More than one way to free choice: A view from child Romanian
Proceedings of the Amsterdam Colloquium · 01.12.2024 · 36-43
DOI: 10.53437/ykgyc608 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Proceedings of the Amsterdam Colloquium, online erschienen am 01.12.2024. Verfasst von Adina Camelia Bleotu und 6 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Studies show that children draw from modalized disjunctive statements of the structure X is allowed to do P or Q (♢(P ∨Q)) a Free Choice (FC) inference, namely X is allowed to do P and X is allowed to do Q (♢P ∧♢Q). Their ability to compute free choice inferences is surprising in light of their well-known difficulties with scalar implicatures involving non modalized disjunction (Tieu, Romoli, et al. 2016), particularly on accounts that unify free choice inferences and scalar implicatures (e.g., Kratzer and Shimoyama 2002; Chierchia 2013). Recent work by Cochard, van Hout, and Demirdache (2024b), however, argues that some children only seemingly derive free choice: these children actually interpret ♢(P ∨Q) as ♢(P ∧Q), which follows from their conjunctive understanding of non-modalized disjunction. In the present study, we extend the investigation by comparing the same children’s performance on non-modalized and modalized utterances in Romanian, an understudied language. Specifically, we tested the same group of 5-year-old monolingual Romanian-speaking children and adult controls, balanced for order. Our findings provide partial evidence for Cochard, van Hout, and Demirdache (2024b)’s hypothesis: some children were inclusive with non-modalized disjunction, and appeared to derive genuine free choice on the free choice task, while some children indeed exhibited conjunctive interpretations in both tasks.
Zitieren
APA
Bleotu, A. C., Panaitescu, M., Cremers, A., Nicolae, A., Benz, A., Bîlbîie, G., & Tieu, L. (2024). More than one way to free choice: A view from child Romanian. Proceedings of the Amsterdam Colloquium, 36-43. https://doi.org/10.53437/ykgyc608
Vancouver
Bleotu AC, Panaitescu M, Cremers A, Nicolae A, Benz A, Bîlbîie G, et al. More than one way to free choice: A view from child Romanian. Proceedings of the Amsterdam Colloquium. 2024:36-43. doi:10.53437/ykgyc608
BibTeX
@article{Bleotu2024,
author = {Bleotu, Adina Camelia and Panaitescu, Mara and Cremers, Alexandre and Nicolae, Andreea and Benz, Anton and Bîlbîie, Gabriela and Tieu, Lyn},
title = {More than one way to free choice: A view from child Romanian},
journal = {Proceedings of the Amsterdam Colloquium},
year = {2024},
pages = {36--43},
doi = {10.53437/ykgyc608}
}
EUVIMED