Freedom of speech, minority protection and the channels of political change: a representation-reinforcing approach to hate speech at Strasbourg
Comparative Constitutional Studies · 01.10.2026 · 4 (2) · 245-276
DOI: 10.4337/ccs.2026.0068 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Comparative Constitutional Studies, erschienen am 01.10.2026. Verfasst von Gavin Phillipson. Die Arbeit nennt 184 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article applies the framework of political process theory (PPT) to the European Court of Human Rights’ hate speech jurisprudence under Article 10 ECHR, offering what is – to the author’s knowledge – the first full-length analysis of that case law through a representation-reinforcing lens. Building on and adapting the neo-Elyian scholarship of Dixon, Hailbronner, Gardbaum and Gerards, it argues that, when Strasbourg’s hate speech case law is considered through a PPT lens, a troubling pattern emerges. While purporting to protect democracy and minority rights, the Court’s approach risks facilitating precisely the kind of process failures that PPT identifies as warranting judicial intervention: incumbent self-entrenchment, the silencing of dissenting political minorities and the closing of channels of political change. These arguments are developed through close analysis of decisions, including Féret v Belgium, Le Pen v France and the recent Grand Chamber decision in Sanchez v France. The article also finds that the Court consistently fails to examine the key issue of the efficacy of hate speech bans, and the extent and quality of democratic deliberation around the hate speech laws it upholds, missing clear opportunities for the representation-reinforcing review that PPT counsels. In relation to the Court’s developing Article 8 case law in this area, it argues that the Court should calibrate its margin of appreciation to encourage democratic experimentalism about the best ways of tackling hate speech across European states rather than continuing to so strongly endorse the current easy resort to criminalisation. It concludes that humility, openness to evidence and recognition of the deep normative and empirical complexity of this area are the virtues we should embrace when debating it.
Zitieren
APA
Phillipson, G. (2026). Freedom of speech, minority protection and the channels of political change: a representation-reinforcing approach to hate speech at Strasbourg. Comparative Constitutional Studies, 4(2), 245-276. https://doi.org/10.4337/ccs.2026.0068
Vancouver
Phillipson G. Freedom of speech, minority protection and the channels of political change: a representation-reinforcing approach to hate speech at Strasbourg. Comparative Constitutional Studies. 2026;4(2):245-276. doi:10.4337/ccs.2026.0068
BibTeX
@article{Phillipson2026,
author = {Phillipson, Gavin},
title = {Freedom of speech, minority protection and the channels of political change: a representation-reinforcing approach to hate speech at Strasbourg},
journal = {Comparative Constitutional Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {2},
pages = {245--276},
doi = {10.4337/ccs.2026.0068}
}
EUVIMED