3.07 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Aesthetic Education, online erschienen am 01.09.2026. Verfasst von Vid Simoniti.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
What are the limits of philosophers’ uses (and abuses) of real-world examples? Paul C. Taylor has criticized my theory of socially engaged art by alleging that I have misdescribed one of the artworks that I use as an example. In this reply, I develop a view about how philosophers should use examples to illustrate our theories. I argue that our use of examples should abide by the criteria of accuracy (we should not misrepresent the examples) and of relevance (the problems that examples are used to illustrate should be implicit in the actual practices surrounding the example). However, I argue that philosophers need not also abide by the criterion of complexity (we need not examine all the possibly relevant aspects of an example). It is the philosopher's prerogative to isolate only some aspects of complex phenomena, to force phenomena into a distilled form. Finally, since my theory of socially engaged art abides by the first two criteria, I argue that it is immune to Taylor's objections.
Zitieren
APA
Simoniti, V. (2026). How to Use Examples in Philosophy: A Response to Paul C. Taylor. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 60(3), 106-115. https://doi.org/10.5406/15437809.60.3.07
Vancouver
Simoniti V. How to Use Examples in Philosophy: A Response to Paul C. Taylor. Journal of Aesthetic Education. 2026;60(3):106-115. doi:10.5406/15437809.60.3.07
BibTeX
@article{Simoniti2026,
author = {Simoniti, Vid},
title = {How to Use Examples in Philosophy: A Response to Paul C. Taylor},
journal = {Journal of Aesthetic Education},
year = {2026},
volume = {60},
number = {3},
pages = {106--115},
doi = {10.5406/15437809.60.3.07}
}
EUVIMED