Human Resources for Health in South-East Asia: Challenges and Strategies
WHO South-East Asia Journal of Public Health · 2023-01 · 12 (1) · 1-3
DOI: 10.4103/2224-3151.386476 ↗Kurz gefasst
Editorial in der Zeitschrift WHO South-East Asia Journal of Public Health, online erschienen am 29.09.2023. Verfasst von Krishna Rao und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Department of International Health, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland, USA. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Workforce. Die Arbeit wurde bisher 4-mal zitiert (Crossref) und nennt 20 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The 11 (Bangladesh, Bhutan, DPR Korea, India, Indonesia, Maldives, Myanmar, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Thailand, and Timor-Leste) countries of the WHO South-East Asia region represent large diversity in the economic development, politics, and progress toward universal health coverage.[1] The health of the approximately 2.5 billion people who inhabit this region will determine the trajectory of global health. Countries such as Thailand, Indonesia, the states of Tamil Nadu and Kerala in India, and Sri Lanka are widely recognized as having achieved high levels of service coverage and health. Yet, for the majority of countries and people in the region, access to affordable and quality health care remains an aspiration. For every country in South-East Asia, the ability to move to higher frontiers of health and universal health coverage will depend on the capacity and ability of the health workforce. Countries in South-East Asia face many of the classic challenges with human resources for health. To varying degrees, countries in the region are challenged with low health worker production capacity in the neediest regions, few qualified health workers in rural and underserved areas, migration of health workers to higher income countries, and variable levels of clinical competence in health workers.[2,3] Importantly, many countries have also demonstrated that these challenges can be overcome with better program implementation, good governance, and evidence-based policies. The density of doctors, nurses, and midwives increased by 21% in the region between 2015 and 2020.[1] Increases in density are also seen in each country over time; however, most of the countries (except Maldives and DPR Korea) still fall behind the WHO density threshold of 44.5 doctors, nurses, and midwives per 10,000 population.[1] South-East Asian countries have substantially increased the training capacity for health workers over the past few decades. For example, in India, the number of medical schools has increased from 136 in 1990 to 703 at present.[4] However, within-country variations are large in India; the four southern states have more than half the medical colleges, while states with the poorest health indicators have few training institutions. In most countries, the majority of medical and nursing schools are located in or near large cities. Such uneven regional production capacity leads to regional deficits in health worker availability. To address regional imbalances in training capacity of doctors, India’s health ministry has proposed to augment a large number of district hospitals into medical colleges. Although training capacity has increased across the region, the quality of training is a concern in many countries. In particular, the curricula are often outdated and do not equip health workers to deal with the complexities of serving rural communities. Interesting innovations in this regard have taken place in Thailand, where the higher medical education system is based on the Western medical education model but pays attention to local needs. Further, medical students are required to work in rural areas to give them realistic exposure as well as reduce health worker shortages there.[5,6] A key human resource challenge for the South-East Asia region is the relative scarcity of qualified health workers in rural areas. Both recruitment and retention issues are at play due to the preference of doctors for urban employment. One interesting strategy that Thailand has employed is to create a special recruitment track for medical training where students from rural provinces and districts receive full scholarships and are placed in the Ministry of Public Health hospitals in their home provinces and districts following graduation for at least 3 years.[7] Mandating medical graduates to perform rural service is another commonly used strategy to boost availability, although its practice is often compromised by weak governance.[6] Other countries, like some states in India, have reserved specialist training opportunities, which are in high demand and competitive, for medical graduates who work in rural areas.[8] The lack of highly qualified health workers in rural areas typically results in rural health services being largely provided by lesser trained health workers such as community health workers, nurses, and mid-cadre health providers. This need not necessarily result in inferior health care for rural populations – numerous studies have documented the effectiveness of task-shifting/sharing strategies of mid-level cadres to deliver quality care.[9] Bangladesh, Nepal, and Thailand have all successfully utilized task shifting in maternal and newborn health programming to combat the shortages of workers and improve coverage in poor and remote areas.