Designing Embodied Engagement Strategies to Support Health Goals in Fitness Apps
M/C Journal · 12.08.2026 · 29 (4)
DOI: 10.5204/mcj.3286 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift M/C Journal, online erschienen am 12.08.2026. Verfasst von Jing Zhou und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Mobile Phone Technology and Health Behaviour Change in China Since the early 2010s, the health and fitness market in China has experienced remarkable growth (Krebs and Duncan). Fitness apps have become an important part of this growth, supporting users to exercise, monitor progress, and develop healthier lifestyles (Sibor, Stoller, and Wang). As of 2023, China’s online fitness app market generated almost RMB 800 million (approximately A$169 million) in revenue (Saas). Industry forecasts suggest this market will continue to grow over the next decade, reflecting increasing demand for digital health and fitness services in China (Grand View Research; Market Research Future). This growth highlights the importance of designing fitness apps that support long-term user engagement. However, despite their popularity, fitness apps in China face a notable challenge. Compared with other mobile health (mHealth) apps, they experience lower levels of user stickiness, referring to users’ continued engagement with an app over time (Hu et al.). According to Localytics, 80% of users stop engaging with their fitness apps within just 30 days of downloading them (Localytics). This low retention rate is especially concerning among young Chinese adults, a group that often struggles with body dissatisfaction, insufficient physical activity, and disordered eating behaviours (Hao et al.). These challenges are not only behavioural, but also reflect how individuals experience and relate to their own bodies in everyday life. Consequently, fitness apps do more than guide behaviour; they also shape how users perceive, experience, and engage with their bodies during exercise. It is worth noting that a lack of physical activity and distorted body image perceptions are common among young people in China. The rate of regular physical exercise among Chinese individuals aged 20–69 years was only 18.7% in 2013 (Nie et al.). Liao et al.‘s study demonstrated a high prevalence of eating disorders among young Chinese adults, with 2.5% displaying at-risk eating attitudes. Body dissatisfaction is considered a significant contributing factor to eating disorders (Arigo, Schumacher, and Martin). Continuous exposure to advertising on social media, coupled with pervasive peer pressure, significantly contributes to the cultivation of distorted body image perceptions in China. For example, the notion that a woman's thinness equates to beauty is deeply ingrained in the public's mindset (Xu et al.); however, most young women feel that the BMI index is inaccurate and should indicate a lower value than the normal index (Hao et al.). Current app designs tend to rely heavily on basic tracking functions, social communities, or influencer livestreams. While these features can support initial engagement, they rarely sustain motivation or foster a balanced, long-term healthy lifestyle (Wei et al.; Zhou, Wang, and Tuo). This highlights the need to better understand how fitness apps can support sustained engagement with physical activity beyond short-term motivation. Drawing on case studies and interviews with young Chinese adults, this study explores how gamification strategies can support users’ ongoing engagement with exercise by considering how they experience and interact with their bodies during physical activity. Gamification Gamification, a term coined in 2008, refers to the use of game design elements in non-game contexts (Deterding et al.). Following the definition proposed by Deterding et al., gamification has been widely adopted across commercial and health sectors to encourage behaviour change and improve user engagement and retention. It has become a dominant strategy in mobile health and fitness apps, where game-like rewards and incentives are used to motivate users and sustain healthy habits. Despite its widespread adoption, evidence regarding its effectiveness in supporting sustained engagement with physical activity remains limited (Kumar and Herger). As young adults are generally familiar with game-based systems (Deterding et al.; Zichermann and Cunningham), gamification has the potential to support long-term physical activity. Drawing on insights from twelve young Chinese adults and case studies of existing fitness apps, this study asks: How can gamification strategies be designed to better support sustained engagement with physical activity in Chinese fitness apps? Gamification and Stickiness A key objective of gamification strategies is to improve user “stickiness”, defined here as an app’s ability to encourage users to return regularly and sustain engagement over time rather than discontinue use after initial adoption. In the context of fitness apps, stickiness extends beyond repeated use to encompass continued participation in physical activity. As shown in table 1, Lister et al. conducted a large-scale review of 132 health and fitness