EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY-NC-ND 4.0

Teaching, Improvising, Galumphing?

Daniel Hirsch

M/C Journal · 12.08.2026 · 29 (4)

DOI: 10.5204/mcj.3222 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift M/C Journal, online erschienen am 12.08.2026. Verfasst von Daniel Hirsch. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

It is almost two years since I stopped teaching in a secondary school in Magandjin/Brisbane, Australia. I could feel myself cracking, becoming cynical and worn down by the expectations of the education system—a system that, I felt, was less and less interested in the people involved and more interested in standardisation and the data and results these people produced. I could feel my teaching becoming restricted by external values that ran counter to my own. My individuality and ethics as a person with experiences and thoughts were becoming less and less important. The ideas and wonderings of my students had diminishing space in which to be heard and considered. I felt I needed some time away. Teacher and scholar Margie Appel explains this well, highlighting a professional and systemic imbalance in Australian schools perniciously affecting teachers, noting a lack of professional autonomy, stifled creativity for teachers and students, and an absence of trust in teachers from school leaders. Black feminist educator and critic bell hooks reflects on her own experiences of needing time away from teaching. She describes a sense of gloom, her diminishing energy, and the sense her classroom was beginning to feel like “a closed-down space” (Teaching Community 13). She writes that she no longer had the energy to cope with the systemic and cultural “obstacles” that had always been there. She too keenly felt a need for some time away from teaching to reconsider and reflect, to create an opportunity for herself to “think of new ways to be immersed in teaching” (Teaching Community 21). hooks’s writing is honest and sounds deeply with me. There is sadness in her realisation­—a mourning for something lost and a recognition of something that cannot be unfelt. But there is also hope and possibility and strength as she continues to teach in a new and renewed way. These teacherly feelings draw me to communication scholar Bryant Keith Alexander’s reflexive concept of standing in the wake. Alexander uses the metaphor of standing in the wake to “represent a time after experience for critical reflection” (98), describing this phrase as “a metaphor for reflexivity, a critical act of standing in the present critically reflecting on past experience, a positionality” (105). He describes the wake as “the rack left in water by a vessel or any other body moving through it” (103) and “a stream of turbulence” (104). In my case, time away from high school teaching has afforded me distance from it and a new perspective on what my teaching might be/be becoming. While this decision has, in some ways, created turbulence, it has also provided a stillness and calm from the pressures and fast tempos of a high school. I am standing in the wake of my teaching and teacherlyness but still very much in, and surrounded by, the waters of it. To clarify, this article is not me reflecting on my teaching experience—the number of years spent doing so, the subjects, the specific lessons, the year levels, and so on—but rather an account of my experience teaching. How do I experience teaching? How does my teaching feel? Curriculum scholar Ted Aoki encourages us to shift our educational discourse away from technical rationality and the doing of teaching and towards the presence and thoughtfulness found in the being of teaching. He reminds us that in our attempts to understand teaching we should try to “reorient ourselves … so that we can see and hear our doings as teaching harboured within pedagogical being, so we can see and hear who we are as teachers” (197, emphasis in original). Aoki’s writings resonate with musical terminology and sonorous observations. He suggests the improvisation of curriculum, the sound and the silence found in classrooms. He asks us to listen to, to hear, to be attuned to our teaching, to move beyond the “ocularcentrism in Western epistemology” (xvi). He is feeling teaching. When I think of my experience teaching, it is these ideas of sounds, attunement, feeling, and presence that call out to me. In what follows, I stand in the wake, reflecting upon my teaching and my teacherlyness, focussing on the feelings of improvising, joy, and galumphing. Teaching feels like improvising but not in a metaphorical sense. I am an improvising musician, taught and playing mostly in the jazz tradition, and the doing and the being of teaching feels remarkably similar to the doing and being of playing this music. Improvisation isn’t unprepared, but it can be unpredictable. Improvisation can be interactive, responsive, and highly collaborative. Artistic freedom and expression can be found within structures and rules. Exemplary in this area are written works by Keith Sawyer, Ingrid Monson, Daniel Fischlin, and musical works: Spirograph Studies, and Ron Miles. Recently, I’ve begun rehearsing again with a jazz trio: saxophone, double bass, and drums. I play the drums. We are playing original music written by the saxophone player, Luke, for a series of performances and an upcoming recording, but also just to play music together. We’ve