Sublime Light
M/C Journal · 18.10.2026 · 29 (5)
DOI: 10.5204/mcj.3295 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift M/C Journal, online erschienen am 18.10.2026. Verfasst von Shaun Wilson. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Introduction
In Stepano Amatucci’s 2016 film Caina, which I will return to later, underworld body hunters gather to extract the corpses of refugees consumed by the sea who wash ashore along the coastal terrain of a near-future Sicily. The beach in this context moves away from an idyllic and picturesque seaside into a screen aesthetic akin to what Edmond Burke described as a sublimity, that is, terror and horror, and vastness and privation. While the beach has held a prominent location for moving image practice as a backdrop to character and event narratives, say, in Storm Boy (1976), Dunkirk (2017), Puberty Blues (1981), and Old (2021), this article argues that screen maritime landforms are a phenomenological experience from metamodernism (see Storm; van den Akker, Gibbons, Vermeulen) brought about by an intersubjective sublimity. The beach in this consideration will be discussed throughout this article in context to slow films as a process rather than an object, and a material system for producing the sublime. Within this, and more specifically, moving image practice across contemporary understandings of metamodernism, not to be confused with the earlier Zavarzaden argument, enables a critical agent to think about the beach that transcends our sense of place within the maritime, while at the same time open debate about the beach as a screen sublimity and into what I will define as a metamodern signal. Metamodern affect ‘as a phenomenological truth rather than an ontological or epistemological truth’ (Gibbons) will be used to apply a consideration of an affective condition defined by an oscillation between two contradictory experiential states. In this sense, meta-signals defined by oscillation are the culturally encoded perceptual trigger by which environmental imagery is decoded as a sublime effect brought about as a condition of an encounter for the viewer between the subject and the environment. The beach when framed through metamodernism oscillates contrasted theoretical values that in context to moving image practice resonate across sublimity that this article defines as two structurally differing critical perspectives. First, whilst acknowledging Burke’s position (1757) of terror and vastness, Kant’s perspective (1790) that followed Burke’s extends an account of the sublime to encounters between reason and imagination, and formlessness and limitlessness; that is, the sublime exists in the mind. Both their perspectives are treated here as pre-metamodern models of sublimity, reconfigured through a metamodern logic of oscillation. Second, when considering these accounts as a relationship of ‘between’, metamodernism’s structural accounts of ‘between’ are in close proximity to apply an affective-based account of sublimity, given that the term sublime exists as an affectual experience consisting of a dual relationship structure. In these considerations, the sublime will be managed and applied as a meta-signal; a perceptual mechanism through which sublime conditions are encoded and recognised. In this way, it functions as a relay between representation and affective interpretation not unlike the Baudrillardian sense of triggering an energy. Thus, it will be considered through metamodernism akin to a frame that holds tension between the two structures of the sublime in beach-themed moving images for an audience to think about how to better understand the distinctive aesthetic qualities of the beach through slow films. I will then use both implications as a way to analyse Caina and three other examples of moving image practice depicting beaches; Shaun Gladwell’s Storm Sequence (2000), Julius von Bismarck’s Punishment #7 (2011), and Shaun Wilson’s The Mast of Ariel (2026). In as much as the beach contains atmospheric triggers harking back to aspects of Romanticist maritime painting, for example, Turner’s Keelmen Heaving Coals by Moonlight (1835), these same residues of terror and awe in the maritime experience bring about the same kinds of sentiments when experienced through video. In the National Gallery of Art essay “Sublime Light: J.M.W Turner’s Keelmen Heaving in Coals by Moonlight”, the Turner painting is framed in relation to terror and awe within a Kantian account of the sublime relative to what ‘nature can evoke in us’ (National Gallery of Art). From a structural point of view, the beach, understood as a sublime form, functions in a Kantian sense as a trigger within the mind through which audiences respond to visual narratives pitted against the forces of nature. It is precisely through this that the aforementioned works establish the same kinds of relationships that Turner evokes in his paintings and within European Romanticism more broadly. When these perspectives are considered, the beach then exists through the moving image as an emotional state shaped by the self and cultural memory. This process, then, unfolds in three stages: first, we witness the subject; second, we comprehend the beach through a meta-signal of visual information depicting nature poised between terror and awe; and third, we decode this meta-signal to derive an emotional response to that of a liminal space between the two. In this sense, the experience we derive from sublimity depends on a meta-signal transmitting the state of nature impacting on the beach. What emerges is a phenomenological relationship in which the beach becomes a site through which emotions associated with the affectual residue of the subject’s meta-signal frame sublimity as encountered, reinterpreted, and redefined. Video Test Cases In doing so, the beach through the moving image necessitates the subject to transmit active forces of nature to trigger a sense of sublimity in order to gain an affective response by an audience. For example, Shaun Gladwell’s video Storm Sequence