EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

A Deeper Look Into Resuscitative Thoracotomy

Vitor F. Kruger, Gustavo P. Fraga

Journal of Acute Care and Resuscitation · 2024

DOI: 10.4103/jacresus.jacresus_16_24 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Acute Care and Resuscitation, 2024. Verfasst von Vitor F. Kruger und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 4 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

A toracotomia de reanimação (TR ou RT) permanece um procedimento controverso na cirurgia do trauma. Melhorias significativas no atendimento pré-hospitalar, resposta rápida e organização do sistema de trauma permitem que as vítimas de ferimentos penetrantes cheguem à sala de trauma com sinais de vida. O uso da RT surgiu nos Estados Unidos ao final do século 19, inicialmente para tratar lesões cardíacas. A RT é usada para tratar parada cardíaca traumática, com objetivos que incluem alívio do tamponamento cardíaco, controle de sangramento e massagem cardíaca aberta. No entanto, requer treinamento extensivo e prática frequente. No Brasil, um debate recente surgiu após uma toracotomia pré-hospitalar bem-sucedida. Contudo, os autores advertem contra a realização de RT no ambiente pré-hospitalar devido à falta de treinamento adequado e de um sistema de trauma bem estabelecido. Na sala de trauma, habilidades técnicas e não técnicas devem ser consideradas ao decidir realizar a RT. A presença de sinais de vida e o mecanismo da lesão são fatores cruciais. Trauma penetrante e parada cardiopulmonar testemunhada com presença de sinais de vida foram identificados como as condições mais favoráveis para realizar RT. Este é um procedimento excepcional que requer protocolos claros, discussões e diretrizes baseadas em evidências para sua indicação segura. We are writing in response to the article “Resuscitative Thoracotomy for Penetrating Trauma: A Valid Option in the Right Circumstances” by Alhussain et al.[1] As the authors provide valuable insights into the role of resuscitative thoracotomy (RT) in trauma care, we would like to share our insights based on our previous experience for a more optimized patient outcome. RT is a surgical intervention employed to manage traumatic cardiac arrest. The procedure aims to address cardiac tamponade, control bleeding, eliminate air embolism, and facilitate open cardiac massage. Additionally, temporary cross-clamping of the descending thoracic aorta is performed to prioritize blood flow to vital organs. Effective execution of RT necessitates substantial training and experience. The use of resuscitative left thoracotomy emerged in the United States in the late 1800s and early 1900s, initially to treat heart injuries and traumatic cardiac arrest. The procedure saw a revival in the 1960s and 1970s, trauma centers proposed its use for resuscitating critically injured patients with penetrating cardiovascular wounds.[2] The existing literature on RT is unclear due to inconsistent terminology, making it difficult to compare and analyze results. Thoracotomy or Walk Away! Despite this epical senior surgeon comment, no clear consensus exists for the optimal use of RT. It remains a controversial procedure despite advances in trauma care. Surgeons must carefully weigh the potential benefits and risks of RT in critically ill patients, balancing the possibility of survival against the risk of neurological complications and exposure to bloodborne pathogens. The absence of definitive guidelines and limited empirical evidence exacerbate the decision-making process surrounding RT. The resurgence of discussions regarding RT can be attributed to advancements in prehospital care, rapid response systems, trauma triage, and overall trauma system organization. These improvements have enabled a greater number of patients to reach the trauma bay with vital signs present. In Brazil, a recent successful pre-hospital thoracotomy sparked a heated debate. While life-saving efforts are applauded, we strongly advise against performing RT in the pre-hospital setting. First, RT requires extensive training and frequent practice, which may not be feasible for most pre-hospital physicians. Second, Brazil lacks a well-established trauma system, and performing RT without rapid transport to a trauma center may be futile. Finally, the cost–benefit ratio must be considered. RT is an extremely morbid and expensive intervention that should only be used in extremis patients. Mitigating team exposure is crucial. Exceptions can be made for medical pre-hospital services in countries with well-trained teams and advanced trauma systems, as the London Air Ambulance Service. Such setup is significantly different from what is observed in Brazil. In the trauma bay, both technical and non-technical skills must be considered when deciding to perform RT. The presence or absence of signs of life, such as pupillary response, spontaneous ventilation, carotid pulse, measurable blood pressure, extremity movement, or cardiac electrical activity, must be determined. The mechanism of injury must also be evaluated, with RT strongly recommended for patients presenting pulseless but with signs of life after penetrating thoracic injury. The trauma team’s experience and situational awareness to perform the procedure safely and with adequate resources are crucial. Another critical consideration is the potential outcome, which not only focuses on mortality but also neurologically intact hospital survival. A recent systematic review aimed to establish evidence-based guidelines for using RT in pulseless patients following critical injuries has supported the its impact on survival and improved neurological outcomes.[3] Standardizing definitions and reporting practices is crucial for developing institutional protocols and aiding decision-making, especially among less experienced surgeons. A comprehensive review of studies conducted between 1975 and 2020 analyzed the indications, contraindications, and outcomes related to radiotherapy (RT). Out of 7,236 patients who received RT, just 7.8% survived.[4] The analysis identified penetrating trauma and witnessed cardiopulmonary arrest, accompanied by signs of life upon arrival at the trauma bay, as the most favorable circumstances for the implementation of RT. Conversely, the procedure is not recommended for patients experiencing cardiopulmonary arrest due to blunt trauma, given the unacceptably low survival rates and poor neurological outcomes associated with such cases. In conclusion, we support the conclusions of Alhussain et al.[1] RT is an exceptional procedure with numerous technical and non-technical variables influencing the surgeon’s decision-making process. Patient’s successful outcome and rapid recovery can be attributed to several key factors: well-coordinated teamwork, a functional trauma system, and adequate hospital resources. However, this case also highlights the importance of continuous medical education and training. To ensure future success in similar complex procedures, we need to implement protocols to rationalize the use of RT, develop evidence-based guidelines, and train surgeons to develop their skills in making this critical decision. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.

Zitieren

APA

Kruger, V. F., & Fraga, G. P. (2024). A Deeper Look Into Resuscitative Thoracotomy. Journal of Acute Care and Resuscitation. https://doi.org/10.4103/jacresus.jacresus_16_24

Vancouver

Kruger VF, Fraga GP. A Deeper Look Into Resuscitative Thoracotomy. Journal of Acute Care and Resuscitation. 2024. doi:10.4103/jacresus.jacresus_16_24

BibTeX
@article{Kruger2024,
  author = {Kruger, Vitor F. and Fraga, Gustavo P.},
  title = {A Deeper Look Into Resuscitative Thoracotomy},
  journal = {Journal of Acute Care and Resuscitation},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.4103/jacresus.jacresus_16_24}
}
Kostenlos starten →