What’s new in academic international medicine? Critical appraisal and re-evaluation of standardized testing in the medical school admission process
International Journal of Academic Medicine · 2025-04 · 11 (2) · 41-45
DOI: 10.4103/ijam.ijam_22_26 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift International Journal of Academic Medicine, online erschienen am 05.05.2026. Verfasst von Tanmoy Ghatak und 3 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 1-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 44 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
INTRODUCTION Modern medical school and postgraduate medical training are complex processes or, perhaps more properly, a choreographed series of interconnected complex processes. Medical education was initially conceived with one singular purpose and focus – to identify, engage, and recruit the best available and most suitable individuals into various medical specialties, with the goal of providing excellent bedside clinical care to populations around the world. Since mid-20th Century, reforms in medical education sought to standardize and professionalize entry into medicine.[1,2] Although the current medical school admission system appears to be performing sustainably, it does so with significant opportunities for improvement and various unresolved concerns, as identified over the years.[3,4] In this Editorial, we will concentrate on the medical education system’s hyperfocus on standardized testing, its benefits, shortcomings, and potential solutions to optimize the future utility (and ultimately the survival) of standardized medical admission and licensing testing.[5-10] Medical professions have a long history of creating “professional filters” (and, at times, “barriers to entry”) intended to screen and channel the most suitable individuals into medical careers.[11,12] Cited reasons for this include the highly structured and demanding nature of medical professional activities, reliability requirements, service orientation, and, in some ways, the military-like regimented lifestyle of physicians. Prior to the modern, post-World War II Era, entry into careers in medicine was heavily influenced by networking, interpersonal connections, and often protracted apprenticeships.[13-16] Although these traditional approaches resulted in an adequate workforce with excellent knowledge and skills, the overall system was clearly biased, with barriers to entry significantly lower for various “in-groups.” Many of the candidates represented the high-income population segment, relatives of physicians and other healthcare professionals, certain military personnel groups, and those fortunate enough to gain access to medical career “gatekeepers,” including physicians and medical educators.[16-19] Entrance into the profession was based largely on direct observations, personal interviews and subjective, nonstandardized examinations, often open-ended essays, or oral-response questions that heavily favored those who received advanced guidance and mentorship, along with the privilege of access to the associated resources. There was an undisputable bias within the system, complete with ample self-reinforcing mechanisms. To address these concerns, in the form of well-intentioned but somewhat flawed attempts, the current system of medical school admissions, leaning heavily on standardized testing, was conceived.[20,21] The standardized testing system was made available to all potential applicants who met or exceeded specific academic prerequisites and high levels of academic performance, effectively democratizing the process and creating a more objective and scalable applicant evaluation mechanism.[22,23] Although significant impetus for the introduction of this new medical school admission testing paradigm came from the wide recognition of biases and the above-mentioned deficiencies associated with the traditional and outdated process, there were other very important reasons for reform, including but not limited to the need for greater candidate diversity and the worsening shortages of physicians across an entire spectrum of specialties. This important shift from largely exclusive to more inclusive medical school admission regimens was a significant step forward; however, it quickly became apparent that, as much as “old habits die hard,” so do old, well-entrenched biases.[11,21,24] SYSTEMIC VULNERABILITIES AND BIAS RE-INTRODUCTION It is not a secret that medical school admission testing does not constitute a sole predictor of one’s clinical ability but rather predicts one’s ability to “do better on future tests” – something of very limited and potentially questionable utility in the context of bedside patient care.[25] Published evidence suggests that although “good test scores” predict “future good test scores,” they fail to reliably predict communication skills, empathy, professionalism, or resilience.[26-28] This is a significant issue within our healthcare training pipeline, where “good test takers” do not always translate into “good, compassionate physicians.”