Recalibrating Takāful’s Compass to Mālikī Sources: Revisiting Classical Proofs for Modern Claims
Journal of Islamic Law · 2026-06 · 7
DOI: 10.53484/jil.v7.afridi ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Islamic Law, 2026-06. Verfasst von Habiba Afridi.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article revisits the tabarruʿ (donative) versus muʿāwaḍa (onerous/reciprocal exchange) distinction in the Mālikī school—a widely invoked justificatory frame for takāful (Islamic insurance)—and examines how far that distinction transposes to takāful’s constitutive contract. It traces the reception history and excavates its classical origins, bringing to light three overlooked insights: al-Qarāfī’s three-feature gharar (uncertainty) test for exchange contracts, Mālik’s tripartite taxonomy of legal dispositions, and his rationale for tolerating gharar in gratuitous contracts. The argument starts with an orientation that surfaces the paradigm-level assumptions and disciplinary priorities often latent in takāful’s doctrinal-technical debates and clarifies the article’s scope and methodological limits. It then proceeds to a logical deconstruction of the received dichotomy, then to a reconstruction of its reception pathway, and finally to a close reading of its classical Mālikī sources. Engaging al-Qarāfī’s Distinction 24 (the standard reference point for the issue) together with the canonical Mālikī text al-Mudawwana, the article proposes a constructive recalibration: shifting discourse away from a rigid, label-driven tabarruʿ–muʿāwaḍa binary toward Mālik’s tripartite scheme, guided by al-Qarāfī’s three features and more faithful to the Islamic moral-juristic economy.
Zitieren
APA
Afridi, H. (2026). Recalibrating Takāful’s Compass to Mālikī Sources: Revisiting Classical Proofs for Modern Claims. Journal of Islamic Law, 7. https://doi.org/10.53484/jil.v7.afridi
Vancouver
Afridi H. Recalibrating Takāful’s Compass to Mālikī Sources: Revisiting Classical Proofs for Modern Claims. Journal of Islamic Law. 2026;7. doi:10.53484/jil.v7.afridi
BibTeX
@article{Afridi2026,
author = {Afridi, Habiba},
title = {Recalibrating Takāful’s Compass to Mālikī Sources: Revisiting Classical Proofs for Modern Claims},
journal = {Journal of Islamic Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {7},
doi = {10.53484/jil.v7.afridi}
}
EUVIMED