EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

Extremist Watchdogs?

Jay Daniel Thompson

M/C Journal · 21.11.2026 · 29 (6)

DOI: 10.5204/mcj.3327 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift M/C Journal, online erschienen am 21.11.2026. Verfasst von Jay Daniel Thompson. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

In 2021, Rukshan Fernando began livestreaming Melbourne anti-lockdown protests on YouTube. Fernando had been a self-employed wedding photographer before this work was halted by COVID-19 and its associated disruptions. Posting as “The Real Rukshan”, Fernando (who has described himself as a journalist) sought to document the ways in which political leaders were “strip[ping] our rights, freedoms and dignity” (cited in O’Neil). He was particularly critical of the Victorian State Government led by Daniel Andrews, of the centrist Australian Labor Party. Under this government, Melbourne (the capital of Victoria) saw a total of six lockdowns between 2020-21, and increased police powers to enforce those lockdowns (Davey). This article asks: “what do Fernando’s 2021 anti-lockdown protest livestreams suggest about the blurring boundaries between journalism, conspiracy and extremism?” Applying Integrative Framing Analysis to those livestreams, this article argues that Fernando performs the role of journalistic watchdog, purporting to hold the Andrews government to account and publicly expose their authoritarianism. In doing this, he supports often violent and factually incorrect views about that government. In this respect, the article suggests, his reportage blurs the (already porous) boundaries separating “journalism” and “conspiracy”. Further, the article demonstrates how Fernando’s lockdown reportage illuminates some ways in which journalism has helped mainstream political extremism. Journalistic Watchdogs, Boundaries, Distrust The journalistic watchdog archetype “casts journalism as a heroic institution, independent from private and political interests, that informs the public about important issues and holds power to account” (Palmer et al. 1973). Watchdog journalism has been described as “the fourth estate” and as a bulwark of healthy democracies (Kalogeropoulos et al. 487). This article focusses on the journalistic watchdog role during a time of growing international distrust in key social institutions such as the media (Flew). A 2020 study notes that “news organizations’ ability to hold powerful people to account depends on audiences finding them credible”—and there can be no credibility for journalists if they are regarded as untrustworthy (Palmer et al. 1986). Significantly, the distrust has arisen concurrently with, and as part of, a broader transformation of journalistic boundaries. That term describes the practices, training, and myths that can distinguish journalism from non-journalistic cultural production (Carlson 2). Increasingly sophisticated Internet technologies have enabled the production and distribution of news content from users who may or may not conceive of themselves as being journalists or media professionals (Thompson and Weldon). These range from livestreams of current affairs to infographics and textual and audiovisual reportage. Journalism and Conspiracy Journalism and conspiracy appear to be strange bedfellows. Journalism has traditionally been associated, at least within its own mythology, with rationality and a reliance on facts. This has meant that it has benefits for democracy (Muller). Conversely, conspiracy—encompassing “narratives stating that some evil conspirators secretly plan wrongdoings”—has traditionally been associated with mis/disinformation and irrationality (De Maeyer and Le Cam 1496). For these reasons, conspiracy has been theorised as a threat to democracy. A growing corpus of scholarship is, however, suggesting that journalism and conspiracy are more similar than may be apparent. A 2025 study notes that the figure of the watchdog who is suspicious of authority appears in both genres (De Maeyer and Le Cam). Another study, published the same year, explores the emergence of an “alternative conspiracy media”, which includes outlets and actors that “position themselves as critical correctives to mainstream media, which they perceive as having an elitist, hegemonic, and left-leaning bias” (Urkens et al. 2365). Some of these outlets (e.g., Breitbart in the US) report on current affairs as any journalistic outlet might, albeit with a distinctly right-leaning slant. This article addresses Rukshan Fernando, one of Australia’s