depicts the artist performing skater tricks at the ‘Bondi Beach's foreshore, amid the crashing waves and rolling clouds of an approaching storm’ (Croggon & Green 133). His precarious state triggers a sense of danger where his performance is poised at the edge of a wet cement lookout point high above a backgrounded beach. The angle of the video presents a potential risk of falling off the edge of the platform or slipping from the wet concrete and environmental conditions. The roaring sea, backdropped against the performance, echoes a treacherous weather condition. The threatening weather, the rough sea, and the vulnerability of the performer amidst these conditions surmount a cultural memory between Romanticist maritime paintings of the same vista and the video enacting a modern skater performance; second, the state of the performer poised between danger and vulnerability; and third, the observation between beauty and the overwhelming forces of nature that exceed human control. If the identical scene was filmed under calm seas and clear skies, much of this affect would disappear. The meta-signal, then, would become picturesque rather than sublime by replacing the possibility of danger or environmental threat with a state of visual pleasantry. The forces of nature, then, are critical to transmit the manifestation of sublimity in maritime art. The transmission of weather in Storm Sequence functions as a catalyst to alter the viewer’s understanding of the subject, indicating what this article argues, that environmental conditions can fundamentally reshape emotional and phenomenological meanings attached to place. What the viewer encounters depends on an interplay between natural power and human facility played out at the same time in the imagination that gives a sense of sublimity oscillating between our emotional responses. Where Gladwell’s video is a controlled athletic performance, Julius von Bismarck’s Punishment #7 is a video artwork based on historical myth depicting the artist ‘dressed in a full suit, doggedly lashing the sea with an extravagantly long leather whip’ (ACCA). The video is based on accounts of ‘Persian King Xerxes [who] had two pontoon bridges built to enable his army to cross the Hellespont. The bridges … were destroyed in a storm. Xerxes ordered … the sea whipped with three hundred lashes as punishment’ (ACCA). As likened to Storm Sequence, von Bismark’s work enacts the perils of weather and the treachery of waves to achieve sublimity heightened by the striking oddity of the whipping performance. Its meta-signal, integrating the Xerxes story, adds an additional layer of meaning by transmission. Yet in doing so, the one aspect that remains in question from this regard is in context to the intervention between the shoreline and the beach. Von Bismark presents a fragility of the central figure located within the roaring waves. At any moment the performer may succumb to the sea, creating tension much like the peril of Gladwell skating at the edge of a landing. When the beach is considered in the sense of a stoic landform buffered amongst the same forces of nature as the performers within it, land, then, shares the same kind of fragility. The views of the beach in Punishment #7 are pounded by the sea against turbulence. In a single storm, beaches can be transformed by rapid erosion and go back into the sea, to change their boundary or even vanish altogether. The beach of von Bismark is clearly in the same state of peril as the performer at the edge of the sea in so much as both performer and shoreline risk the same fate. As for metamodernism, the state of this peril, between the states of risk and safety, and of transformation and resistance oscillate at the same time, which imbues a sense of sublimity across and within the subject. Shaun Wilson’s The Mast of Ariel (2026) is a video artwork depicting the artist strapped to a pole on a beach during a storm. In 1842, British Romanticist painter William Turner’s testimonial claimed that he had allegedly asked to be tied to the mast of the steamboat Ariel over four hours during a snowstorm ‘in order to better observe the tempest around him’ (Gage 68). Wilson reenacts the Turner account as a meta-history critique of romantic authenticity where the artwork’s meta-signal testifies as a secondary simulation of observational extremity to be later decoded as a sublimity. Like Gladwell’s and von Bismark’s examples, human frailty is centred in the work, placing the artist and the beach against a storm environment where a sense of precariousness is the centrepiece backdropped to the forces of nature. It, then, moves between the lens of Burke’s sublime as an observation of overwhelming power and danger and Kant’s sublime as the mind’s reasoning, to comprehend these classes into reflexive judgement. Turner allegedly experienced the snowstorm in preparation for the painting Snow Storm – Steam Boat off a Harbour’s Mouth Making Signals in Shallow Water, and Going by the Lead. The Author Was in This Storm on the Night the Ariel Left Harwich (1842). His account prescribes an intent to experience the storm within the elements instead of approaching the painting as mere pictorial representation. Although disputed (Monks) that the event was in fact fictitious, the motivation by the artist was to demonstrate an affective intent where he claims, ‘I did not paint it to be understood, but I wished to show what such a scene was like’ (Tate). Inferring immersion over the picturesque, the nature of a storm’s affect in Turner’s account reconstituted to a beach location overlooking the crashing of waves and the power of torrential wind, the structural argument in Wilson's work connects to the Turner account reconfigured as a story that is neither factual nor apocryphal in as much as the reconfiguration itself, set on a beach instead of a ship, also lands between authenticity of events and its reconfiguration through interpretation. Returning to Caina, Amatucci’s use of the beach as a silent character remains in stark contrast to other