EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Facilitating Discussion of Theory and Practice in Education Seminars

Bailey Herrmann, Jessica R Gallo

Networks: An Online Journal for Teacher Research · 01.01.2018 · 20 (1)

DOI: 10.4148/2470-6353.1265 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Networks: An Online Journal for Teacher Research, online erschienen am 01.01.2018. Verfasst von Bailey Herrmann und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 2-mal zitiert (Crossref).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Field experience seminars, discussion-based courses paired with school-based practicum experiences, provide a space for teacher candidates to discuss the theories they study in their university classes and the practices they observe and implement in their school placements. This article describes an action research study that examines teaching techniques that promote discussion in English education seminar courses. The purpose of this research was to collaboratively develop teaching approaches that would help teacher candidates bridge ideas about theory and practice in their development as aspiring teachers. The conversations that challenged the teacher candidates to think critically and theoretically about their classrooms were transformative moments in our seminar classes.

Introduction

The deep divide between content knowledge and pedagogy that occurs in many teacher preparation programs is well documented in teacher education research (Zeichner, 2010; Ball, 2000). Ideally, teacher preparation programs create a synergy between theory and practice (Zeichner, 2010) and exist as “new hybrid spaces where academic, practitioner, and community-based knowledge respect and interact to develop new solutions to the complicated process of preparing teachers,” (Kretchmar & Zeichner, 2016, p. 428). Zeichner (2010) explains “one of the central problems that has plagued collegeand universitybased preservice teacher education for many years” is the “disconnect between the campus and school-based components of programs” (p. 89). Ball (2000) identified three problems that teacher education programs must address in order to bridge this divide: “The first problem concerns identifying the content 1 Herrmann and Gallo: Facilitating Discussion of Theory and Practice Published by New Prairie Press, 2018 knowledge that matters for teaching, the second regards understanding how such knowledge needs to be held, and the third centers on what it takes to use such knowledge in practice” (p. 244). Given the siloed nature of content departments and university pedagogy courses, achieving a more integrated model of teacher preparation is no easy feat (Ball, 2000). Traditional teacher preparation programs like ours, which have not yet found a way to achieve a more integrated model, have created programs that consist of methods classes grounded in studying education theory, field experiences designed to give teacher candidates spaces to practice pedagogies with actual students, and seminar courses focused on helping teacher candidates to bridge the theory/practice divide. As teacher educators, we know the importance of the seminar course, which led us to the following research question: How can we structure the seminar so it brings together theory and practice? We see our seminars as a place of opportunity where we can help the teacher candidates to look at their practice in new ways they may not have considered. We can also help them work through the questions that arise in their field experiences in a way that is immediately useful to their work in the schools. We see our seminar classes as opportunities to more deeply understand the complexities of teaching in a way that is “powerful enough to enable candidates to build upon and extend their prior knowledge and experiences to accomplish the goal of competent teaching” (Hollins & Crockett, 2012, p. 8). The seminars can both build teacher candidates’ confidence and encourage revision of, and reflection on, their developing teacher identities. We want to make sure our teacher candidates feel confident and well-prepared for the situations they will 2 Networks: An Online Journal for Teacher Research, Vol. 20 [2018], Iss. 1, Art. 2 https://newprairiepress.org/networks/vol20/iss1/2 DOI: 10.4148/2470-6353.1265 encounter, but we also want them to think critically about their teaching and make decisions based on their understandings of how and why those choices work and what the consequences might be. We want them to think through possibilities for their practice as a way of understanding their questions rather than only having a playbook of answers to problems that come up. Thus, we began a collaborative action research project to explore our teaching in our individual field experience seminars to develop practices that would promote productive conversations about teaching with our teacher candidates. Our hope is that other teacher educators can learn from our action research process and the teaching approaches that we tried in experimenting with our seminars.