apps and found that 67% incorporated at least one gamification element. The most common features were social competition, feedback mechanisms, and digital rewards. Table 1: Descriptive statistics for gamification elements. Measuring rubrics Feature or strategies Num of apps Score Total % Game elements 3.80 of 13 29.23 Self-representation with avatars 68 3D environments 8 Narrative context 8 Feedback from game (before or during) 45 Feedback, reinforcement (after) 76 Leaderboards 43 Ranks of achievements 39 Different levels of play 28 Marketplaces and economies 19 Competition 42 Teams (multi-player modes) 19 Parallel communication systems 64 Time pressure 43 Gamification 2.29 of 6 38.16 Leaderboards 43 Levels of achievement or rank 34 Digital rewards 73 Real word prizes 24 Competitions or challenges 51 Social or peer pressure 78 Note. Summary of Lister et al.'s evaluation of 132 health and fitness apps. The behavioural score (maximum = 13) measures the extent to which an app incorporates health behaviour constructs, including capability, motivation, and opportunity/trigger. The game score (maximum = 13) assesses the use of effective game design principles, while the gamification score (maximum = 6) indicates the number of gamification elements implemented in each app. These findings suggest that gamification is widely incorporated into fitness apps, although the depth and quality of its implementation vary considerably. Lister et al.’s findings align with other empirical studies, identifying social challenges and progress challenges as two common forms of gamification in fitness apps (Aparicio et al.; Aydınlıyurt et al.; Cotton and Patel). Social challenges encourage participation through interaction with other users, including cooperation, competition, or peer support, or shared goals that promote motivation and accountability. Examples include Fitbit and Fitocracy, where users can compete with or support friends and teams. Progress challenges focus on individual progression by encouraging users to complete personally defined fitness tasks or milestones and rewarding their progress. Apps such as MyFitnessPal, RunKeeper, and Strava use this approach by tracking users' achievements and providing feedback, badges, or other rewards upon task completion. Csikszentmihalyi and Larson hypothesise a state of flow, in which the level of task difficulty plays a key role in sustaining engagement. In fitness apps, an easy task may involve completing a 5-minute stretching session or achieving a daily step goal that is well within a user's ability, which can become repetitive and lead to boredom if it offers little challenge. In contrast, a difficult task, such as completing a high-intensity workout or reaching an unrealistic weekly exercise target, may exceed a user's current ability and result in frustration or anxiety. When task difficulty is appropriately matched to an individual's skills, users are more likely to experience focus, enjoyment, and immersion. Similarly, Fogg’s Behaviour Model suggests that motivation and behaviour depend partly on an individual's ability to perform a task. Together, these theories suggest that gamified fitness apps should adapt task difficulty to users' changing abilities to better support sustained engagement throughout the fitness journey. However, gamified challenge tasks, ranging from easy to difficult, are more likely to function as behavioural triggers or sources of motivation than to develop users' capabilities. Lister et al. found that the use of health behaviour theory in fitness apps was positively associated with gamification, particularly with motivation, but not with users' capability or opportunity/trigger. This suggests that many gamified fitness apps primarily seek to motivate users while paying less attention to whether they have the skills and confidence to complete the activity. Consequently, gamification may encourage initial participation but fail to support sustained engagement if users' abilities and experiences are not considered over time (Michie, Van Stralen, and West). Designing Embodied Engagement in Fitness Apps This section draws on case studies and interviews conducted in this study to examine how gamified fitness experiences are shaped through users' bodily interactions with tasks and rewards. By bringing these findings together, the analysis identifies aspects of current fitness app design that may be overlooked and offers insights into participants’ lived experiences of exercise. Tasks Need to Consider the User's Ability to Grow Ring Fit Adventure is a popular fitness game developed by Nintendo for the Switch console, widely used across Asia. The game combines role-playing elements with exercise, guiding players through a narrative adventure while requiring physical movements to progress. It primarily relies on progress challenges, where users complete fitness tasks and receive rewards as they advance through levels. Ring Fit Adventure was selected as a case study because it illustrates how gamified tasks are designed in relation to users’ abilities and was frequently discussed by participants during the interviews. Examining this relationship provides a basis