best-known “alternative conspiracy media” actors; the other is Avi Yemini, of Rebel News, who is regularly captured (usually in the background) in the livestreams discussed below, and with whom Fernando later collaborated. Fernando has self-identified as an “independent journalist” (Fernando, “Affidavit”). As of August 2026, his YouTube account had 42,200 followers, which is high; one media commentator has estimated that the “exact percentage of YouTube channels with over 1,000 subscribers is 8.86%” (Hocking). Fernando has been profiled by mainstream media outlets in Australia and America, thus increasing the reach of his views and suggesting that those views have an international resonance (Fernando, “Australia” and “Interview”; O’Neil; Wilson). This article contends that Fernando is a significant cultural figure because of the boundary-blurring that his work represents. In his lockdown livestreams, Fernando purports to expose the Andrews government as being ideologically biased (to the left), authoritarian, and hostile towards its citizens. In doing this, he performs what resembles a journalistic watchdog role. Conversely, he portrays himself as a saviour to those citizens, remarking that “the ordinary people on the street … don't have a platform. And in many ways, doing livestreams … provides a platform for these people” (cited in Hermant). Further, the article suggests that Fernando’s journalism contributes to the mainstreaming of extremism. The term “mainstreaming” describes the growing normalisation and social acceptability of “far-right views and political violence” (Gillespie 219). During 2020-21, across the world, protests against government-mandated COVID-19 measures enabled “radical and extremist actors to tie their ideologies to concerns shared by many” (Rothut et al. 3). Internet affordances such as streaming have meant that extremist views have been amplified to particularly large audiences, sometimes in the guise of journalism. Methodology This article deploys Integrative Framing Analysis, a qualitative approach that entails “analysing the contribution of both words and visuals to the framing of people or issues across communication contexts” (Dan 6). This article studies combinations of visuals (placards, marching) and sounds (e.g., chanting, speeches) that have been captured in Fernando’s livestreams. There is an emphasis on the uncritical repeating of mis/disinformation regarding COVID, lockdowns, and vaccines; and hostile rhetoric about the Victorian State Government. The corpus entails 17 livestreams that have been archived on “The Real Rukshan” Website. 16 of these were recorded between 11 March and 21 October 2021, the latter being the final day of Melbourne’s COVID lockdowns. The researcher chose this period because those lockdowns increased social isolation and this—combined with factors that include the declining trust in institutions—contributed to an increase in extremist activity in Victoria (Parliament of Victoria 67). The researcher also included a livestream recorded on 16 November 2021, because, filmed after the lockdowns concluded, this suggests a logical conclusion to the fierce anti-government animus, and the reliance on hostile rhetoric and misinformation, found on display in the protests. The livestreams range in length from 5.23 minutes to over six hours. Most of the demonstrations were focussed on opposing the lockdowns, though participants are also critical of other COVID-related measures (e.g., vaccines). The livestreaming genre is an important one, characterised as it is by immediacy and “creating authentic moments” (Taylor xii). Fernando frames his livestreams as achieving journalistic objectivity, saying: “I think it's really important that people see unedited continuous video … . When you see it in this manner you can make up your mind” (cited in Hermant). Elsewhere, Fernando has told conservative reporter Rita Panahi: “I’m not doing anything except going there with a camera and hitting ‘record’” (Fernando, “Interview”). Fernando’s livestreams were coded using inductive coding, which involved ascertaining themes from the data themselves rather than coding the data using pre-organised themes (Chandra and Shang 92). The researcher was familiar with Fernando’s work but wanted to remain open-minded when studying it. The researcher watched the entirety of each livestream, and as he did so, took notes using the following two coding criteria: the sounds heard (e.g., chanting, journalistic narration) and the imagery included (e.g., placards, protesters marching).

