Situating Design Science Research and Projects within a Critical Realist’s perspective
International Journal of Project Management · 2026
DOI: 10.47672/ijpm.2846 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift International Journal of Project Management, 2026. Verfasst von Stephen Kyakulumbye und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Purpose
Design scientists, philosophers of science, and project designers hold mixed views on evaluating participatory design research, projects, processes, and outcomes. We argue that design science research produces varied contributions, including theories, methods, and artefacts. From a critical realist perspective, evaluation emphasizes mechanisms-based explanations. This paper examines the role of mechanisms in design science research and shows how studying them enhances statistical approaches for causal inference. It distinguishes statistical from causal inference; discusses mechanisms and mechanism-based explanations; mechanism quantification; mechanisms in explaining individual actions; and mechanisms in explaining outcomes. Drawing lessons from an empathetic participatory design process, it illustrates how design science studies can be situated within critical realism. Materials and Methods: This study adopts design science research, combining qualitative and quantitative approaches. It includes an extensive literature review and uses empirical statistical data from mechanisms observed in participatory design processes involving prototyped citizen incident reporting applications. Data collection employed qualitative repertory grids with potential citizen users; constructs were then incorporated into a quantitative structured questionnaire for empathetic prototype testing with designers. Prototype evaluation follows the Realist Evaluation model of Context-Mechanism-Outcome Configuration (CMOc), which explains how and why interventions work by analyzing Contexts (conditions), Mechanisms (activated forces), and Outcomes (intended or unintended results).
Findings
Inferentially, co-designed artifact features show a causal-mechanism relationship to perception (sig.=0.397) and projection (sig.=0.222), but not to understanding (sig.=0.177). Significant causal interrelationships exist among situation awareness constructs. There are also significant relationships between perception and action (sig.=0.382), comprehension and action (sig.=0.312), and projection and action (sig.=0.450). Relationships involving situation awareness constructs, PAL, and e-government artifact adoption were not tested. Implications to Theory, Practice and Policy: Informed by Personal Constructs Theory (PCT) and Situational Awareness, which view individuals as scientists forming bipolar mental frameworks to interpret and predict the world. The paper advances debates on rigor and relevance in design science research, arguing that a critical realist lens balances rigor (via statistical inference) and relevance (via problem-solving prototypes). Researchers may treat context variables as explicit or implicit ceteris paribus conditions and explore additional causal relationships based on design and evaluation contexts.
Zitieren
APA
Kyakulumbye, S., Bwengye, A. K., & Pather, S. (2026). Situating Design Science Research and Projects within a Critical Realist’s perspective. International Journal of Project Management. https://doi.org/10.47672/ijpm.2846
Vancouver
Kyakulumbye S, Bwengye AK, Pather S. Situating Design Science Research and Projects within a Critical Realist’s perspective. International Journal of Project Management. 2026. doi:10.47672/ijpm.2846
BibTeX
@article{Kyakulumbye2026,
author = {Kyakulumbye, Stephen and Bwengye, Anny Katabaazi and Pather, Shaun},
title = {Situating Design Science Research and Projects within a Critical Realist’s perspective},
journal = {International Journal of Project Management},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.47672/ijpm.2846}
}
EUVIMED