It’s proportionality, stupid! Authoritarian and populist norm repurposing and human rights adjudication in Europe and the Americas1
Comparative Constitutional Studies · 01.10.2026 · 4 (2) · 300-319
DOI: 10.4337/ccs.2026.0064 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Comparative Constitutional Studies, erschienen am 01.10.2026. Verfasst von Alain Zysset. Die Arbeit nennt 71 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The literature on the authoritarian and populist attack on both international and constitutional law is flourishing. Characteristics of this phenomenon are not necessarily the rejection and elimination of liberal and/or democratic norms but the concerted and insidious repurposing of these norms. One could identify ‘norm re-purposing’ as the process by which a liberal and/or democratic norm in purpose becomes authoritarian and/or populist in its operation and effects. But what ultimately makes a norm authoritarian and/or populist? In this article, I first challenge the predominant approaches to norm repurposing in comparative constitutional law. On the one hand, by relying on a comparative, inductive (often abductive), and interpretive methodology, approaches focused on government behavior or discourse consolidation ultimately elude the conceptual and normative question of what makes repurposing authoritarian and/or populist. On the other hand, approaches anchored in a thick normative framework, such as (liberal or democratic) constitutionalism, risk over-including the list of abusively repurposed norms, obscuring the specific norms, effects, and grounds needed to explain the phenomenon. To enhance our understanding of authoritarian and populist repurposing, I suggest switching the focal point to adjudication in general and human rights adjudication in particular. This focus has conceptual and epistemological advantages, I argue. It is not just that conceptually human rights norms enshrined in international conventions specify which equal freedoms of individuals are protected, which lends a clearer conceptual and normative grounding to the analysis of repurposing. Epistemologically, adjudication also allows allegedly repurposed norms to enter in direct contact with liberal and/or democratic content, which enables us to better identify – via deductive rather than inductive or abductive reasoning – norm repurposing. Drawing from select case law of both the European and Inter-American Courts of Human Rights, I shed light on the crucial role of proportionality analysis as the adjudicative framework to ascertain norm repurposing as authoritarian and/or populist.
Zitieren
APA
Zysset, A. (2026). It’s proportionality, stupid! Authoritarian and populist norm repurposing and human rights adjudication in Europe and the Americas1. Comparative Constitutional Studies, 4(2), 300-319. https://doi.org/10.4337/ccs.2026.0064
Vancouver
Zysset A. It’s proportionality, stupid! Authoritarian and populist norm repurposing and human rights adjudication in Europe and the Americas1. Comparative Constitutional Studies. 2026;4(2):300-319. doi:10.4337/ccs.2026.0064
BibTeX
@article{Zysset2026,
author = {Zysset, Alain},
title = {It’s proportionality, stupid! Authoritarian and populist norm repurposing and human rights adjudication in Europe and the Americas1},
journal = {Comparative Constitutional Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {2},
pages = {300--319},
doi = {10.4337/ccs.2026.0064}
}
EUVIMED