Findings

The researcher identified four dominant frames. These frames often appear simultaneously in the same livestream; at least one appears in every livestream. Frame One: The Victorian State Government is authoritarian and is using COVID-19 as a pretext to subjugate citizens. Frame Two: The protesters are ordinary people who are demonstrating (peacefully) against authoritarianism, for their own freedom. Frame Three: The protesters are distrustful of the mainstream media, which have misrepresented them. Frame Four: “Independent” media provide a trustworthy representation of the protests and protesters. These themes are invoked via combinations of imagery and dialogue. Some of this dialogue is spoken by Fernando, who regularly describes the events unfolding, and articulates his opinions on the issues raised in the protests—thereby eschewing the objectivity he touts. Some dialogue is spoken by protesters, either to each other or to Fernando’s camera. Fernando may not agree with all the views expressed; the researcher acknowledges that calling out certain views could be especially difficult when livestreaming large rallies. Nonetheless, and this point will be discussed shortly, he largely avoids challenging these views at all, and this amounts to a tacit acceptance.

Discussion

The “ordinary/average person” being oppressed by higher powers is a common trope in populist and conspiracist rhetoric (Yates and Mondon). This is a trope that Fernando invokes in his livestreams, describing protesters as “everyday people” and “the working-class”. They certainly appear unified in the demonstrations: marching in unison, chanting the same slogans, pleading the case for their “freedom” (that word appears frequently throughout the livestreams). Conversely, the oppressive forces comprise the Andrews state government, whose COVID responses have, they argue, severely impinged on the freedom of Victorians (Frame One). Fernando himself describes Andrews as “Kim Jong Dan”, a reference to North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un; this sentiment is echoed by several protesters—and Victoria as a “socialist, communist hellhole”. According to some protesters, the Victorian State Government have used COVID to enforce authoritarianism; one placard reads: “this isn't about a virus. It's about government control...” According to Fernando and the protesters, the subjugation of Victorians is enforced in several ways. It is enforced via the vaccine mandate and via increased police powers, which has entailed their disproportionate presence at the demonstrations. As per Frame Three, the government’s authority is (according to Fernando and protesters) reinforced by a mainstream media that seek to “demonise” protesters (Fernando, “Interview”). There is some basis to this accusation and that is worth acknowledging when trying to account for the resonance of Fernando’s reportage. For instance, in September 2021, the Andrews government banned “tearooms” on construction sites. When construction workers protested this decision, they were described in the media as “man baby Nazis” having “man baby tantrums” (cited in Copland). In fact, these closures “represented a major safety issue, removing the only place workers ha[d] to take some rest …” (Copland). Against this hostile mainstream media coverage, Fernando frames independent media—represented by himself—as honest and trustworthy, as comprising genuine watchdogs. There is some evidence that this framing was effective; for example, in a 2 October livestream, one protester describes Fernando as “the real media”. The problem above lies not in publicly disagreeing with a government. This is surely a sign of a robust democracy. The problem lies in Fernando’s reliance on what Mark Davis calls “anti-public discourse”, which shows little interest in adherence to principles of argumentation, evidence, truthfulness, mutuality, reciprocity, good faith and inclusiveness, among other democratic ‘public sphere’ norms, that while never fully adhered to, nevertheless underpin democratic culture. Second … such discourse often sets itself in pointed counter-hegemonic opposition to democratic processes and institutions such as the state, the media and the academy, and their managerial ‘elites’, and actively seeks to disrupt democratic processes for its own purposes. (145) Davis identifies “anti-public discourse” in the work of online extremist actors such as Milo Yiannopoulos, as well as Breitbart News (155). This article suggests that such discourse is also stock in trade for Fernando. He lacks the bombast of Yiannopoulos and the combativeness of Avi Yemini (who has also produced livestreams). Fernando’s reporting style is chatty and unassuming; he interacts in a friendly manner with demonstrators. This affable persona conceals the ethical issues raised by his work. Firstly, Fernando’s livestreams show a disregard for facts. This is most evident in the platforming of conspiratorial and factually dubious statements about COVID. For example, in a 20 September livestream, he reads out the following message, which appears on a protester’s shirt: “vaccine is COVID. Daniel Andrews is a coward. No Master”. There is an ethical imperative for journalists to acknowledge inaccuracies and point to actual evidence—in this case, the already (in 2021) growing scientific literature about COVID’s harms. This does not mean being adversarial towards misinformation proponents, which might inadvertently reinforce their narratives about a hostile, elitist media (Thompson and Sengul 9). The journalist could, for instance, remark on camera, and after the interview, that the views quoted have been contested. Fernando’s refusal to do this means that he uncritically amplifies the views (which are potentially dangerous) to his audience. Secondly, the livestreams amplify criticisms of the Victorian state government that are clearly not made in good faith and could at times be classified as “violent talk”. This entails “utterances [that] express an ideology and invoke the use of violence as part of those expressions” (Simi and Windisch 2). For example, in a 20 September livestream, Fernando describes the protest as “peaceful”, even though one demonstrator in the same stream can be heard describing Andrews as a “communist cunt” and another can be heard saying: “you can stick your fucking vaccine up your arse”. Fernando’s livestream of the 16 November protests outside Victoria’s Parliament House, which depicts makeshift gallows emblazoned with the word “traitor”, emphasises this atmosphere of threat. The violence of this imagery marks a shocking contrast to the rest of the livestream, which appears most harmonious, even joyous (there are, for example, shots of people dancing on the street). This footage provides one stark example of what happens when extremism becomes mainstreamed; indeed, it echoes footage of a gallows that was erected outside the Capitol Building in Washington D.C. prior to the 6 January 2021 riots (which were themselves fuelled largely by misinformation; see Thompson). Thirdly, Fernando frames his livestream reportage as being more authentic—and therefore more trustworthy—depictions of the anti-lockdown protests than those offered by the mainstream media. This framing is disingenuous; Fernando does indeed insert his opinions into the reportage, but these are presented as “common sense” assertions of fact. Through his use of this framing, Fernando seeks to contrast the “authenticity” of his reporting, including his editorialising, with the supposedly untrustworthy coverage of mainstream media, thus potentially helping to exacerbate distrust in the mainstream media.

