Structural Integrity, Information Coverage, and Reporting Completeness of Manual Inspection Tools in Urban Environmental Health Governance: Evidence from Kwara State, Nigeria
African Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development · 2026
DOI: 10.46654/e9tvn563 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift African Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development, 2026. Verfasst von Eyiwunmi Bolanle Ajao und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
Municipal environmental health premises inspection serves as a vital regulatory mechanism for interrupting disease transmission and enforcing sanitary compliance across sub-Saharan Africa. In municipal administration throughout Nigeria, routine field monitoring continues to depend almost exclusively on legacy paper checklists (Form ES1/ES2). However, structural gaps and operational field missingness threaten the validity of regulatory decision-making.
Objective
This study systematically evaluated the structural architecture, environmental item coverage, and baseline reporting completeness of traditional paper-based premises inspection forms across urban Local Government Areas (LGAs) in Kwara State, Nigeria.
Methods
A cross-sectional census investigation was undertaken across three metropolitan LGAs (Ilorin South, Ilorin West, and Ilorin East), encompassing all 35 field-active registered Environmental Health Officers (EHOs). A total of 76 paired premises evaluations were audited across two distinct observer groups: Main EHOs (n=50) and SIWES student interns (n=26). Inspection instruments comprised the standardized 23-item ES1 tool (1–5 Likert scale; theoretical range: 23–115). Primary outcomes assessed included item-level content comprehensiveness, total completeness yields, field-level missingness rates, and score agreement verified via absolute-agreement Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICC) and Multiple Imputation by Chained Equations (MICE) sensitivity modeling.
Results
Content audit revealed critical omissions in the standard 23-item checklist, which entirely excludes ambient/indoor air quality parameters, direct microbial/chemical water safety metrics, toxic exposure indicators, and environmental noise assessments. Field audits established severe reporting missingness. Complete 23-item data were recorded in only 28 of 50 Main EHO forms (56.0% yield; 52/1,150 missing cells, 4.52% item missingness) and 15 of 26 SIWES forms (57.7% yield; 55/598 missing cells, 9.20% item missingness). Mean paper scores among complete cases were 83.21 ± 14.2 for Main EHOs and 77.07 ± 14.5 for SIWES interns. Paired mode comparisons against an electronic benchmark showed non-significant total score differences (Main EHO difference: -3.54, p=0.091; SIWES difference: +6.73, p=0.284), yet absolute-agreement ICCs remained low (Main EHO ICC = 0.476; SIWES ICC = 0.444), demonstrating lack of individual-level interchangeability. MICE sensitivity analysis confirmed stable pooled estimates (Main EHO paper mean = 84.82; SIWES paper mean = 77.27).
Conclusion
Paper-based environmental health inspection tools in urban Kwara State are compromised by structural content gaps and substantial field reporting missingness. Standardizing checklist parameters and transitioning toward digital capture with automated mandatory validation are required to strengthen municipal environmental surveillance.
Zitieren
APA
Ajao, E. B., Opasola, O., & Olorede, K. (2026). Structural Integrity, Information Coverage, and Reporting Completeness of Manual Inspection Tools in Urban Environmental Health Governance: Evidence from Kwara State, Nigeria. African Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development. https://doi.org/10.46654/e9tvn563
Vancouver
Ajao EB, Opasola O, Olorede K. Structural Integrity, Information Coverage, and Reporting Completeness of Manual Inspection Tools in Urban Environmental Health Governance: Evidence from Kwara State, Nigeria. African Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development. 2026. doi:10.46654/e9tvn563
BibTeX
@article{Ajao2026,
author = {Ajao, Eyiwunmi Bolanle and Opasola, Olaniyi and Olorede, Kabir},
title = {Structural Integrity, Information Coverage, and Reporting Completeness of Manual Inspection Tools in Urban Environmental Health Governance: Evidence from Kwara State, Nigeria},
journal = {African Journal of Environment and Sustainable Development},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.46654/e9tvn563}
}
EUVIMED