Is There A Circular Argument for the “State Capacity Explanation” of Economic Development?
Journal of Chinese Economy · 2022
DOI: 10.48014/jce.20220407002 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Chinese Economy, 2022. Verfasst von Shaowei FANG.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The “state capacity explanation” of the “developmental state theory” is an important doctrine for understanding the reasons for economic development in latecomer countries.Recently,this theory has been questioned in terms of both case and logical demonstration.This paper supports the case explanation of this doctrine from three “latent theories”:the “internal cause perspective of subjectivism”,“the flexibility of state capacity”,and “the coordination of primary and secondary factors”,and the non-circular argumentation of the concept of “conceptual slippage” and the “outcome dependence” of “state capacity” support the case explanation of the doctrine.This paper argues that the concept of “state power” cannot replace the concept of “state capacity” and that the “state capacity explanation” can be further refined by introducing “government endowment”,and “logic of factor shifting and combining”,and by strengthening the mastery of specific “institutional cultures”,so that the doctrine can be developed into a more general theory to explain economic development,while the rejection of the “circular argument” can be regarded as a preparation for the development of a new theory.
Zitieren
APA
FANG, S. (2022). Is There A Circular Argument for the “State Capacity Explanation” of Economic Development?. Journal of Chinese Economy. https://doi.org/10.48014/jce.20220407002
Vancouver
FANG S. Is There A Circular Argument for the “State Capacity Explanation” of Economic Development?. Journal of Chinese Economy. 2022. doi:10.48014/jce.20220407002
BibTeX
@article{FANG2022,
author = {FANG, Shaowei},
title = {Is There A Circular Argument for the “State Capacity Explanation” of Economic Development?},
journal = {Journal of Chinese Economy},
year = {2022},
doi = {10.48014/jce.20220407002}
}
EUVIMED