Conclusion

This article has argued that Ruskhan Fernando’s 2021 lockdown livestreams provide an instructive insight into the blurring boundaries between journalism, conspiracy, and extremism. The livestreams seek to hold the Victorian State Government and the mainstream media to account for subjugating Victorians and demonising those who resisted that state’s COVID measures. In doing this, Fernando frames both this government and the mainstream media as oppressive enforcers of a dangerous status quo and himself as the brave independent journalist who highlights their wrongdoings and gives ordinary folk a voice. Through not correcting factually dubious views on vaccines, or violent rhetoric about the Victorian premier, Fernando’s livestreams also help enable the further mainstreaming of extremism. References Carlson, Matt. “Introduction: The Many Boundaries of Journalism.” Boundaries of Journalism: Professionalism, Practices and Participation. Eds. Matt Carlson and Seth C. Lewis. Milton Park: Routledge, 2015. 1–18. Chandra, Yanto, and Liang Shang. Doing Qualitative Research Using R: A Systematic Approach. Singapore: Springer, 2019. Copland, Simon. “How the Smug Politics of COVID-19 Empowers the Far Right”. The Atlantic, 6 Oct. 2021. 1 June 2026 . Dan, Viorela. Integrative Framing Analysis: Framing Health through Words and Visuals. New York: Routledge, 2017. Davey, Melissa. “Police Given ‘Extraordinary Powers’ to Enforce COVID-19 Restrictions.” The Guardian, 4 Aug. 2020. 1 June 2026 . Davis, Mark. “The Online Anti-Public Sphere.” European Journal of Cultural Studies 24.1 (2021): 143-159. . De Maeyer, Juliette, and Florence Le Cam. “Conspiracy Theorists as Alternative Journalists.” Journalism Studies 26.12 (2025): 1495-512. . Fernando, Rukshan. “Australia Declines into A Biomedical Police State – Ingraham Angle.” 23 Sep. 2021. 1 June 2026 . Fernando, Rukshan. “Interview with Rita Panahi on Melbourne Protests—Sky News Australia.” Rukshan Fernando, 12 November 2021. 1 June 2026 . Fernando, Rukshan. “Affidavit of Rukshan Fernando.” Moira Deeming v John Pesutto. Federal Court of Australia, 27 May 2024. 1 May 2026 . Flew, Terry. “The Global Trust Deficit Disorder: A Communications Perspective on Trust in the Time of Global Pandemics.” Journal of Communication 71.2 (2021): 163-86. . Gillespie, Liam. “On the Proximity of the Far Right and the Misuses of the ‘Mainstreaming’ Metaphor.” Identities 33.2 (2026): 219-38. . Graham, Timothy, Axel Bruns, Daniel Angus, Edward Hurcombe, and Sam Hames. “#IStandWithDan versus #DictatorDan: The Polarised Dynamics of Twitter Discussions about Victoria’s COVID-19 Restrictions.” Media International Australia 179.1 (2021): 127-48. . Hermant, Norman. “At Melbourne’s Anti-Lockdown Protests, Everyone Has a Different Version of the Truth.”. ABC News, 26 Sep. 2021. 