depictions of beaches as a coastal backdrop. Whether it be an embodiment of the discovery of washed-up corpses from the aftermath of refugee boat sinkings or the spatial foregrounding of where body scavengers patrol, Caina’s meta-signal transmits an affectual state of the maritime. Unlike the previous examples of action amidst the forces of nature, the film’s turbulence is psychological, or in Kant’s view, of the mind. While there are storm sequences in the film, the overarching premise of depictions of the beach is mostly in calm weather leading to two states. The first is in relation to the bodies of drowned refugees as a sign of what had previously occurred unseen during the treacherous sea crossing. The second is that the terror and awe of Caina’s sublimity remain psychological in terms of the horror of the plight of people who drowned, the fragility of the beach as a site of tragedy, and the trade by body snatchers on the beach of selling bodies to the government to be then ground up into reinforced cement. The Intersubjective Sublime When considering the four test case examples, common denominators emerge for the sublime: spectacle, risk, and experience. To unpack these states, what emerges is a contextual framework that grounds metamodernism as a threshold by which we ought to think about the beach as a triangulation of intersubjectivity. Much like Husserl’s ‘problem of other minds’, which defined how collective experiences can phenomenologically understand shared emotion, this article proposes that to comprehend a metamodern sublimity is embodied within an intersubjectivity as its very nature determines a subjectivity of a shared experience. While maritime sublimity often portrays a solitude scenario of alone or lost, the beach as a subject, arguably, imbues the sublime when there is little or no one presence for it to achieve maximum effect. For example, a beach with many visitors compared to a lone figure on an empty beach shifts the locus of the sublime to an embodied witnessing of collective immersion. This allows the perceptual framing of observers to become part of the phenomenological field. In this sense, the beach operates as the grounding locality to mediate a site of metamodern affect whereby the intersubjective intensifies the sublime experience through its oscillation between solitude and collective witnessing. If that intersubjectivity was not privileged by these observations, the residue of engaging with the observation of sublimity, then, blurs the distinction between subject and object to destabilise the boundary of external or internal affect. In essence, we need intersubjectivity to perceive the sublime in a meaningful way that holds value to our perceptive experiences that otherwise would be diminished in isolation. Meaning, then, risks collapsing into a purely private affective response unanchored from the beach as a shared and historically sedimented site where one is experienced individually yet collectively constituted across time. Returning to the three denominators, the first is the observational oscillation between the state and spectacle of perimeters. This oscillation describes how the beach is apprehended as a shifting field in which conditions and aesthetic framing continually configure one another and away from a static spatial form. Spectacle emerges through the variability of these perimeters – the tide, the weather, the density of presence – to each contribute a fluctuating sense of perception as an ongoing redefining of the limits of observational experience. The beach, then, functions as a conceptual threshold where observation is inseparable from what is witnessed, an effective force arising of sorts, through the continual transmission between the subject, a sense of place, and the oriented awareness that mediates their relation. Where both Burke and Kant located their sense of the sublime in the senses of terror and vastness and the mind controlling its own limits, the beach suggests that sublimity emerges through intersubjective relations, much as Storm Sequence and Caina demonstrated, that give meaning to the experience of the beach anchored through a sense of place. Consequently, the beach persists as a site of sublime significance because its meanings are continually renewed through acts of witnessing that return the space of perception under changing conditions of affective engagement. The present encounter, likened to The Mast of Ariel, is shaped by earlier experiences that continue to inform how the state of the beach is apprehended, allowing each moment of observation to enable for an audience what is seen and remembered. The second and third denominators form an interlinked experience as the oscillation of risk between certainty and collapse. If this dimension is considered through a metamodern account of sublimity, risk emerges as a conditioned expectation that structures how the beach is perceived when we witness it framed within the moving image. Its framing then sustains through the viewer’s anticipation of what could happen at any given moment, moving away from the security of land unsettled by the presence of unpredictable consequences from the forces of nature. In Punishment #7, for example, this condition is already active in the way the work holds attention within moments where stability appears to be momentary and fragile in relation to the performer whipping the water. The risk of collapse operates as an orienting experience that shapes how form is perceived in the present by gathering attention around what may give way within the structure of the performance. The beach becomes a site where observation is perceived as part of this risk that evidently defines the locality of the beach as an unstable environment affecting how we develop a sense of place influenced by these determining factors. Risk is encountered by this as something that persists within the conditions of viewing influenced by the presence of human form oscillating between the form of the land and sea and the force of weather patterns.