for considering how task difficulty supports (or hinders) sustained engagement with physical activity. The following observations draw first on existing analyses of Ring Fit Adventure before being considered alongside participants’ reflections from this study. According to Czerwonka, Alvarez, and McArthur, Ring Fit Adventure provides a useful example of how Flow Theory can be implemented in an exergame. Their analysis also highlights several limitations of the game experience that warrant further consideration. Ring Fit Adventure employs an idealised body image to motivate users. However, it fails to fully accommodate the diverse range of player body types. Players may feel further disappointed by the avatar representation on the screen, perceiving it as misrepresentative. As shown in fig. 1, players encountered difficulties during the setup process, as the game failed to recognise their readiness. Despite standing, their height was not accurately registered by the system. To overcome this issue, players had to resort to lowering the leg strap below their knees to deceive the setup system successfully. Furthermore, the yoga exercises feature an idealised female body shape, and the standardised movements do not accommodate some overweight women, leading to difficulty in performing exercises correctly or causing injuries. This highlights a gap between the designed representation of the body and the user’s lived bodily experience during interaction. Fig. 1: Ring Fit Adventureforces the player to cheat their body. Adapted from Jiang and Tham, "The Thing-Power of Ring Fit Adventure as Embodied Play: Tracing New Materialist Rhetoric across Physical and Cultural Borders." Jiang and Tham conducted a case study on Ring Fit Adventure and noted that one movement should be adaptable to different abilities. Ring Fit Adventure often instructs movements within a limited timeframe, causing frustration for some users. For example, a reviewer expressed exhaustion from attempting to keep up with the rapidly changing instructions on the screen before even starting the game. Upon reaching the end of the warm-up screen, the player felt upset by the avatar's representation, sarcastically remarking on the disparity between himself and the character. As shown in fig. 2, due to improper gestures while holding the Ring-Con, the screen consistently failed to register the completion of the "Hold" instruction. The user was unaware that their improper operation was the reason they could not proceed to the next step. Fig. 2: Ring Fit Adventure using time continuing into a “Hold” instruction. Adapted from Jiang and Tham, "The Thing-Power of Ring Fit Adventure as Embodied Play: Tracing New Materialist Rhetoric across Physical and Cultural Borders." All Ring Fit Adventure fitness tasks are completed through its narrative story mode. Once users experience the entire story, they achieve a sense of accomplishment. However, this sense of accomplishment is tied primarily to completing the game's narrative rather than to the experience itself. As a result, many users abandon Ring Fit Adventure after completing the story (Jiang and Tham). Ideally, task difficulty should increase as users’ skills and confidence develop. However, users' body shapes, abilities, endurance, and sense of accomplishment inadvertently add complexity to the task-setting process in fitness products. Rewards Need to Be Aligned with the User's Interests Reward systems such as points, coins, rewards, prizes, competitions, and challenges are widely used gamification design (McGonigal). However, compared to goal setting and social communities, rewards solely focussed on encouraging users to complete performance goals do not sustain engagement over time (Groening and Binnewies). Cotton and Patel investigated the gamification elements used in the top 50 most frequently downloaded fitness apps by iPhone users. The most frequently employed gamification elements (as shown in Table 2) were goal-setting and social influence. This is because goal-setting is easiest to design and implement, and social influence aligns with social challenges gamification. However, the use of points, levels, unlockable content, and lifelines was found to be of low frequency. Table 2: Gamification elements used in fitness apps. Gamification Feature Description Frequency of Use % Goal setting Performance-based measures and targets 25/32, 78.1 Social influences Performance is publicly displayed or ability to communicate directly with another user 25/32, 78.1 Challenges Time-limited goals or competitions 20/32, 62.5 Collaboration Work together with other members to achieve a goal 15/32, 46.9 Competition Compete with other users either head-to-head or through leaderboards 13/32, 40.6 High scores Tracking of best attempts at goals or challenges 7/32, 21.9 Badges Recognition earned for completing specific milestones 6/32, 18.8 Narrative A story is used to provide context for targeting a goal 4/32, 12.53 Streaks Recognition for consecutive goal achievement 3/32, 9.4 Points Accumulate points that help progress through game or can be redeemed for rewards 2/32, 6.3 Levels Progress through parts of the game (e.g., level 1 