been playing together on and off for several years, but from the first rehearsal, this time around felt different. Luke writes what he fondly refers to as sketches of songs: ideas that grab him unexpectedly and demand to be written down immediately. He’s been notating these ideas differently, in a digital notebook (as opposed to musical notation software), as there is a freedom in the process of writing this way, he says, where the unfinished idea that tumbles out feels less fixed and aesthetically more open to being developed, changed, questioned (for example, see fig. 1). As a fellow ensemble member, my experience of this music is also different: the very fact that the notes don’t look as final on the page as notation software renders, there is ambiguity as to placement, and mistakes where Luke has written something 'wrong', or forgotten to include something harmonically or rhythmically important, means there is possibility and openness in this music. The sketches are inviting us all in to learn them and wanting our ideas and voices to join them. Fig. 1: Eerie/Beautiful. Image courtesy of Luke. This music visually welcomes collaboration and questions. This is music unsure what it might sound like. And we are musicians wondering how we might play it and how we might make it sound. Alongside these sketches, Luke tells us his inspiration or intentions for each song. These can be very clear or quite vague. But regardless, there is something within each sketch that resonates strongly within him that he wants to share, even if it is just the joyful feeling of playing the melody. The experience of playing this music and playing in this ensemble is how I try to teach in the classroom. What I mean by this is that there is openness, opportunity, and unexpectedness in these rehearsals but there is also preparation, a perspective, and a possible outcome. We three meet knowing that we will be learning and making music together but not knowing what that might sound like or how far we might get in that process. Education theorist Gert Biesta writes about what he believes to be two fundamental elements of teaching: showing and explaining (44–8). The teacher shows something they think is interesting, or worth noticing, to their students, and offers them an explanation of what they feel is noteworthy, but also gives their students space to critique it, consider it in their own way, and offer their thoughts. Critical education theorist Paulo Freire provides a similar notion that he terms “a little introductory exposition” (123), in which a teacher makes a brief presentation of a subject and then students and teacher analyse and question together the subject and presentation. He writes that in this way, “the teacher challenges the students, who thereupon question themselves and question the teacher, and thereby share in plumbing the depths of, developing, the initial exposition” (123). In this process, the teacherly act becomes less about instruction and more about invitation. Students are invited into the teacher’s thinking but do not conform to it, nor are they limited by it. The object and subject provide an opportunity for individual and collaborative thinking and reflection on the object and the self as the students bring their selves to bear on the object. I feel this is what Luke is offering to us in these rehearsals. Just as students and teacher in the classroom environments I foster, we three too gather around the thing Luke is showing us and explaining to us (his composition) and bring our perspectives to bear on it. We all regard it, think about it, play and improvise with it, and with each other and through this process we come to know this composition, ourselves, and each other a little more. We each bring different perspectives to bear on this composition and, as such, may notice different things or derive meanings different from Luke’s, which are then shared with the group sonically through our music-making and through discussions during and after each rehearsal. These rehearsals are full of risk-taking, mistakes, conversation, listening, joy: improvisation. These rehearsals are full of the sound of learning and teaching and creating. These rehearsals are lessons. Our music-making, our improvising, is our learning. This feels like my teaching. Teaching feels joyful; teaching is joyful. This seems somewhat contrary to what I outlined in the opening to this piece, and in some ways it is, but it is also a crucial part of my experience. hooks argues the need “to emphasize that the pleasure of teaching is an act of resistance countering the overwhelming boredom, uninterest, and apathy that so often characterize the way professors and students feel” (Teaching to Transgress 10). And I do feel these feelings too. I have been very bored and uninterested in the classroom and school setting. There is much in the culture and systems of education that demands a beige compliance among teachers and students, a systemic stultification, to borrow philosopher Jacques Ranciere’s (7) term, which sneaks slowly to numb and deaden the minds and bodies and places and things that reside in a school. But despite the systemic pressures and the mechanical focus on outcomes and data, there is much joy to be found. There is much joy I find in teaching. There is the joy I feel when a student has a 'moment'—something is suddenly understood, unveiled, connected. This is