[10] India has made a major commitment in this regard by establishing a cadre of community health officers who operate in rural health facilities. However, a policy commitment to strengthening these cadres is important, something that not all countries in the region have embraced. Access to specialist health services remains a challenge for rural populations across the region. Here, digital health strategies can be critical. Telemedicine strategies pursued by some countries (e.g., the e-Sanjeevani program in India) can offer a tested way of improving access to specialized services. In most South-East Asian countries, the private sector is an important provider of health services in both rural and urban areas. Yet, the private sector, particularly the for-profit private sector, has remained peripheral to government policy. The human resources represented in the private sector are substantial. In India, 65% of doctors, 93% of AYUSH, and 67% of other health workers work in the private sector.[11] In Bangladesh, 76% of doctors and 42% of nurses work in private sector facilities, and in Thailand, 43% of doctors and 14% of nurses work in the private sector.[12] Because these health workers are often the main providers of both basic and specialist health services, bringing them under a policy umbrella toward common health goals is important. Countries that have national health insurance systems, such as Thailand, India, and Indonesia, have been able to harness the resources available in the private sector through purchasing mechanisms. For example, Thailand has a large private sector, comprising 72% of all health facilities nationwide; most of which are clinics providing primary health care in urban areas; the National Health Security Office and the Social Security Office contract with private facilities to fill service gaps in urban areas.[13] India’s PM-JAY national insurance scheme purchases services from private hospitals. Informal providers make up a significant proportion of the private health workforce in some countries but are often ignored by government policy. Estimates of the number of informal providers in some South Asian countries are large, and the utilization of care provided by informal providers is high. In India, informal providers are estimated to comprise 51%–55% of all providers; in Bangladesh, informal providers are even more prevalent, comprising 88%–95% of all providers.[14] These informal providers are often the first-contact care providers for rural and poor urban populations for their convenience, affordability, and connections to the community.[14] Engaging them toward addressing local health needs, such as sharing information or providing guidance on referrals, can aid progress toward better coverage and quality care. The quality of health workers is also a concern in the region, particularly for countries at lower levels of economic development. Training institutes often have inadequate staff and infrastructure and are weakly regulated. As such, students graduate from such places without adequate training. Studies that have examined the quality of clinical care have reported low levels of health worker ability.[9,15] While the traditional approach to improving the quality of care has been through training programs, more recently, innovations in India, Nepal, and Indonesia with mentoring programs for health workers have offered a potentially more effective way of improving the clinical quality of care.[16,17,18] Some countries, such as Indonesia and Thailand, have a policy of mandatory renewal of professional licenses for local professionals that require continued professional development.[2] South-East Asia is one of the major source regions for health worker migration. The presence of Indian doctors and nurses in the Middle East, the UK, Australia, and North America is testimony to this.[19,20] A surplus production of nurses and midwives in Indonesia has led the government to promote employment abroad with popular destination countries.[21] The debate on medical migration is divided between advantages in the form of transfer of skills, knowledge, and technology, professional development and improvements in remuneration and living standards of migrant workers, and the drawbacks through its impact on source countries, which often are resource poor and have a chronic shortage of health workers. Some countries in the region have taken steps to control the outflow of health workers, like requiring recent graduates to serve some years in the country.[2] Addressing the human resources challenges faced in the health sector requires a multifaceted approach involving education, policy reforms, and innovations. There is a wealth of innovations and experiences within the region to draw upon that may help address these challenges. As such, sharing this knowledge and experience is an important first step for a more vibrant health workforce and achieving universal coverage in the region.
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Department of International Health, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
Zitieren
APA
Rao, K., & Schmidt, A. (2023). Human Resources for Health in South-East Asia: Challenges and Strategies. WHO South-East Asia Journal of Public Health, 12(1), 1-3. https://doi.org/10.4103/2224-3151.386476
Vancouver
Rao K, Schmidt A. Human Resources for Health in South-East Asia: Challenges and Strategies. WHO South-East Asia Journal of Public Health. 2023;12(1):1-3. doi:10.4103/2224-3151.386476
BibTeX
@article{Rao2023,
author = {Rao, Krishna and Schmidt, Austin},
title = {Human Resources for Health in South-East Asia: Challenges and Strategies},
journal = {WHO South-East Asia Journal of Public Health},
year = {2023},
volume = {12},
number = {1},
pages = {1--3},
doi = {10.4103/2224-3151.386476}
}
EUVIMED