to level 2) or gradients of status (e.g., bronze level or silver level) 1/32, 3.1 Unlockable content Access to enhanced functionality or content for accumulating experience or achieving a specific goal 1/32, 3.1 Lifelines Ability to obtain help or gain a second chance at completing a goal 0/32, 0 Note. Adapted from Cotton and Patel's study of the most commonly used gamification features in 50 popular health and fitness apps. Studies by Hamari, Koivisto, and Sarsa and Seaborn and Fels also found that points, badges, and leaderboards, although widely recognised as core gamification elements, do not necessarily motivate users in fitness apps. Edwards et al. and Lister et al. suggest that user dissatisfaction with rewards stems from their primary focus on task completion rather than users’ individual interests or experiences. Our participants shared that praise as a form of reward does not motivate users, which aligns to Cotton and Patel’s case study, if the descriptions within the rewards feature are presented in a robotic manner. For example, “Your goal in this task is to complete fifteen exercises and advance to the next level”, “Your aim is to achieve a certain proficiency level within a specified time limit”, “You can invite other players to challenge a goal together.” In Jiang and Tham's case study on Ring Fit Adventure, phrases like "You are doing great!", "Nice!", "Well done!", and "Perfect!" in English are good. However, when these expressions are translated into another language like Chinese, Chinese players laugh because such expressions in this context are unfamiliar to their culture. Our participants further shared that many reward mechanisms are unchanging, causing users to become accustomed to rewards and pay less attention to them. This finding aligns to Skinner, who proposed that digital rewards should be allocated on a variable reinforcement schedule to maintain engagement; without this, individuals might become accustomed to receiving rewards, leading to a decrease in motivation over time. Tasks and Rewards Can Be Designed throughout the Fitness Journey The study conducted a three-hour interview and asked ‘How Might We’ questions about setting tasks and gaining rewards in fitness apps. This approach could gain deeper insights into the relationship between setting appropriately challenging tasks and motivating users through sustainable rewards within gamification strategies in fitness apps. Participants' reflections highlighted several recurring themes: The process plays a more critical role than task completion. Well-designed situations can provide participants with challenges, excitement, and emotional value, even when difficult goals are set. The data showed that participants are more engaged in the immersive experience, allowing them to forget the physical exertion. These two insights illustrate the power of immersive environments in supporting complex tasks. The concept of immersion can be central in explorations of gamification, specifically in understandings of users’ subjective feelings and flow. The reward mechanism does not necessarily need to be established only after the completion of the workout, with participants indicating that the reward mechanism during the fitness process has not yet been fully developed. Conclusion Gamification plays an important role in fitness app design, yet its current implementation does not always support sustained engagement with physical activity. This study highlights three considerations for future fitness app design: (1) tasks need to account for users’ ability to grow, (2) digital rewards should be aligned with users’ interests, and (3) tasks and rewards should be designed to accompany users throughout their fitness journey. Together these findings provide practical design considerations for using gamification to better support sustained engagement in fitness apps. Fitness apps provide an important platform for promoting physical activity, yet current evidence suggests that the implementation of gamification often emphasises motivation while overlooking other key components of health behaviour change, particularly users' capabilities and opportunities to sustain engagement. Although gamification can encourage initial participation through rewards, challenges, and social interaction, its effectiveness depends on how well these elements are integrated with behavioural theory and users' lived experiences. The findings of this review suggest that effective fitness app design should move beyond isolated game mechanics towards a more comprehensive approach that combines gamification with health behaviour theory, personalised task design, and meaningful user engagement. Such an approach has the potential to better support sustained engagement with physical activity while informing the future design of fitness apps in China. References “Analysis and Application of Gamification.” Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Interacción Persona-Ordenador. 