Contextual restriction and faultless disagreement about generics across development
eScholarship (California Digital Library) · 18.06.2025
DOI: 10.48448/k4y6-bd81 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift eScholarship (California Digital Library), erschienen am 18.06.2025. Verfasst von Cognitive Science Society 2025 und 7 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
We report a study examining developmental changes in perceptions of disagreements among speakers who use generics to describe contextually-restricted or unrestricted regularities. Sixty-five adults and 222 5-12-year-olds reacted to generic claims from speakers who attributed ostensibly contradictory attributes to a biological kind (“Xs are striped”; “Xs are spotted”). Crucially, we manipulated the scope of each speaker’s claim, described as restricted to a specific context, or unrestricted. Participants assessed faultless disagreement (whether the speakers could “both be right”). Adults were sensitive to contextual restriction: they allowed for faultless disagreement when contextual restrictions mis-aligned, and denied it when both speakers restricted to one context. Young children demonstrated striking partial competence in faultless disagreement judgments much earlier than prior developmental literature suggested. This is the first study to document faultless disagreement between differentially-restricted generics, both in adults and in children. We discuss the developmental trajectory, and implications for social functioning and learning.
Schlagwörter
Zitieren
APA
2025, C. S. S., Campos, G., Caoile, J., Curiel, A., Khurelkhuu, S., Ritchie, K., Rouzbehani, B., & Vasil, N. (2025). Contextual restriction and faultless disagreement about generics across development. eScholarship (California Digital Library). https://doi.org/10.48448/k4y6-bd81
Vancouver
2025 CSS, Campos G, Caoile J, Curiel A, Khurelkhuu S, Ritchie K, et al. Contextual restriction and faultless disagreement about generics across development. eScholarship (California Digital Library). 2025. doi:10.48448/k4y6-bd81
BibTeX
@article{2025,
author = {2025, Cognitive Science Society and Campos, Gaia and Caoile, Jason and Curiel, Alejandro and Khurelkhuu, suren and Ritchie, Katherine and Rouzbehani, Bahar and Vasil, Ny},
title = {Contextual restriction and faultless disagreement about generics across development},
journal = {eScholarship (California Digital Library)},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.48448/k4y6-bd81}
}
EUVIMED