EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Where the outliers lie: The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot of Tunis and the limits of identity in death

Margaux Fitoussi

L'Année du Maghreb · 2026 · 35

DOI: 10.4000/16fhh ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift L'Année du Maghreb, 2026. Verfasst von Margaux Fitoussi. Die Arbeit nennt 47 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

This article examines the Freethinkers’ Burial Plot of Tunis as a site where the limits of a “non-religious” identity become visible. While the living may enjoy a degree of flexibility in how they define themselves outside of religion, death often imposes categorization. Decisions about the burial site and the physical form of the tomb inscribe the departed into identities that may not reflect how they lived. In Tunisia, the overwhelming majority of the population—Muslim, Jewish, and Christian—is buried in cemeteries corresponding to their family’s religious background, regardless of personal belief or practice. The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot disrupts this pattern while simultaneously revealing its social grammar: Jewish- and Christian-born freethinkers, though minorities in Tunisian society at large, are disproportionately represented in the plot, yet find themselves discursively reinscribed within their religious communities of origin. Muslim-born freethinkers, by contrast, are strikingly absent, returned both materially and discursively to Islam in death. This asymmetry illuminates the constraints of a postcolonial Tunisian national identity deeply bound to Islam and raises questions about who can be memorialized as non-religious, and on what terms. The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot examines the cultural reality that determines which forms of Muslim, Jewish, and Christian identity in Tunisia can be commemorated in perpetuity.The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot is located within the Borgel cemetery complex in the Montplaisir neighborhood of Tunis, a 26-hectare site divided into a Jewish cemetery maintained by the Jewish community and a municipal cemetery that is in practice Christian and predominantly European. The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot occupies a single row at the very back of this Christian section. The article uses the term “freethinkers” as it was the one I most commonly encountered in the course of ethnographic research on Jews and Jewish-Muslim relations between 2016 and 2022, including during my full-time residency in Tunis in 2021–2022. The research for this article draws on personal archives, newspaper articles, observations of the burial plot and its tombs, conversations with freethinkers and their families, Muslim caretakers of the Jewish and Christian cemeteries, and personal attendance at a funeral, an exhumation, and a public memorial.In “History from Six Feet Below,” the historian Shana Minkin observed that scholarship on death in the Middle East has engaged with questions about the dead and the archives they leave behind, without making death itself the central lens of analysis. “Where the Outliers Lie” takes up Minkin’s call—an approach that reveals how identity crystallizes at the moment of death and how burial is always a social act, never purely a matter of individual choice. What is at stake here is not abstract identity formation but the concrete ways in which a site like the Freethinkers’ Burial Plot produces a particular simplification—fixing freethinker identity unevenly according to one’s religious origin. In life, these were people united by shared political commitments and a rejection of organized religion; in death, only a handful of Jewish and Christian freethinkers were brought together there. This fixity is not static but dynamic: death acts as a lever that can simultaneously elevate certain aspects of a person’s identity while obscuring the multiplicity of who they were in life. “Where the Outliers Lie” proceeds in two parts. First, it traces the genealogy of the Freethinkers’ Burial Plot to its colonial predecessor and considers how Tunisia’s Code of Personal Status created the conditions for the contemporary burial plot’s existence. Second, the bulk of the paper reflects on the Muslim absence and the Jewish and Christian presence in the plot, with particular attention to the decedents of Jewish origin—a focus that illuminates how religious identity, minority status, and national belonging intersect in the memorialization of these deceased “outliers”.

Zitieren

APA

Fitoussi, M. (2026). Where the outliers lie: The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot of Tunis and the limits of identity in death. L'Année du Maghreb, 35. https://doi.org/10.4000/16fhh

Vancouver

Fitoussi M. Where the outliers lie: The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot of Tunis and the limits of identity in death. L'Année du Maghreb. 2026;35. doi:10.4000/16fhh

BibTeX
@article{Fitoussi2026,
  author = {Fitoussi, Margaux},
  title = {Where the outliers lie: The Freethinkers’ Burial Plot of Tunis and the limits of identity in death},
  journal = {L'Année du Maghreb},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {35},
  doi = {10.4000/16fhh}
}
Kostenlos starten →