To Defend American Innovation from Foreign Espionage, Amend the Patent Disclosure Timeline
Science and Technology Law Review · 10.11.2026
DOI: 10.52214/ewzxs559 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Science and Technology Law Review, online erschienen am 10.11.2026. Verfasst von Lorenzo Battaglia. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In an interview with Stanford University’s Hoover Institution earlier this year, Anduril founder Palmer Luckey suggested that the patent system may be actively undermining the United States’ economic security and technological leadership over China. “Patents are Chinese instruction manuals,” he told the interviewer, and the way to prevent China from stealing innovations is to “stop patenting everything.” In our globalized economy, the “entire patent office [can] be downloaded every single morning and then ripped off, [and] used to fight a war against you.” What a U.S. patent “practically means,” he continued, “is that … China can rip it off right away, and western companies can only rip it off after 20 years” Palmer Luckey Interview (starts at 27:45). This post examines the threat posed by foreign economic espionage, how such activity has increased since Congress enacted the America Invents Act in 2011, and considers how the problem could be addressed today. It is widely understood that the patent represents a trade between the government and an inventor: the inventor places their newly acquired knowledge in the public domain, and in exchange, the state compensates them with a temporary legal monopoly: “The federal patent system … embodies a carefully crafted bargain for encouraging the creation and disclosure of new … technology … ‘[i]n consideration of its disclosure and the consequent benefit to the community, the patent is granted.’” Bonito Boats v. Thunder Craft Boats, 489 U.S. 141, 150-51 (1989), quoting U.S. v. Dubilier Condenser Corp, 289 U.S. 178, 186 (1933). A patent grant is thus fundamentally predicated on the inventor’s disclosure of information to the public. In a globalized online economy, this feature of the patent system places inventors squarely between a rock and a hard place: in order to secure legal protection for their technology against domestic competitors, they must effectively give it away to the international competition. This glaring contradiction in a system designed to protect the property rights of inventors has only become more apparent with the rapid growth of Chinese cyber espionage. While concerns about foreign intellectual property theft were voiced to a limited extent during the debates over the America Invents Act (see: Congressional Record), the threat has since grown massively in scale. Over the past 15 years, China has aggressively implemented a policy framework described as the “securitization of everything,” placing an especially significant emphasis on developing their cybercapabilities. MERICS Comp. Nat. Sec XJP In 2021, a report by the Center for Security and Emerging Technology at Georgetown University found that China maintains an extensive science and technology intelligence network, which is dedicated to monitoring foreign technology developments through open information sources accessible on the internet, including patents. CSET report 2021. The report estimated these efforts employ over 100,000 people and concluded that “[n]o other country has anything remotely comparable.” (page v) CSET report 2021. In 2020, FBI Director Chistopher Wray testified that the number of cases at the FBI involving Chinese economic espionage had increased by 1300% in the decade between 2010 and 2020, and warned that Chinese economic espionage is the “greatest long-term threat to our nation’s information and intellectual property” Wray Testimony 2. And as American innovation has come under increasing threat, China’s own inventive output has increased. In 2010, China issued around 135,000 invention patents China Patents 2010, compared to the roughly 121,000 total patents granted in the U.S. the same year US Granted Patents. In 2024, the United States issued 324,042 total patents US Patents 2024, while China issued over 1,000,000 China Patents 2024. The Invention Secrecy Act provides that some patents may be placed under secrecy orders when the publication of the patent would be “detrimental to national security,” but this statute provides inadequate protection against international economic espionage for several reasons 35 U.S. Code § 181. First, the statutory determination regarding national security must be made by the head of a government agency, who then sponsors a secrecy order. The statute is thus directed more toward preventing threats to state interests, rather than mitigating the long-term effects of civilian economic espionage. Second, there is no formal mechanism which would allow the patent applicant to affirmatively request a secrecy order, or state the reasons why they believe that one would be appropriate. Third, the statute requires that secrecy orders be re-evaluated every year, which puts an increasing burden on the government as the number of secrecy orders increases, and possibly disincentivizes government agencies from sponsoring secrecy orders in the first place. The data show that a very small number of patents are subject to secrecy orders: there were 365 secrecy orders imposed in 2024, representing just 0.1% of the 324,042 total issued patents that year US Patents 2024 FAS Secrecy Orders. To better protect inventors and foster innovation, Congress should consider reforms to the patent system in order to better effectuate the patent system. Mr. Luckey has suggested that we “need to massively expand the national security patent process.” Palmer Luckey Interview. However, this solution may be overbroad and could jeopardize the fundamental bargain which emphasizes disclosure as the basis for the inventor’s right to a state-granted monopoly. There is an alternative which serves both the interests of prospective inventors and the goal of promoting disclosure of innovation: Congress should simply extend the period during which patents are kept secret by the Patent and Trademark Office. At present, the P.T.O. is required to make public all patents 18 months after their filing date 32 U.S.C. §122. Congress could increase that timeframe without imposing secrecy for an indefinite period, thus ensuring that technologies will eventually become part of the public domain when they are no longer valuable targets for theft. This would allow inventors to receive earned property protection for inventions which could not be protected by trade secrets, while reducing the economic harms of foreign espionage. And compared to the status quo, this policy could better promote the goal of maximizing the aggregate disclosure of new knowledge by causing more inventors to seek patent protection without fear of theft by foreign actors. The patent system was simply not built to withstand an army of 100,000 scientific intelligence analysts dedicated to exploiting each detail of every American invention.
Zitieren
APA
Battaglia, L. (2026). To Defend American Innovation from Foreign Espionage, Amend the Patent Disclosure Timeline. Science and Technology Law Review. https://doi.org/10.52214/ewzxs559
Vancouver
Battaglia L. To Defend American Innovation from Foreign Espionage, Amend the Patent Disclosure Timeline. Science and Technology Law Review. 2026. doi:10.52214/ewzxs559
BibTeX
@article{Battaglia2026,
author = {Battaglia, Lorenzo},
title = {To Defend American Innovation from Foreign Espionage, Amend the Patent Disclosure Timeline},
journal = {Science and Technology Law Review},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.52214/ewzxs559}
}
EUVIMED