[29,30] In addition, as discussed later in this section, the ability to perform well on a relatively narrowly scoped assessment examination is not a good predictor of one’s ability to “think critically” or skillfully “integrate new knowledge.” This worrisome phenomenon is not unique to the United States or the West in general. For example, in India, the National Eligibility Entrance Test was implemented in order to standardize medical school entry processes across diverse States while instituting critically important fee curbs. Since its inception, this well-intended initiative has faced all-too-familiar criticisms, including the proliferation of expensive “coaching factories” that essentially re-created a two-tier system based on income inequality[31,32] (e.g., economically disadvantaged peers continue to face significant challenges achieving comparable scores, despite equal talent and potential, as discussed in later sections of this Editorial). Even more importantly, some researchers raised concerns about the lack of consistent relationship between highly competitive test-taking abilities and the adequacy of one’s interpersonal/social skills.[30,33,34] Such concerns raise the question of whether focusing on other factors, such as personality traits, interview performance, or learning style, may offer alternative ways to predict medical academic success and, most importantly, the trainee’s actual real-world competence.[34-37] Because the current set of competitive selection tools is associated with relatively narrowly defined cognitive and psychometric variables, modern medical school admission processes risk failing to capture one’s proficiency in important “real-world” competencies. This, in turn, risks conflating academic test-taking proficiency with holistic clinical capabilities. Among the most significant reputational issues facing the current standardized medical school testing paradigm is the well-established ability of both undergraduate schools and candidates to “teach to the test” and “study for the examination,” thereby gaming the system without ensuring that the actual breadth and depth of individual knowledge are truly present.[38-40] This may be especially problematic for institutions that base their educational quality performance metrics on student admissions and licensing examination performance as the primary determinant of success. As practicing physicians and medical educators, the authors of this Editorial have anecdotally encountered plenty of “high-scoring” students who were “top test takers” and yet displayed significant difficulties integrating complex new knowledge and/or efficiently processing new information. Socioeconomic disparities further complicate this paradigm.[40,41] More specifically, for some individuals, success on standardized admission testing becomes a matter of resource availability. It is well established that resource-intensive, dedicated preparatory curricula and practice sessions, targeting specific admission and/or licensing examination content, may be beneficial in optimizing one’s ability to achieve more favorable (and competitive) scores.[42,43] In this way, standardized testing performance becomes a corollary to “iterative practice,” not conceptually different from repetitive sports (e.g., tennis and basketball) or musical instrument practice. As such, it essentially evolves into “psychometric exercise” for pretrained individuals, as opposed to an actual “knowledge assessment” for those without pretraining.[26,44] At the end of the day, those individuals who can afford dedicated “test preparation” courses are able to take advantage of this often-significant advantage. This, in turn, leads to the persistence of various socioeconomic and population-group-based disparities, thereby perpetuating the “barrier-to-entry” paradigm of the past. Ironically, this informal system of resource-based advantage creation largely negates the very purpose for the initial introduction of standardized testing. Lastly, given the association between “iterative practice” and performance on standardized testing, one must question the point at which the “measured merit” becomes more analogous to the performance of a large language model that can outperform purely based on “iterative patterns,” rather than a true merit attributable to a high-achieving, honest, compassionate, humble, and self-reflecting student whose intent is to become a competent and empathetic physician.[45,46] Of importance, the high level of psychological stress associated with the “high-stakes” outcome of standardized admission testing examination may lead to relative testing underperformance that is not related to one’s true knowledge, skills, and dispositions but rather to the extreme anxiety of an “all-or-none” situation.[47,48] Among undergraduate students embarking on medical school admission testing, this particular event is highly stressful and anxiety-provoking, and for many, it represents such a “high-stakes” situation for the first time in their lives.[49,50] For some, who would otherwise be highly qualified and suitable for a career in medicine, the extreme stress of preparation and examination-taking, especially if one’s scores on the initial attempt(s) are insufficient to warrant medical school admission, may effectively preclude their ability to pursue their dreams. The observed anxiety, depression, and emotional distress among medical trainees are, at least in part, associated with the extreme personal stakes and professional pressures experienced by invested individuals.