Time for a Bariatric Reset – In Conversation and Practice!
Journal of Bariatric Surgery · 2024
DOI: 10.4103/jbs.jbs_11_24 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Bariatric Surgery, 2024. Verfasst von Ramen Goel. Die Arbeit nennt 7 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Over the years, the focus of academic discussion has shifted from attempts to improve an established procedure, to devise and establish superiority of a new procedure. Such attempts, usually published with small sample size and short-term follow-ups, are hurriedly accepted as “better ones” by young surgical colleagues. Scientific zeal to improvise existing surgeries or find a new procedure cannot be questioned; however, unlike other surgical procedures, bariatric story begins (and not ends) with a surgery. Long-term weight maintenance, nutritional deficiencies, and quality of life (QOL) outcomes are equally important considerations, as are immediate 6–12 months’ results. Procedure specifications of accepted bariatric procedures are questioned and altered with a kind of impunity, not seen with other surgeries, even though abundant data from large series or well-conducted randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are available. It is time to discuss and accept standardized surgical steps of accepted procedures, specifically to discuss “why” each step should be done in a particular manner, instead of focusing only on “how” it can be done. This understanding and adherence to standardized procedure should limit surgical adventurism, outside of clinical trial protocols. In a landmark publication, Bhandari et al.[1] drafted an international consensus statement on standardization of 22 bariatric and metabolic surgeries. In this issue, an interesting article is published, “Delphi Consensus on Surgical Technique of Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass: An Obesity and Metabolic Surgery Society of India Initiative” by Bindal et al.,[2] which highlights the current surgical practices among selected experts performing Roux-en-y gastric bypass (RyGB) surgery in India. In the words of the authors, “this standardization not only promises improved patient outcomes but also facilitates enhanced training, advances research efforts, and reduces the learning curve for surgeons entering this specialized field.” RyGB remains the longest surviving and consistent bariatric procedure, even though its gold standard status may be questioned by a few. For the ease of understanding, RyGB can be deconstructed into four surgical steps: the gastric pouch, gastrojejunostomy (stoma), limb lengths, and mesenteric defect closure(s), to explain “why” using quality published literature. A 30–50 cc (3 cm × 3–4 cm) gastric pouch is a standard.[1] The data of 14,168 patients from the Scandinavian Obesity Surgery Registry[3] elaborated that a small gastric pouch is desirable to reduce marginal ulcer incidence, even though it may not be a determinant of excess weight loss or regain.[4] The Swedish study[3] estimated that 145 mm stapler length for pouch creation results in marginal ulcers in 0.9% only. The same study mentioned that every extra 1 cm use of stapler cartridge results in 14% higher ulcer incidence. Longer pouches are still created by surgeons with possibility of high (8%–12%) anastomotic ulcer rate. Technique of gastrojejunostomy (stoma) is acknowledged as the single most important surgical step determining long-term outcome. The recommended stoma size is 1.2–1.5 cm;[1] however, not enough emphasis is laid on stoma size during surgery, especially when using the linear cutter. In a study, stoma dilatation is reported in 58.9% of weight regain patients,[5] while in another study, stoma dilatation was found to be an independent modifiable factor, besides preoperative body mass index and duration from surgery, associated with weight regain after gastric bypass.[4] The odds ratio for the risk of weight regain with a stoma diameter of more than 2 cm was 1.5 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.1–2.1, P = 0.010). Limb lengths remain the most contentious issue among bariatric surgeons due to a lack of quality evidence. A perception has gained ground that a strong procedure should have a longer biliopancreatic limb (BPL), even though it is likely to be at higher deficiency risk. Unfortunately, most of the studies measuring limb lengths change more than one limb length in each cohort. Ruiz-Tovar et al. in a RCT have clearly shown that for a fixed alimentary limb length(ALL), increase in BPL length, from standard 70 cm to longer 120 cm, does not result in any statistically significant difference in weight loss and/or comorbidity resolution. Though this increase in BPL is associated with greater deficiencies of Vitamin B12, Vitamin A, and folic acid.[6] Mesenteric closures, though a routine in open intestinal surgeries, are sometimes not practiced by a few bariatric surgeons, because they are considered technically challenging and/or not necessary. Fortunately, mesenteric defect closures are practiced by most surgeons performing RyGB. A recent RCT,[7] published in JAMA by Stenberg et al. of 10-year follow-up of cohorts of closures (n = 1251) versus nonclosures (n = 1248) with ~95% follow-ups, has reported reoperation for small-bowel obstruction in 98 patients with closure (10-year cumulative incidence, 7.8%; 95% CI: 6.4%–9.4%) and in 185 patients with nonclosure (10-year cumulative incidence, 14.9%; 95% CI: 13.0%–16.9%). Nearly 50% reduction in the possibility of a reoperation (from iatrogenic reasons) should be a motivation enough for nonclosing surgeons to change. The recommended roux limb can vary between 50 and 150 cm,[6] subject to the BPL limb length as the total length of BPL and roux limb should not exceed 200 cm. In our practice, we continue to have a fixed roux limb length of 75 cm, primarily to avoid bile reflux. In summary, a standard RyGB surgery should be performed laparoscopically with 30–50 cc pouch,[1,2] 1.2–1.5 cm stoma,[7] 50–75 cm BPL length, ~100 cm roux limb,[1,2,6] and both mesenteric defects closed with nonabsorbable sutures.[7] At this stage, it is pertinent to recognise that other factors, beyond surgical technique, determining overall outcomes include program support, eating habits, food choices, and the psychological and social environment. Technique standardization is always desirable in surgery, but is a necessity in bariatrics, considering the long-term impact of a nonstandardized surgery on health and QOL of an individual and family. A nonstandard procedure exposes the patient to avoidable health risks and does not bode well for an evolving specialty with potential to help millions.
Zitieren
APA
Goel, R. (2024). Time for a Bariatric Reset – In Conversation and Practice!. Journal of Bariatric Surgery. https://doi.org/10.4103/jbs.jbs_11_24
Vancouver
Goel R. Time for a Bariatric Reset – In Conversation and Practice!. Journal of Bariatric Surgery. 2024. doi:10.4103/jbs.jbs_11_24
BibTeX
@article{Goel2024,
author = {Goel, Ramen},
title = {Time for a Bariatric Reset – In Conversation and Practice!},
journal = {Journal of Bariatric Surgery},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.4103/jbs.jbs_11_24}
}
EUVIMED