EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Survivor’s Bias in Psychotherapy

Suresh Bada Math

Journal of Psychiatry Spectrum · 2025

DOI: 10.4103/jopsys.jopsys_123_25 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Psychiatry Spectrum, 2025. Verfasst von Suresh Bada Math. Die Arbeit nennt 23 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

INTRODUCTION Psychotherapy is widely acknowledged as an effective and evidence-based treatment for a broad range of psychiatric disorders. Extensive research, including clinical trials, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses, demonstrates its efficacy in alleviating symptoms[1] and enhancing quality of life[2] in conditions such as depression,[3] obsessive–compulsive disorder,[4] bipolar disorder,[5] posttraumatic stress disorder,[6] and substance use disorders.[7] However, research focusing on the negative effects of psychotherapy remains limited, partly due to factors such as survivor bias, which has hindered a comprehensive understanding of potential adverse outcomes.[8,9] This gap in knowledge is particularly critical in light of the preamble of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, an Act enacted to provide mental health care and services for persons with mental illness and to protect, promote, and fulfill the rights of such persons during the delivery of mental health care and services. Hence, this article focuses on the negative effects of psychotherapy. SURVIVOR’S BIAS Survivor’s bias, also known as survivorship bias, is a common cognitive pitfall where we tend to focus only on the people, cases, or outcomes that have “survived” a particular process, while ignoring those that did not make it through.[10] This selective attention occurs when you tend to assess successful outcomes and disregard failures.[11] We naturally notice successes more than failures, which can lead us to overestimate how effective certain practices or treatments are, simply because the failures are overlooked. The idea of survivor’s bias became widely recognized during World War II, thanks to the work of mathematician Abraham Wald.[11] The U.S. military was trying to figure out how to best reinforce their bomber planes to reduce losses from enemy fire. Initially, the instinct was to armor the parts of the planes with the most visible bullet holesessentially, bolstering the areas that surviving planes had the most damage in. However, Wald pointed out a crucial oversight: this analysis only looked at the planes that returned safely, the “survivors.” The military was ignoring the planes that did not make it back the “nonsurvivors.” Wald recommended reinforcing the areas that had fewer bullet holes on returning planes, reasoning that damage to those areas likely meant the plane was lost.[11] This insight fundamentally changed how data were interpreted, emphasizing the importance of considering what was missing along with what was visible. Moreover, survivor’s bias is often amplified by editorial policies in scientific publishing, which tend to favor positive results and are less likely to showcase studies reporting negative or harmful outcomes. This skew in publication further clouds the true picture of psychotherapy’s risks and benefits. SURVIVOR’S BIAS IN PSYCHOTHERAPY When it comes to psychotherapy, survivor’s bias shows up in how we assess the therapy’s side effects and failures. Imagining a study following 100 clients who start therapy: 60 complete it and report improvement, while 10 more finish despite experiencing some mild unwanted effects. The remaining 30 clients drop out quietly, some because they felt worse or faced negative effects, but often these dropouts are not followed up or reported. If we only consider the 70 who completed therapy, it might appear overwhelmingly effective and safe. In reality, the 30 who dropped out could indicate a much higher rate of unwanted or negative effects that simply go unrecorded. However, slowly, the research into negative effects of psychotherapy is accumulating. The prevalence and nature of negative effects in psychotherapy are shaped by a variety of factors, including definition of side-effect, patient characteristics, therapist competence, the quality of the therapeutic match, assessment methods, instrument chosen, and the specific side effects under investigation.[12] Scientific evidence highlights substantial variability in the reported rates of these negative outcomes.[8] However, there is an emerging consensus that unwanted events should be expected in about 5%–20% of psychotherapy patients.[13] Negative effects in psychotherapy should be suspected when there is a worsening of symptoms, lack of improvement, the emergence of new psychiatric symptoms, increased dependency on the therapist, disruption in interpersonal relationships, occupational dysfunction, and emotional exhaustion, among others.[12] Such adverse outcomes underscore the importance of careful monitoring and ongoing evaluation throughout the therapeutic process. Structured assessment of negative effects of psychotherapy can be done using validated tools [Table 1]. For a comprehensive review of instruments used to assess the negative effects of psychotherapy, readers are encouraged to consult the scholarly article by Herzog et al.[14]Table 1: Assessment Tools for Evaluating Negative Effects of PsychotherapyTo get a more accurate understanding, it is essential that research and clinical practice systematically assess why clients drop out, monitor negative effects throughout therapy, and continue evaluating any harmful effects even after treatment ends. Only then can the complete story of psychotherapy’s impact, both positive and negative, be honestly and reliably told. In this regard, there has been a call from various psychiatric organizations to systematically assess the negative effects of psychotherapy.[13,15] FUTURE IMPLICATIONS There is an urgent need to clearly define and operationalize these terms for both clinical practice and research to ensure consistency and precision.[16] Mandatory reporting of both negative and serious adverse effects to ethics committees is essential.[17] At present, under-reporting is common, and ethical oversight often overlooks harms. Requiring comprehensive reporting aligns psychotherapy research with biomedical standards, promoting transparency and patient safety.[15] Identifying predictors of negative effects enables personalized treatment planning. Factors such as poor therapeutic alliance, prior negative experiences, and unrealistic expectations increase the risk of adverse outcomes.[18] Awareness of these predictors helps therapists tailor interventions to minimize harm.[16] Research into negative effects also informs psychotherapy training. Integrating awareness and management of adverse effects into training enhances clinician skills, fosters open discussion of challenges, and improves patient care quality.[16,18,19] Finally, boundary violations seriously undermine psychotherapy’s effectiveness and client trust. Evidence supports stronger national regulations to prevent exploitative behaviors and protect clients. Clear, enforceable guidelines ensure ethical standards and preserve therapeutic integrity. To conclude, there is an urgent need to consider the “survivor’s bias” in psychotherapy and thoroughly investigate the negative effects of psychotherapy in real world. If such adverse effects are identified, it strongly supports the case for stricter regulations in psychotherapy training and licensing, ensuring higher standards and greater client protection. On the contrary, if robust research finds no significant negative effects, this would justify a nationwide push to expand the practice of psychotherapy across all professional backgrounds without needing any licensing to practice psychotherapy, so that every patient gets the benefit of psychotherapy. In either scenario, evidence-based policymaking is essential for optimizing both the quality and accessibility of psychotherapeutic care. Author contribution statement Sole author, not applicable. Disclosure of use of AI-assisted generative devices Generative AI ChatGPT assistance was limited to grammar correction only. Declaration of use of copyright tools Copyright tools not applicable. Declaration of Interest The author serves as the Chairperson of Psychotherapy Training in the Department of Psychiatry at National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences, Bengaluru. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.

Zitieren

APA

Math, S. B. (2025). Survivor’s Bias in Psychotherapy. Journal of Psychiatry Spectrum. https://doi.org/10.4103/jopsys.jopsys_123_25

Vancouver

Math SB. Survivor’s Bias in Psychotherapy. Journal of Psychiatry Spectrum. 2025. doi:10.4103/jopsys.jopsys_123_25

BibTeX
@article{Math2025,
  author = {Math, Suresh Bada},
  title = {Survivor’s Bias in Psychotherapy},
  journal = {Journal of Psychiatry Spectrum},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.4103/jopsys.jopsys_123_25}
}
Kostenlos starten →