Radbruch Revisited: Coping with Injustice in Post-Conflict Societies
Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho · 30.06.2026 · (64) · 122-144
DOI: 10.5347/64/2026/872 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Knut Seidel. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article revisits Gustav Radbruch’s famous formula in the context of transitional justice, with a comparative focus on Germany and Argentina. It argues that the formula, although theoretically inconsistent and not coherently derivable from Radbruch’s own relativist legal philosophy, has proven highly functional in judicial practice. German jurisprudence after 1945 and 1989, as well as the Argentine Supreme Court’s landmark decisions in Simón (2005) and Mazzeo (2007), illustrate how Radbruch’s insight – that extremely unjust law cannot claim validity – provides an argumentative bridge between legal certainty and substantive justice. The article develops a comparative structural analysis: German courts relied explicitly on Radbruch’s threshold of “intolerable injustice,” while the Argentine Corte Suprema reached functionally equivalent results through the doctrine of ius cogens. Both lines of reasoning show that post-conflict societies require normative categories to deny recognition to formally valid norms that violate fundamental justice. Philosophically, the formula oscillates between relativism and natural law, between positivism and idealism. Its logical inconsistencies are undeniable, yet courts have applied it responsibly and with restraint. The formula’s enduring significance lies less in theoretical coherence than in its practical capacity to preserve judicial sensitivity to the moral limits of law. Unlike more systematic theories – such as those of Kelsen, Hart, or even Habermas – Radbruch’s fragment endures as a pragmatic tool, a reminder, and a challenge. In this sense, the “philosophical rubble” of Radbruch’s formula remains an indispensable resource for judges confronted with law’s darkest failures.
Zitieren
APA
Seidel, K. (2026). Radbruch Revisited: Coping with Injustice in Post-Conflict Societies. Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho, 122-144. https://doi.org/10.5347/64/2026/872
Vancouver
Seidel K. Radbruch Revisited: Coping with Injustice in Post-Conflict Societies. Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho. 2026:122-144. doi:10.5347/64/2026/872
BibTeX
@article{Seidel2026,
author = {Seidel, Knut},
title = {Radbruch Revisited: Coping with Injustice in Post-Conflict Societies},
journal = {Isonomía - Revista de teoría y filosofía del derecho},
year = {2026},
number = {64},
pages = {122--144},
doi = {10.5347/64/2026/872}
}
EUVIMED