2012. Arigo, Danielle, Leah Schumacher, and Lindsay M. Martin. “Upward Appearance Comparison and the Development of Eating Pathology in College Women.” International Journal of Eating Disorders 47.5 (2014): 467–70. Aydınlıyurt, Elif Tuğba, et al. “Continuance Intention in Gamified Mobile Applications: A Study of Behavioral Inhibition and Activation Systems.” International Journal of Information Management 61 (2021). . Cotton, Victor, and Mitesh S. Patel. “Gamification Use and Design in Popular Health and Fitness Mobile Applications.” American Journal of Health Promotion 33.3 (2019): 448–51. Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, and Reed Larson. Flow and the Foundations of Positive Psychology. Vol. 10. Dordrecht: Springer, 2014. Czerwonka, Sara, Adrian Alvarez, and Victoria McArthur. “One Ring Fit to Rule Them All? An Analysis of Avatar Bodies and Customization in Exergames.” Frontiers in Psychology 12 (2021). . Deterding, Sebastian, et al. “From Game Design Elements to Gamefulness: Defining ‘Gamification.’” Proceedings of the 15th International Academic MindTrek Conference: Envisioning Future Media Environments. Tampere, Finland, 2011. 9–15. Edwards, Elizabeth Ann, et al. “Gamification for Health Promotion: Systematic Review of Behaviour Change Techniques in Smartphone Apps.” BMJ Open 6.10 (2016). . Fogg, B.J. “A Behavior Model for Persuasive Design.” Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Persuasive Technology. Claremont, CA, 2009. Grand View Research. “China Fitness App Market Size & Outlook, 2033.” Grand View Research, 2026. . Groening, Christopher, and Carmen Binnewies. “‘Achievement Unlocked!’—The Impact of Digital Achievements as a Gamification Element on Motivation and Performance.” Computers in Human Behavior 97 (2019): 151–66. Hamari, Juho, Jonna Koivisto, and Harri Sarsa. “Does Gamification Work?—A Literature Review of Empirical Studies on Gamification.” Proceedings of the 47th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. IEEE, 2014. 3025–34. . Hao, Ming, et al. “Relationship between Body Dissatisfaction, Insufficient Physical Activity, and Disordered Eating Behaviors among University Students in Southern China.” BMC Public Health 22.1 (2022). . Hu, Shuchen, et al. “Chinese TikTok (Douyin) Challenges and Body Image Concerns: A Pilot Study.” Journal of Eating Disorders 11.1 (2023). . Jiang, Jialei, and Jason Tham. “The Thing-Power of Ring Fit Adventure as Embodied Play: Tracing New Materialist Rhetoric across Physical and Cultural Borders.” Computers and Composition 65 (2022). . Krebs, Paul, and Dustin Duncan. “Health App Use among US Mobile Phone Owners: A National Survey.” JMIR mHealth and uHealth 3 (2015). . Kumar, J., and Mario Herger. Gamification at Work: Designing Engaging Business Software. Interaction Design Foundation, 2013. . Lister, Cameron, et al. “Just a Fad? Gamification in Health and Fitness Apps.” JMIR Serious Games 2.2 (2014). . Localytics. “Mobile App Retention Rate: What’s a Good Retention Rate?” Upland, 2021. . Market Research Future. “China Fitness App Market Size, Share and Research Report.” Market Research Future, 2026. . McGonigal, Jane. “Gaming Can Make a Better World.” TED, 2010. . Michie, Susan, Maartje M. van Stralen, and Robert West. “The Behaviour Change Wheel: A New Method for Characterising and Designing Behaviour Change Interventions.” Implementation Science 6.1 (2011): 1–12. Nie, Xueqiong, et al. “The Association between Health Literacy and Self-Rated Health among Residents of China Aged 15–69 Years.” American Journal of Preventive Medicine 60.4 (2021): 569–78. SaaS. “The App Dominating China’s Fitness Market and Inspiring Millions.” Daxue Consulting, 2023. . Seaborn, Katie, and Deborah I. Fels. “Gamification in Theory and Action: A Survey.” International Journal of Human-Computer Studies 74 (2015): 14–31. Sibor, Douglas, Gregory L. Stoller, and Wenjun Wang. Lefit: Keeping the Chinese Workout Market Fit. Sage Business Cases Originals. Sage, 2020. Skinner, Burrhus Frederic. The Behavior of Organisms: An Experimental Analysis. Cambridge, MA: B. F. Skinner Foundation, 2019. Wei, Jiuchang, et al. “Understanding and Predicting the Adoption of Fitness Mobile Apps: Evidence from China.” Health Communication 36.8 (2021): 950–61. Xu, Xiaoyan, et al. “Body Dissatisfaction, Engagement in Body Change Behaviors and Sociocultural Influences on Body Image among Chinese Adolescents.” Body Image 7.2 (2010): 156–64. Zhou, L., Z. Wang, and Z. Tuo. “Sports Fitness Industry in China.” The Global Private Health & Fitness Business: A Marketing Perspective. Emerald, 2021. Zichermann, Gabe, and Christopher Cunningham. Gamification by Design: Implementing Game Mechanics in Web and Mobile Apps. Sebastopol, CA: O’Reilly Media, 2011.
Zitieren
APA
Zhou, J., & Jung, J. (2026). Designing Embodied Engagement Strategies to Support Health Goals in Fitness Apps. M/C Journal, 29(4). https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3286
Vancouver
Zhou J, Jung J. Designing Embodied Engagement Strategies to Support Health Goals in Fitness Apps. M/C Journal. 2026;29(4). doi:10.5204/mcj.3286
BibTeX
@article{Zhou2026,
author = {Zhou, Jing and Jung, Jo},
title = {Designing Embodied Engagement Strategies to Support Health Goals in Fitness Apps},
journal = {M/C Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {29},
number = {4},
doi = {10.5204/mcj.3286}
}
EUVIMED