[47,51] LOOKING FOR UTILITY The biggest question that is almost never asked is, “Does everyone need to take standardized tests?” The answer is complex, although there are already some very functional solutions that may offer sufficient insight into “selective testing” that is both targeted and applied in a very utilitarian and egalitarian manner, with a specific purpose (or set of purposes), rather than simply for the sake of administering and taking a test.[52-54] The slowly emerging holistic medical school admission models tend to incorporate standardized exams as one (relatively small but not insignificant) component rather than a universal “gatekeeper” variable.[46,55,56] A selective or threshold-based testing model may offer a pragmatic compromise. Under such a framework, the most accepted and increasingly widely utilized solution is the selective application of standardized medical school admission testing, primarily as a “tie-breaker” rather than an “across-the-board” evaluation. More specifically, medical schools began implementing various iterations of combined grade-point-average (GPA) and undergraduate college aptitude test scores as a surrogate for future academic capabilities.[57,58] Under such regimes, only candidates with clearly predefined “borderline performance” are requested to take standardized medical school admission tests, which then serve within a capacity similar to the United States General Education Development (GED) test – a broadly based, singular assessment that reflects proficiency across key subject areas, such as language arts, mathematics, science, and social studies.[59,60] This approach, when applied to “borderline” candidates for medical school admission, results in reasonably accurate stratification and selection of those individuals who are more likely to possess the required aptitude to succeed in medical school and beyond. At the same time, the reformed system rewards high performers during undergraduate studies by exempting them from devoting significant time and effort to a high-stakes, high-pressure, narrow-scope examination that has little to no consequence to their future career. Another solution is to integrate situational judgment tests (SJTs) to evaluate interpersonal and social skills alongside academic performance. Integrating SJTs into the medical application process could provide a different way to evaluate candidates by providing information on how they would behave in certain physician/patient/clinical scenarios.[61] This information would provide insight into the applicant’s interpersonal skills and personality characteristics, complementing standardized examinations in identifying individuals who have the temperament to become physicians. Currently, in the educational community, there is a focus on identifying additional positive predictors of medical school success, including personality traits, interview performance, and learning styles, in addition to prior academic performance, to evaluate candidates holistically.[35] SYNTHESIS AND CONCLUSIONS The current medical school admission testing paradigm represents a significant improvement over the now-defunct “networking and handshake” model of entry into the medical profession. Still, it is imperfect and likely precludes some of the highly qualified and uniquely suitable candidates from entering medical training. Consequently, we propose a new paradigm, based on selective medical admission standardized testing, utilized only in cases where routine measures of academic performance (e.g., GPA or undergraduate college admission testing) demonstrate insufficient evidence to support one’s ability to achieve expected levels of scholastic aptitude to succeed during the rigorous medical school training. Additionally, adding SJTs can serve as an adjunct to the exclusive focus on solitary standardized examination performance, supporting a more holistic approach to candidate assessment. This proposed selective approach could help eliminate some of the most significant shortcomings associated with the current medical school standardized admission testing while freeing up premedical students to pursue truly relevant preclinical activities, including volunteer and other healthcare exposure opportunities. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
Zitieren
APA
Ghatak, T., Galwankar, S. C., Ullrich, L., & Stawicki, S. P. (2025). What’s new in academic international medicine? Critical appraisal and re-evaluation of standardized testing in the medical school admission process. International Journal of Academic Medicine, 11(2), 41-45. https://doi.org/10.4103/ijam.ijam_22_26
Vancouver
Ghatak T, Galwankar SC, Ullrich L, Stawicki SP. What’s new in academic international medicine? Critical appraisal and re-evaluation of standardized testing in the medical school admission process. International Journal of Academic Medicine. 2025;11(2):41-45. doi:10.4103/ijam.ijam_22_26
BibTeX
@article{Ghatak2025,
author = {Ghatak, Tanmoy and Galwankar, Sagar C. and Ullrich, Lauryn and Stawicki, Stanislaw P.},
title = {What’s new in academic international medicine? Critical appraisal and re-evaluation of standardized testing in the medical school admission process},
journal = {International Journal of Academic Medicine},
year = {2025},
volume = {11},
number = {2},
pages = {41--45},
doi = {10.4103/ijam.ijam_22_26}
}
EUVIMED