a combination of my internal satisfaction and happiness for the student, coupled with the obvious joy the student is experiencing and sharing. There is the pure joy in being in and among the space of my classroom, in with the learning, so to speak. This is a vibrant and alive place in which to reside, a place rich in ideas upon which I could base or create further lessons. There is the joy found outside the classroom or after the lesson, sometimes in the staffroom talking with colleagues, or even the walk from one classroom to the next—the reflective joy when I am thinking back on a lesson of which I am particularly proud, or the student’s 'moment', or a sequence of a lesson, or an idea that I hoped would 'work', even if I didn’t know how, and that I felt really did. One of the best joys, though, is the sense of being on the edge of something, collaboratively. Something unexpected has emerged in the lesson, and it feels exciting. This is a vanguard in the lesson. Unexpected, unpredictable, full of possibility and opportunity. It draws everyone in. No one is entirely sure where this is all going, or maybe how it even arrived, but suddenly there is energy in the room and a combination of intense focus, listening, and openness. Multiple voices are speaking, their ideas overlapping as they rush out. I may have withdrawn slightly from the centre of the action, off to one side observing, but maybe offering ideas too, probably laughing, asking questions, following the threads. Or perhaps I am in the thick of it, connecting people’s ideas together, sharing my own, or just sitting among it listening to the lesson being created in real time as we are all swept up in joyful enthusiasm. These moments sound rowdy and happy. These moments sound like Luke’s rehearsals. They feel like improvising. What is remarkable is that despite the pressures on teachers, these joyful moments happen. And these joyful moments spread throughout the culture of that group and that room. They bounce back off the walls and resonate within the classroom space. Their echoes remind everyone that this is a space where joy, and silliness, and curiosity can live alongside rows of desks, assessment dates, and effort. Because the presence of joy and happiness in a classroom or teaching practice does not suggest the absence of focus, professionalism, intention, or learning. As educator Ron Scapp reminds us, “joy can be present along with hard work. Not every moment in the classroom will necessarily be one that brings you immediate pleasure, but that doesn't preclude the possibility of joy” (in hooks, Teaching to Transgress 154). The possibility of joy. Hard work does not preclude the possibility of joy, and joy does not preclude the possibility of hard work. Practising the drums can be hard work, and learning music can be hard work, and teaching can be too, but all can be immensely joyful. Teaching feels like it might be galumphing, and this is a new feeling, one that has emerged in my time away—an exciting, unfinished thought that brings me to the end of this writing. This new feeling is founded on, and found in, experiences of improvising and joy such as I have described above. Galumphing is a term not really found in any educational literature or writing, save a couple of old online music education blogs such as this one. Galumphing is a nonce word created by Lewis Carroll in Through the Looking-Glass from the nonsense poem within, 'Jabberwocky', to describe the heavy, triumphant galloping return of the hero of the poem after vanquishing the monstrous Jabberwock: “One, two! One, two! And through and through / The vorpal blade went snicker-snack! / He left it dead, and with its head / He went galumphing back” (132). Anthropologist Stephen Miller uses the term “galumph” to describe the “unique ‘galumphing’ quality” he observes in the physical play of juvenile baboons, which “involves much flailing, bobbing, exaggeration, and indirect, ineffective action” (89). It now also describes the movement of seals on land and is sung in the children’s song Der Glumph/Galumph Went the Little Green Frog. Improviser, musician, and educator Stephen Nachmanovitch extends Miller’s concept, weaving galumphing and its joyful, play-based elements explicitly into modes of creativity and making art. Nachmanovitch writes that galumphing is the seemingly useless elaboration and ornamentation of activity. It is profligate, excessive, exaggerated, uneconomical. We galumph when we hop instead of walk, when we take the scenic route instead of the efficient one, when we play a game whose rules demand a limitation of our powers, when we are interested in means rather than in ends. (26–7) Miller explains that galumphing operates within the hierarchies of social groups and yet the play-based feature of it is “ahierarchical” (90), as younger animals invite older, more senior animals to play. It is a collaborative activity within the hierarchy of the social group that allows for a flexibility but overall retention in roles. Galumphing doesn’t suspend the notion of rules or outcomes either. Rather, those engaged in the activity create specific rules or “obstacles”, as Miller (91) and Nachmanovitch (44) describe, which are embedded as part of the play. These obstacles are voluntarily created purely for the pleasure of overcoming them (Nachmanovitch 44). I think my teaching feels like galumphing. Perhaps most