Conclusion
Across these perceptions, the beach emerges within moving image practice as a locality where sublimity is perceived by the oscillations of nature’s forces and encounters of human frailty. These works demonstrate how video can mobilise an effective interface that generates perceptual conditions that exceed picturesque backdrops or maritime settings. In doing so, they expose the limitations of human endurance pitted against these forces that when reframed through metamodernism establish the beach as a threshold condition. These encounters oscillate between Burkean and Kantian views yet remain co-present in shaping how sublimity is perceived through shifting relations of intensity and reflection. The concept of a meta-signal developed in this article accounts for how these oscillations are encoded with meaning embedded in environmental tableaux that allow the beach to function as a site of meaning recalibrated through perceptual engagement. Within this framework, the beach becomes an intersubjective field structured in relations between orienting bodies through coastal places, and the act of watching these manoeuvres through the moving image. The works mentioned then demonstrate how a cinematic attention is drawn toward risk where the volatility of nature and human vulnerability shape the terms by which our experience is organised. Ultimately, the sublimity of such foregrounds is a criticality in the moving image of how we experience the beach and come to terms with the perceptions of encountered states amongst the maritime and to where the sublime is encountered. References ACCA. “Julius von Bismarck: Punishment #7.” Australian Centre for Contemporary Art, 2026. 8 June 2026 . Burke, Edmund. A Philosophical Enquiry into the Origins of Our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful. London: R and J. Dodsley, 1757. Croggon, Alison, and Charles Green. “Shaun Gladwell: Storm Sequence.” In Shaun Gladwell. Melbourne: Australian Centre for Contemporary Art, 2009. 133. Dunkirk. Dir. Christopher Nolan. Warner Bros. Pictures, 2017. Gage, John. Turner: A Wonderful Range of Mind. New Haven: Yale UP, 1987. Gibbons, Alison. “Contemporary Autofiction and Metamodern Affect.” Metamodernism: Historicity, Affect, and Depth after Postmodernism. Eds. Robin van den Akker, Alison Gibbons, and Timotheus Vermeulen. London: Rowman & Littlefield, 2017. 117-130. Gladwell, Shaun. Storm Sequence. Video artwork with sound. 2000. Husserl, Edmund. Cartesian Meditations: An Introduction to Phenomenology. Paris: Armand Colin, 1931. Kant, Immanuel. Critique of Judgment. Berlin and Libau: Lagarde and Friedrich, 1790. Kirkbride, Martin P., Susan P. Mains, and Vanessa Brazier. “Turner’s 1836 Crossing and the Little Ice Age Portrayed in Val Veny and Val Ferret: A Geography of the Sublime.” Revue de Geographie Alpine 111.2 (2023): n.pag. . Monks, Sarah.“’Suffer a Sea-Change’: Turner, Painting, Drowning.” Tate Papers 14 (2010): n. pag. 8 June 2026 . National Gallery of Art. “Sublime Light: J.M.W. Turner’s Keelmen Heaving in Coals by Moonlight.” N.d. 30 May 2026 . Old. Dir. M. Night Shyamalan. Universal Pictures, 2021. Puberty Blues. Dir. Bruce Beresford. Australian Film Commission, 1981. Storm, Jason Anada Josephson. Metamodernism: The Future of Theory. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 2021. Storm Boy. Dir. Henri Safran. South Australian Film Corporation, 1976. Tate. “Toil and Terror at Sea.” Tate Britain, n.d. 8 June 2026 . Von Bismarck, Julius. Punishment #7. Video artwork with sound. 2011. Wilson, Shaun. The Mast of Ariel. UHD video with sound. 2026.
Zitieren
APA
Wilson, S. (2026). Sublime Light. M/C Journal, 29(5). https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3295
Vancouver
Wilson S. Sublime Light. M/C Journal. 2026;29(5). doi:10.5204/mcj.3295
BibTeX
@article{Wilson2026,
author = {Wilson, Shaun},
title = {Sublime Light},
journal = {M/C Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {29},
number = {5},
doi = {10.5204/mcj.3295}
}
EUVIMED