1 June 2026 . Hocking, Chris. “How Many YouTube Channels Have over 1k Subscribers?” Indiy, n.d. 28 Oct. 2026 . Kalogeropoulos, Antonis, Benjamin Toff, and Richard Fletcher. “The Watchdog Press in the Doghouse: A Comparative Study of Attitudes about Accountability Journalism, Trust in News, and News Avoidance.” The International Journal of Press/Politics 29:2 (2024): 485-506. . Muller, Denis. Journalism Ethics for the Digital Age. Melbourne: Scribe Publications, 2014. O’Neil, Patrick. “Who Is the Real Rukshan?” The Age, 25 Sep. 2021. 1 June 2026 . Palmer, Ruth, Benjamin Toff, and Rasmus Kleis Nielsen. “‘The Media Covers Up a Lot of Things’: Watchdog Ideals Meet Folk Theories of Journalism.” Journalism Studies 21.14 (2020): 1973-89. . Parliament of Victoria. Inquiry Into Extremism in Victoria. Parliament of Victoria Legislative Council Legal and Social Issues Committee, 2022. The Real Rukshan. May-June 2026 . (Offline as of 18 Oct. 2026.) Rothut, Sophia, Heidi Schulze, Diana Rieger, Maximilian Lechner, and Brigitte Naderer. “Protest Movements and the Mainstreaming of Radical and Extremist Ideologies: The Case of COVID-19 Protests.” Information, Communication & Society (2026). . Taylor, T.L. “Foreword: Broadcasting Our Lives, Broadcasting Ourselves.” Real Life in Real Time: Live Streaming Culture. Eds. Johanna Brewer, Bo Ruberg, Amanda L.L. Cullen, and Christopher J. Persaud. Cambridge: MIT P, 2023. ix-xv. Simi, Pete, and Steven Windisch. “The Culture of Violent Talk: An Interpretive Approach.” Social Sciences 9.7 (2020): 1-16. . Thompson, Jay Daniel. “Body of Evidence: Conspiracy, Masculinity and Otherness in ‘QAnon Shaman’ Meme Discourses.” Continuum 37.5 (2023): 608-20. . Thompson, Jay Daniel, and Kurt Sengul. “The Platforming Is the Point: News Media, ‘The Oxygen of Amplification’, and Interviewing the Far-Right.” Communication and the Public 11.3 (2026): 251-65. . Thompson, Jay Daniel, and John Weldon. Content Production for Digital Media. Singapore: Springer. Urkens, Jolan, Jaram Harambam, and Leen d’Haenens. “Threat or Menace to Media Pluralism? A Framework to Assess Alternative Conspiracy Media in Today’s Information Landscape.” Journalism 26.11 (2025): 2364-81. . Wilson, Cam. “Real Rukshan: The Live Streamer Who Took Melbourne’s Protest to the World Stage.” Crikey, 24 Sep. 2021. 1 June 2026 . Yates, Alex, and Aurelien Mondon. “‘Get Off Your High Horse and Vote for Us’: The Anti-Populist Construction of the Elite and the People.” The British Journal of Politics and International Relations 27.3 (2025): 677-95. .

Zitieren

APA

Thompson, J. D. (2026). Extremist Watchdogs?. M/C Journal, 29(6). https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3327

Vancouver

Thompson JD. Extremist Watchdogs?. M/C Journal. 2026;29(6). doi:10.5204/mcj.3327

BibTeX
@article{Thompson2026,
  author = {Thompson, Jay Daniel},
  title = {Extremist Watchdogs?},
  journal = {M/C Journal},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {29},
  number = {6},
  doi = {10.5204/mcj.3327}
}
Kostenlos starten →