From Action to Reflection - Designing Video-Assisted Debriefings for Simulation-Based Mountain Rescue Training
University of Regensburg Publication Server (University of Regensburg) · 13.10.2026
DOI: 10.5283/epub.80917 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift University of Regensburg Publication Server (University of Regensburg), erschienen am 13.10.2026. Verfasst von Stefan A. Schreder.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Simulation-based training (SBT) gives mountain rescuers a safe way to prepare for complex and potentially rare emergencies. However, participating in simulations alone does not guarantee learning. Debriefings are needed to transition from the simulated experience to an opportunity for feedback and reflective discussion. Previous research has shown that without debriefing, learners achieved significantly worse learning outcomes. Despite the established educational significance, questions remain regarding the focus and form of debriefings. This dissertation addresses this gap by examining what aspects of and influences on simulation performance should receive attention during debriefing, and to identify and implement the most promising debriefing approach in the context of the Bavarian mountain rescue organisation. A total of three complementary empirical studies were conducted: a quantitative study examining factors connected to simulated resuscitation performance (Study 1), a qualitative study comparing experiences with verbal and video-assisted debriefing (Study 2), and a design-based research study developing and evaluating a context-sensitive implementation of video-assisted debriefing (Study 3). The first major contribution of the dissertation concerns the content and focus of debriefing. Study 1 showed that resuscitation performance in mountain rescue cannot be reduced to a single performance dimension. Technical and non-technical performance were not significantly related, and previous experience was not consistently associated with better performance. Mountain rescuers were also not fully able to correctly assess their colleagues’ performance during the simulation. These findings indicate that technical and non-technical skills may need to be treated as separate points of reflection and that previous experiences should rather be used as reference points to recontextualise the simulated experience than dependable indicators of competence. A second contribution lies in demonstrating the potential and challenges of video-assisted debriefing. Study 2 showed that the video-assisted debriefing approach was favoured by both participants and facilitators, as it provided an objective, external perspective on the simulation, thus supporting the reconstruction of events and team processes during debriefing. However, with the possibility of having mistakes displayed prominently on screen, participants also reported negative effects such as stress and impacts on their behaviour. The third and last contribution concerns the implementation of video-assisted debriefing within the context of mountain rescue training. Study 3 identified three recurring challenges for facilitators: ensuring psychological safety, operating the video-assisted debriefing technology, and managing the cognitive demands associated with the new debriefing approach. These challenges were addressed as part of the design-based research approach, with iteratively developed scaffolds reducing cognitive demands, providing structure and helping with the establishment of psychological safety. Participants of the video-assisted debriefing reported a significant decrease in stress after debriefing and rated the perceived debriefing quality as consistently high. The results illustrate that a context-sensitive implementation can work with the targeted support of facilitators, without the need for large structural changes. Overall, this dissertation strengthens the basis for improving SBT within the specialised field of mountain rescue organisations. The combined findings indicate that debriefing practice can be advanced through an integrated consideration of content, approach, and implementation. Although grounded in mountain rescue, the gained insights can also provide useful guidance for other voluntary rescue organisations facing similar training and organisational challenges.
Zitieren
APA
Schreder, S. A. (2026). From Action to Reflection - Designing Video-Assisted Debriefings for Simulation-Based Mountain Rescue Training. University of Regensburg Publication Server (University of Regensburg). https://doi.org/10.5283/epub.80917
Vancouver
Schreder SA. From Action to Reflection - Designing Video-Assisted Debriefings for Simulation-Based Mountain Rescue Training. University of Regensburg Publication Server (University of Regensburg). 2026. doi:10.5283/epub.80917
BibTeX
@article{Schreder2026,
author = {Schreder, Stefan A.},
title = {From Action to Reflection - Designing Video-Assisted Debriefings for Simulation-Based Mountain Rescue Training},
journal = {University of Regensburg Publication Server (University of Regensburg)},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.5283/epub.80917}
}
EUVIMED