Response to Symposium
Comparative Constitutional Studies · 01.06.2026 · 4 (1) · 148-155
DOI: 10.4337/ccs.2026.0061 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Comparative Constitutional Studies, erschienen am 01.06.2026. Verfasst von Gautam Bhatia. Die Arbeit nennt 58 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In this essay, I respond to Victoria Miyandazi, Jeffery Foreman, Meghan Finn, and Scott Stephenson as part of the symposium on Horizontal Rights: An Institutional Approach. These scholars’ pieces range from the methodological to the substantive, addressing questions around the comparative dimension of comparative constitutional law, the conceptual pillars of the institutional approach to horizontality, and the scope and limitations of the approach. In responding to these review essays, I make the following arguments. Firstly, any work of comparative constitutional law (especially one that is written in English) must, of necessity, acknowledge and engage with the phenomenon of constitutional ethnocentrism, which accords normative priority to US constitutional law and doctrine, as a touchstone of comparison, but it ought to do so from a critical – and ‘de-centering’ – perspective. Secondly, the kind of private power institutional horizontality focuses on is not limited to monopolies or oligopolies. It includes – perhaps especially so – instances where no individual agent can exercise monopolistic power. Where the power difference between two parties is mediated by an institution, from which there is no feasible exit. This would include, for example, ‘competitive’, non-monopolistic labour markets. Thirdly, institutional horizontality provides a reason for applying complex and evolved doctrines of equality and non-discrimination to the private sphere, but its reach is not limited only to equality cases (labour rights, for example, can be applied horizontally in certain specific cases). And finally, the warning that the institutional approach risks over-judicialisation is well-taken. This, however, is a problem that operates at the level of legal practice, and therefore, any proposal to deploy (or not to deploy) the approach – and to what extent to deploy it – in a concrete constitutional context ought to be informed by the existing context.
Zitieren
APA
Bhatia, G. (2026). Response to Symposium. Comparative Constitutional Studies, 4(1), 148-155. https://doi.org/10.4337/ccs.2026.0061
Vancouver
Bhatia G. Response to Symposium. Comparative Constitutional Studies. 2026;4(1):148-155. doi:10.4337/ccs.2026.0061
BibTeX
@article{Bhatia2026,
author = {Bhatia, Gautam},
title = {Response to Symposium},
journal = {Comparative Constitutional Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {1},
pages = {148--155},
doi = {10.4337/ccs.2026.0061}
}
EUVIMED