Context

The data from this study came from two universities (all names are pseudonyms). Site 1, River City University (RCU) is a mid-sized public university with a total enrollment hovering around 25,000 students (River City University, 2015). Site 2, Mountain View University (MVU) is a mid-sized, public university enrolling approximately 13,000 students (Mountain View University, 2015). These two predominantly white universities are located in different parts of the country, but they share a similar seminar-style course for teacher candidates. The seminar courses, which meet once a week for 50-90 minutes, are designed to foster reflective practice and to prepare teacher candidates for English education field experiences (practicum teaching) in grades 5-12. Both seminars are held concurrently with field experiences for the teacher candidates; teacher candidates spend part of their semester in an English language arts classroom in a local or surrounding community. The seminars take place on the university campuses. 3 Herrmann and Gallo: Facilitating Discussion of Theory and Practice Published by New Prairie Press, 2018 As a collaborative action research study, both co-authors of this article studied our teaching practices and experiences in leading these seminar courses. Both the seminar course at RCU and MVU used the text You’ve Got to Reach Them to Teach Them by Mary Kim Schreck. This text discusses elements of student engagement through chapters such as, “Relationships,” “Motivation,” and “Confidence.” Each week teacher candidates read chapters from the text and discussed them in class. The chapter topics served as the springboard for group discussion. Methodology Because we were teaching similar seminar courses for English education majors in similar university settings, we saw an opportunity to collaboratively examine our practices and to implement new teaching approaches that would help us become better seminar professors. In order to evaluate our effectiveness as teachers, we took several different perspectives into account. We certainly wanted the seminar to be a productive and supportive space for the teacher candidates to get feedback and inspiration about their teaching practices. We also wanted the seminar to provide a space for us, as teacher educators and field experience supervisors, to encourage teacher candidates to think about the multiple possibilities for their teaching choices and to recognize the complexity of the work they were doing in classrooms. With this dual purpose in mind, we chose teaching approaches that we hoped would accomplish these goals and work within the broader context of helping teacher candidates develop as teachers. We conceptualized our study as an action research study. We wanted to study our own teaching practices “in order to better understand them and to be 4 Networks: An Online Journal for Teacher Research, Vol. 20 [2018], Iss. 1, Art. 2 https://newprairiepress.org/networks/vol20/iss1/2 DOI: 10.4148/2470-6353.1265 able to improve [our] quality or effectiveness” (Mertler, 2014, p. 4). We also wanted to be able to implement changes to our practice immediately and analyze results as they happened. Thus, we followed Stringer’s (2007) Action Research Interacting Spiral to structure our inquiry (as cited in Mertler, 2014). In this model, we repeatedly looked at the data in the form of anecdotes from our teaching, thought about what was going on in each of the anecdotes, and acted on our new understandings to implement changes to our teaching. We followed Patterson, Baldwin, Araujo, Shearer, and Stewart’s (2010) suggestions to see our action research as part of a larger ecology for the teacher candidates’ development as teachers: As agents in complex adaptive systems (or teaching/learning ecologies), we should engage in continuous, recursive ‘Look, Think, Act’ cycles to ensure that the system adapts to changes within and changes in the environment but also that these adaptations are coherent with our shared values, beliefs, goals, and expectations. (p. 147) Each time we met for our research meetings, we discussed our previous seminar class and revisited previous concerns in light of the techniques we had tried. Then we repeated the process of examining anecdotes from our teaching and developing new teaching approaches. The data for this study come from a virtual online action research group. We met weekly via online video conferencing (Google Hangouts) to debrief on our recent class sessions. During these meetings, we each took turns sharing challenges, successes, and anecdotes from our teaching. We discussed our teaching practices and our observations of seminar meetings with the teacher 5 Herrmann and Gallo: Facilitating Discussion of Theory and Practice Published by New Prairie Press, 2018 candidates. At the end of each meeting, we wrote notes in a shared Google Doc to capture our thinking. Here is a sample of our meeting notes from March 18. Note that we refer to the teacher candidates as “students” in our seminar classes: Jess: I am feeling a disconnect between me choosing topics for discussion and holding a discussion about students’ practical concerns. We [Bailey and Jess] talked about several possible solutions: Could we structure the seminar around some big projects? Another solution we talked about [in our action research group] is giving students something a bit more concrete to spark their

Zitieren

APA

Herrmann, B., & Gallo, J. R. (2018). Facilitating Discussion of Theory and Practice in Education Seminars. Networks: An Online Journal for Teacher Research, 20(1). https://doi.org/10.4148/2470-6353.1265

Vancouver

Herrmann B, Gallo JR. Facilitating Discussion of Theory and Practice in Education Seminars. Networks: An Online Journal for Teacher Research. 2018;20(1). doi:10.4148/2470-6353.1265

BibTeX
@article{Herrmann2018,
  author = {Herrmann, Bailey and Gallo, Jessica R},
  title = {Facilitating Discussion of Theory and Practice in Education Seminars},
  journal = {Networks: An Online Journal for Teacher Research},
  year = {2018},
  volume = {20},
  number = {1},
  doi = {10.4148/2470-6353.1265}
}
Kostenlos starten →