pertinent to me is that there is a valuing of process over outcomes or results, but not at the exclusion of them. The feeling of collective improvisation on the edge of something emerging in a classroom is an experience that is one of being in the process: responding to unexpected questions and replying with my own; spending fifteen minutes talking about my new favourite hat; or sitting with a group of students and listening to their ideas, telling them they are all brilliant, and then walking away to do something else. This might be galumphing in the classroom. This joyful vanguard reframes the roles in the classroom, as those participating are brought into the space to play with ideas together. The joy here is found in the unexpectedness and surprise that this playful moment welcomes and the new obstacles that are created in the process. Unlike the imposition of external obstacles, these are personalised and bespoke to this moment; they are our obstacles, representative of the character of our classroom. As the teacher, I strive to keep us hopping and skipping along in this elaborated means to an end, interacting and responding to the class, knowing that the end—or better yet, an end—will reveal itself, that the process is the purpose. As Miller explains, this type of play “is not means without the end; it is a crooked line to the end; it circumnavigates obstacles put there by the player or voluntarily acceded to” (93). Luke’s music is full of crooked lines that welcome the ornamentation of our musical interpretations, and we create our own obstacles: What if we played it like this? Can we change that? I’m going to try this. This music is being created to be shared—the ends of our rehearsals—but we spend much more time revelling in the joyful galumphing along the way. The values that underpin my teaching—joy, improvisation, play, collaboration, listening—feel like galumphing. There is a lot galumphing may reveal about education that is beyond the scope of this article, which I will be returning to in future writing as I consider ‘galumphing in the classroom’ in more depth. Both Luke’s jazz and ensemble and my classroom are framed by hierarchies, ends, and obstacles. There are rules and expectations that are socially recognised and even required. But there is joyful freedom and improvisation too. A galumphing quality can be found within these spaces. My teaching feels like galumphing? References Alexander, Bryant Keith. “Standing in the Wake: A Critical Auto/Ethnographic Exercise on Reflexivity in Three Movements.” Cultural Studies – Critical Methodologies 11.2 (2011): 98–107. Aoki, Ted. “Layered Voices of Teaching: The Uncannily Correct and The Elusively True (1992).” Curriculum in a New Key: The Collected Works of Ted T. Aoki. Eds. William F. Pinar and Rita L. Irwin. Routledge, 2011. 187-98. Appel, Margie. “Performativity and the Demise of the Teaching Profession: The Need for Rebalancing in Australia.” Asia Pacific Journal of Teacher Education 48.3 (2020): 301-5. Biesta, Gert. Letting Art Teach. ArtEZ P, 2017. Carroll, Lewis. Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking-Glass. Penguin Books, 1872/1998. Fischlin, Daniel. “Worldmaking Pedagogies: Improvising as Learning / Leaning as Improvisation.” The Improviser’s Classroom: Pedagogies for Cocreative Worldmaking. Eds. Daniel Fischlin and Mark Lomanno. Temple UP, 2024. Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of Hope. Bloomsbury, 1994/2021. hooks, bell. Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of Hope. Routledge, 2003. ———. Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom. Routledge, 1994. “Jabberwocky by Lewis Carroll.” Poetry Foundation. 15 Sep. 2026 . “Megan Washington Performs Der Glumph.” YouTube, uploaded by ABC Kids, 18 July 2022. . Miles, Ron. Old Main Chapel, Blue Note Records, 2024. YouTube. . Miller, Stephen. “Ends, Means, and Galumphing: Some Leitmotifs of Play.” American Anthropologist 75.1 (1973): 87–98. Monson, Ingrid. Saying Something: Jazz Improvisation and Interaction. U of Chicago P, 1996. Music Improv. “’Galumphing’ in the Classroom.” Improvisation in Music Education, 26 Feb. 2008. 26 July 2025 . Nachmanovitch, Stephen. FreePlay: Improvisation in Life and Art. Penguin Putnam, 1990. ———. The Art of Is: Improvising as a Way of Life. New World Library, 2019. Pinar, William. “Foreword.” Curriculum in a New Key: The Collected Works of Ted T. Aoki. Eds. William F. Pinar and Rita L. Irwin. Routledge, 2011. xv-xvii. Ranciere, Jacques. The Ignorant School Master: Five Lessons in Intellectual Emancipation. Trans. Kristin Ross. Stanford UP, 1991. Sawyer, Keith. The Creative Classroom: Innovative Teaching for the 21st-Century. Teachers College P, 2019. Spirograph Studies. Kindness, Not Courtesy, Opening Gambit Music, 2019. YouTube. . “Your Visual Guide to Sea Lion and Seal Behaviour.” The Marine Mammal Center, 18 Feb. 2025. 9 Aug. 2025 .

Zitieren

APA

Hirsch, D. (2026). Teaching, Improvising, Galumphing?. M/C Journal, 29(4). https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3222

Vancouver

Hirsch D. Teaching, Improvising, Galumphing?. M/C Journal. 2026;29(4). doi:10.5204/mcj.3222

BibTeX
@article{Hirsch2026,
  author = {Hirsch, Daniel},
  title = {Teaching, Improvising, Galumphing?},
  journal = {M/C Journal},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {29},
  number = {4},
  doi = {10.5204/mcj.3222}
}
Kostenlos starten →