Dimensioni, processi ed esiti del privato in sanità
Sistema Salute · 2024 · 8 (3) · 339-363
DOI: 10.48291/sisa.68.3.8 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Sistema Salute, 2024. Verfasst von Carlo Romagnoli.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Key words: “Health impact”, “health system impact” e “private health providers”, framework
SUMMARY
The main expressions of the private sector in health care are represented by private agreements for hospital care, out-of-hospital care (territorial, diagnostic, specialist) and residential care, by the direct expenditure of families (Out Of Pocket: OOP) for examinations, analyses, medicines, admissions, etc., and by the expenditure intermediated by private funds and insurances activated for the most part through trade union agreements. Objectives: to describe for each of the three types of private investment in health care for Italy and the Italian regions – with an exemplifying focus on Umbria – dimensions, development in the care processes, outcomes for the patient and the eco-social health system.
Materials and methods: three lines of bibliographic research were activated on: a) systematic reviews and studies on the effects of the private sector in health care; b) ministerial and national agency reports containing data on the phenomenon under investigation; frameworks capable of describing the outcomes for the patient and for the socio-health care eco-system.
Results: a) the available scientific literature does not show any benefits of the private sector in health care, nor does it suggest that it is not inferior to public management, given the negative findings in terms of unequal access to effective care, safety, quality of care, costs for citizens and payers, spoliation of care functions, centrality of illness to sustain business, competition for scarce resources such as funds and personnel, and well-known problems of regulation and compliance with rules and contracts; b) data are available that illustrate, for each type, development in Italy and at the level of each region, with greater growth in out-of-hospital care, where the sectors of laboratory and instrumental diagnostics, specialist care (not only dentistry, now all the branches are involved) and residential care are contracted out in a prevalent share to the accredited private sector, while in hospital care many important regions have a third or more (Lazio) of accredited private facilities; OOP expenditure accounts for more than 20 per cent of the total healthcare expenditure; intermediated expenditure has a heterogeneous and alternating trend linked to the difficulties in guaranteeing stable profit conditions, which could lead to further state measures to guarantee this sector; c) the measures of health outcomes for the patient and for the ecosystem systematised in the framework proposed here, highlight the shortcomings expected on the basis of the literature data, with the complication that as a result of the forty years of service to the private sector of the neo-liberal Italian state, a series of strings and ties have been imposed on the NHS that considerably limit its quality, making it ‘convenient’ for those who can afford it to resort to the private sector.
Conclusions: this study, by measuring the development and criticality of the private sector in health care, supports the identification and development of targeted policies to counter it at the national and regional levels, making it clear that the convenience of resorting to the private sector is the result of an artificial dysregulation of the public service, to resolve which it is necessary to return to policies of appropriate organisation of health care systems and participatory planning, given the evidence available on the market’s inability to allocate resources and guarantee services capable of responding fairly to health and care needs.
Autore per corrispondenza: Carlo Romagnoli mail: surfcasting.dakla@gmail.com
Zitieren
APA
Romagnoli, C. (2024). Dimensioni, processi ed esiti del privato in sanità. Sistema Salute, 8(3), 339-363. https://doi.org/10.48291/sisa.68.3.8
Vancouver
Romagnoli C. Dimensioni, processi ed esiti del privato in sanità. Sistema Salute. 2024;8(3):339-363. doi:10.48291/sisa.68.3.8
BibTeX
@article{Romagnoli2024,
author = {Romagnoli, Carlo},
title = {Dimensioni, processi ed esiti del privato in sanità},
journal = {Sistema Salute},
year = {2024},
volume = {8},
number = {3},
pages = {339--363},
doi = {10.48291/sisa.68.3.8}
}
EUVIMED