Nuevo modelo de evaluación de la Interacción Persona-Robot en entornos industriales: ITPX-ROBOTS
eRepository Mondragon University (Mondragon University) · 01.01.2023
DOI: 10.48764/xen9-ax07 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift eRepository Mondragon University (Mondragon University), erschienen am 01.01.2023. Verfasst von Ainhoa Apraiz.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The Industry 5.0 has as its main pillar the well-being of people, thus redefining the role of individuals and transforming current job positions into formats that are still unknown. This research focuses on one of the most relevant challenges for Industry 5.0: Human-Robot Interaction (HRI), specifically in scenarios where people and robots share the same workspace to achieve a common goal in a synchronized, cooperative, or collaborative manner. The number of robots in the manufacturing industry has significantly increased over the past few decades, and in recent years, the number and variety of industries using robots have also grown. However, for robots to become allies of the users, they must provide positive and purposeful experiences through smooth and satisfactory interactions so that people can accept this new technology. In this context, User Experience (UX) emerges as a fundamental framework that connects people with robots, with its evaluation being an essential task. With the aim of ensuring the successful acceptance of robots by people, this research introduces the ITPX-ROBOTS model (Individual Task Performance Experience - Robots) as a proposal to assess the suitability of robotic systems in relation to individuals and to evaluate task achievement in terms of performance, physiology, and perception. This model allows for a comprehensive evaluation of Human-Robot Interaction (HRI), merging both hedonic and pragmatic approaches. The model provides valuable insights into the dynamics of HRI, contributing to improving efficiency and effectiveness in the workplace. In this context, this doctoral thesis introduces the conceptual framework of Human-Robot Interaction Experience (HRIX), which illustrates how the alignment between the characteristics of the entities involved in the interaction (person, robot, and context) impacts the User Experience (UX) and its components. In the HRI environment, these components include utility, ease of use, comfort, learnability, and controllability. All of these factors have consequences for human-related factors such as attitude and intention to use, trust, perceived safety, and satisfaction. Furthermore, the model is based on the Human-Robot-Context taxonomy (HUBOXT), which identifies (i) the characteristics of the person that influence the acceptance of HRI, (ii) the characteristics of the robot that influence the acceptance of HRI, and (iii) the characteristics of the context that influence the acceptance of HRI, divided into micro-context and macro-context characteristics. Taking into account the conceptual framework and the taxonomy, the ITPX-ROBOTS model is proposed, which is divided into three phases, following a holistic approach to UX evaluations, in line with the ITPX model (Mazmela, 2020). These three stages encompass: (i) the pre-interaction evaluation, which focuses on expert evaluation using heuristics; (ii) the evaluation during the interaction, which involves collecting performance indicators and physiological parameters during the execution of tasks with the robot; and (iii) the post-interaction evaluation, which focuses on obtaining user perceptions about the interaction they have experienced with the robot. To execute the pre-interaction phase, heuristic evaluation emerges as a low-cost and easily implementable method that can be applied iteratively in various stages of the design process. In this context, HEUROBOX has been developed, a new set of heuristics that groups design guidelines into a logical list of heuristics for evaluating the interaction between people and robots in industrial environments. HEUROBOX consists of 84 heuristics for basic evaluation and 228 heuristics for advanced evaluation, allowing the tool to be adapted to different industrial requirements. Finally, the set of new heuristics has been validated by experts using the System Usability Scale (SUS) questionnaire and the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). To complement the post-interaction phase, the HUROX questionnaire has been developed, designed to evaluate the User Experience (UX) in interactions with robots in industrial environments. It has been developed using an empirical approach for item selection to ensure their practical relevance. Through psychometric analysis, where experts have evaluated each of the items for importance, necessity, relevance, and clarity, the questionnaire has been validated. The experimental phase of the model has been carried out through two case studies, one related to an assembly task and the other to a disassembly task. The results reveal that the ITPX-ROBOTS model helps diagnose the success of HRI, providing a procedure that facilitates the analysis of the impact of robots on task accomplishment and user perception. Consequently, the thesis presents a model to gain a deeper understanding of the integration of robots, which will enable the optimization of industrial processes, improve quality, and increase productivity effectively. The document details the development process of the ITPX-ROBOTS model in several chapters. In the first chapter, after providing context, the research objectives and hypotheses are listed, along with the research methodology employed. The second chapter encompasses the scientific and technological framework and consists of five sub-chapters. Firstly, it provides an overview of HRI in the literature, establishing fundamental concepts. Next, it conducts a systematic literature review of evaluation models used to measure UX and technological acceptance in HRI in industrial environments. Following that, this systematic review is updated with new advancements identified in the literature. Then, it details the methods and metrics used to assess UX and acceptance, focusing on psychophysiological evaluation and user perception through questionnaires. Finally, to conclude the scientific and technological framework, a critical analysis of the state of the art is conducted, discussing possible contributions and identified research opportunities. The third chapter introduces the ITPX-ROBOTS model. Here, it describes the theoretical foundations that underpin its creation and defines the key elements that make up this new model, as well as the experimental procedure. The fourth chapter is dedicated to the development and validation of the heuristic evaluation tool HEUROBOX. In the fifth chapter, the development and validation of the HUROX questionnaire are presented. In the sixth chapter, the case studies validating the model in its entirety are described. Finally, in the last chapter, conclusions are presented, and the hypotheses are confirmed. Furthermore, the most relevant contributions of the research are highlighted. Some of the significant contributions of this study include: A new model for evaluating Human-Robot Interaction in industrialenvironments, named ITPX-ROBOTS. A new list of heuristic evaluation criteria for Human-Robot Interaction inindustrial environments, named HEUROBOX. A new questionnaire for assessing user perceptions in Human-RobotInteraction in industrial environments, named HUROX.
Schlagwörter
Zitieren
APA
Apraiz, A. (2023). Nuevo modelo de evaluación de la Interacción Persona-Robot en entornos industriales: ITPX-ROBOTS. eRepository Mondragon University (Mondragon University). https://doi.org/10.48764/xen9-ax07
Vancouver
Apraiz A. Nuevo modelo de evaluación de la Interacción Persona-Robot en entornos industriales: ITPX-ROBOTS. eRepository Mondragon University (Mondragon University). 2023. doi:10.48764/xen9-ax07
BibTeX
@article{Apraiz2023,
author = {Apraiz, Ainhoa},
title = {Nuevo modelo de evaluación de la Interacción Persona-Robot en entornos industriales: ITPX-ROBOTS},
journal = {eRepository Mondragon University (Mondragon University)},
year = {2023},
doi = {10.48764/xen9-ax07}
}
EUVIMED