Human academic ghostwriting after ChatGPT: Academic labour outsourcing and process ownership in higher education
Borneo International Journal of Education (BIJE) · 11.10.2026 · 8 (1) · 135-152
DOI: 10.51200/bije.v8i1.8397 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Borneo International Journal of Education (BIJE), online erschienen am 11.10.2026. Verfasst von Yow Siang Lee. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Academic ghostwriting is a form of contract cheating in which assessed work is produced by a third party, creating an academic-integrity problem that cannot be reduced to textual similarity. This qualitative single-case study examines how an experienced Malaysian academic ghostwriter adapted to the emergence and subsequent diffusion of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) between 2022 and 2026. The participant, “Xiaofen”, is a doctoral graduate who provided paid academic writing services before ChatGPT and continued operating after its widespread adoption. The data comprise two published investigative reports, a newly conducted asynchronous semi-structured written interview, and six purposively sampled public Facebook advertisements. Reflexive thematic analysis indicates that, in this case, GenAI devalued routine undergraduate writing but complemented the provider’s higher-order work. She shifted her focus towards postgraduate and time-poor clients, incorporated several paid GenAI tools, and expanded from text production to end-to-end academic labour outsourcing involving topic formulation, revision management, data-related support, and viva preparation. The case does not establish the prevalence or direction of Malaysia’s wider ghostwriting market. Instead, it offers a task-based explanation: automation substitutes for routine drafting while complementing non-routine coordination, verification, judgement, and client management. Higher education institutions should therefore supplement text detection with staged, dialogic, and verifiable assessment practices that make students’ ownership of the academic process visible. Penulisan akademik secara upahan ialah satu bentuk penipuan kontrak akademik apabila tugasan yang dinilai dihasilkan oleh pihak ketiga. Amalan ini menimbulkan masalah integriti akademik yang tidak dapat dikenal pasti melalui pemeriksaan persamaan teks semata-mata. Kajian kes kualitatif ini meneliti bagaimana seorang penulis akademik upahan berpengalaman di Malaysia menyesuaikan perkhidmatannya dengan kemunculan dan penggunaan meluas kecerdasan buatan generatif (GenAI) antara tahun 2022 hingga 2026. Peserta kajian, “Xiaofen”, ialah pemegang ijazah kedoktoran yang menawarkan perkhidmatan penulisan akademik berbayar sebelum kemunculan ChatGPT dan terus beroperasi selepas teknologi tersebut digunakan secara meluas. Data kajian terdiri daripada dua laporan penyiasatan yang diterbitkan, satu temu bual bertulis separa berstruktur secara tidak segerak, dan enam iklan Facebook awam yang dipilih melalui persampelan bertujuan. Analisis tematik refleksif menunjukkan bahawa, dalam kes ini, GenAI mengurangkan nilai penulisan rutin pada peringkat prasiswazah tetapi melengkapi kerja aras tinggi penyedia perkhidmatan tersebut. Beliau beralih kepada pelanggan pascasiswazah dan pelanggan yang menghadapi kekangan masa, menggunakan beberapa alat GenAI berbayar, serta memperluas perkhidmatannya daripada penghasilan teks kepada penyumberluaran tenaga kerja akademik secara menyeluruh yang merangkumi perumusan tajuk, pengurusan semakan, sokongan berkaitan data dan persediaan peperiksaan lisan (viva). Kes ini tidak membuktikan kelaziman atau hala tuju pasaran penulisan akademik upahan di Malaysia secara keseluruhan. Sebaliknya, kajian ini menawarkan penjelasan berasaskan tugas: automasi menggantikan penulisan rutin sambil melengkapi koordinasi, pengesahan, pertimbangan dan pengurusan pelanggan yang tidak rutin. Oleh itu, institusi pendidikan tinggi disarankan supaya melengkapi pengesanan teks dengan amalan pentaksiran berperingkat, dialogik dan boleh disahkan yang memperlihatkan pemilikan pelajar terhadap proses akademik.
Zitieren
APA
Lee, Y. S. (2026). Human academic ghostwriting after ChatGPT: Academic labour outsourcing and process ownership in higher education. Borneo International Journal of Education (BIJE), 8(1), 135-152. https://doi.org/10.51200/bije.v8i1.8397
Vancouver
Lee YS. Human academic ghostwriting after ChatGPT: Academic labour outsourcing and process ownership in higher education. Borneo International Journal of Education (BIJE). 2026;8(1):135-152. doi:10.51200/bije.v8i1.8397
BibTeX
@article{Lee2026,
author = {Lee, Yow Siang},
title = {Human academic ghostwriting after ChatGPT: Academic labour outsourcing and process ownership in higher education},
journal = {Borneo International Journal of Education (BIJE)},
year = {2026},
volume = {8},
number = {1},
pages = {135--152},
doi = {10.51200/bije.v8i1.8397}
}
EUVIMED