Logic and validity of ‘statistical proofs’ of ineffective cartels
Competition Law & Policy Debate · 01.04.2026 · 9 (3-4) · 83-92
DOI: 10.4337/clpd.2025.03-04.02 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Competition Law & Policy Debate, erschienen am 01.04.2026. Verfasst von Simone Kohnz und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 72 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In the background of the intuitive mantra that rational actors only engage in illegal costly activities if this behaviour guarantees them a sizeable benefit, the German Federal Court of Justice has ruled in its Trucks III judgment that a statistically non-significant overcharge estimate (alone) does not ‘prove’ no harm. While empirically we can never prove anything with 100% certainty, in this paper, we argue that a precise overcharge estimate close to zero represents stronger evidence for ‘no harm’ than for positive harm. This is due to the fact that, on the one hand, we expect, with a non-negligible prior probability, that a cartel or information exchange does not systematically increase prices (‘ineffective conduct’) and, on the other hand, we expect an effective illegal conduct to generate a sizeable effect. We draw the following conclusions. Case-specific plausibility analyses can help to inform the prior probabilities of ineffective conduct. Similarly, case-specific plausibility analyses can provide at least some information on the expected effect, assuming the conduct effectively established collusion among competitors. Finally, we encourage economic experts and courts to be more transparent about their initial beliefs based on their case-specific plausibility assessments and how they affect the interpretation of statistical results acknowledging that we cannot quantify such initial beliefs precisely.
Zitieren
APA
Kohnz, S., & Nitsche, R. (2026). Logic and validity of ‘statistical proofs’ of ineffective cartels. Competition Law & Policy Debate, 9(3-4), 83-92. https://doi.org/10.4337/clpd.2025.03-04.02
Vancouver
Kohnz S, Nitsche R. Logic and validity of ‘statistical proofs’ of ineffective cartels. Competition Law & Policy Debate. 2026;9(3-4):83-92. doi:10.4337/clpd.2025.03-04.02
BibTeX
@article{Kohnz2026,
author = {Kohnz, Simone and Nitsche, Rainer},
title = {Logic and validity of ‘statistical proofs’ of ineffective cartels},
journal = {Competition Law & Policy Debate},
year = {2026},
volume = {9},
number = {3-4},
pages = {83--92},
doi = {10.4337/clpd.2025.03-04.02}
}
EUVIMED