Responsive Judicial Review and J.H. Ely in the “Bed of Procrustes”
Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho · 2026
DOI: 10.5347/64/2026/893 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho, 2026. Verfasst von Leonardo García Jaramillo. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Judicial review has proven to be an empowering device for minorities, enabling the articulation of their claims through constitutional language and compelling majorities to debate the merits of such claims. To capture contemporary threats to democratic responsiveness, Dixon's responsive judicial review model builds on Ely’s political process, grounding judicial review in procedural enhancement and reinforced political representation. This article does not seek to critique Ely’s updated framework as a justification for weak or strong judicial review. Instead, it explores whether this model can provide a normative foundation for the urgently required responsive judicial review in Global South democracies. Despite well-considered cases and examples from the Global South —a commendable rarity in the parochial Global North literature in the field— Dixon's model does not adequately characterize and normatively justify an exceptionally activist form of judicial review capable of addressing structural problems. In democracies with profound dysfunctions, the rationale for judicial review is rooted in systemic failures in public policy, a lack of institutional coordination, chronic budgetary insufficiency, and prolonged inaction by authorities to adopt necessary measures. The “Procrustean bed” metaphor illustrates the process of testing a model's portability in the Global South as Dixon intends to do with Ely's normative but minimal approach to judicial review. The predictive and explanatory potential of political and constitutional theories depends on specific political and social realities and constitutional history.
Zitieren
APA
Jaramillo, L. G. (2026). Responsive Judicial Review and J.H. Ely in the “Bed of Procrustes”. Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho. https://doi.org/10.5347/64/2026/893
Vancouver
Jaramillo LG. Responsive Judicial Review and J.H. Ely in the “Bed of Procrustes”. Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho. 2026. doi:10.5347/64/2026/893
BibTeX
@article{Jaramillo2026,
author = {Jaramillo, Leonardo García},
title = {Responsive Judicial Review and J.H. Ely in the “Bed of Procrustes”},
journal = {Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.5347/64/2026/893}
}
EUVIMED