Is ‘competition on the merits’ a useful concept?
Competition Law Journal · 2026-11 · 25 (2) · 98-116
DOI: 10.4337/clj.2026.02.03 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Competition Law Journal, 2026-11. Verfasst von Sean-Paul Brankin. Die Arbeit nennt 187 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The concept of ‘competition on the merits’ plays an increasingly important role under Article 102. It is central to the Court of Justice judgments in Google Shopping and Servizio Elettrico Nazionale and plays an important role in the European Commission’s Article 102 Guidelines on Exclusionary Conduct. Despite this, it has yet to be properly defined. Nor is that likely to change. Traditional behavioural definitions based on consumer benefits are unworkable, the definition proposed by the Court of Justice in Servizio Elettrico Nazionale is self-confessedly flawed, and no single economic test for unlawful unilateral conduct has yet been identified. EU case law applies multiple, mutually irreconcilable definitions, including one (in Google Shopping ) that is difficult if not impossible to defend coherently. The core difficulty is that any workable definition must reliably identify both (i) exclusionary conduct that is always lawful; and (ii) exclusionary conduct that is always unlawful (subject to potential defences). This follows from the concept’s origins as a signifier of definitively lawful conduct – per its use in Intel – and its subsequent adoption as the basis for a definition of abuse. The OECD was right, in 2006, to describe competition on the merits as an ‘empty phrase’, the use of which should be abandoned as it results in unpredictable enforcement.
Zitieren
APA
Brankin, S. (2026). Is ‘competition on the merits’ a useful concept?. Competition Law Journal, 25(2), 98-116. https://doi.org/10.4337/clj.2026.02.03
Vancouver
Brankin S. Is ‘competition on the merits’ a useful concept?. Competition Law Journal. 2026;25(2):98-116. doi:10.4337/clj.2026.02.03
BibTeX
@article{Brankin2026,
author = {Brankin, Sean-Paul},
title = {Is ‘competition on the merits’ a useful concept?},
journal = {Competition Law Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {25},
number = {2},
pages = {98--116},
doi = {10.4337/clj.2026.02.03}
}
EUVIMED