Juridical Analysis of a New Lawsuit Involving the Same Subject Matter of Dispute Based on the Principle of Ne Bis in Idem
Justice Voice · 21.11.2026 · 5 (2) · 361-372
DOI: 10.37893/jv.v5i2.1456 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Justice Voice, online erschienen am 21.11.2026. Verfasst von Moh. Fauzan Mustofa und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 16 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This study examines the legal reasoning of the panel of judges in assessing the distinction between the causa petendi in Decision Number 23/Pdt.G/2023/PN Gsk and Decision Number 70/Pdt.G/2019/PN Gsk in relation to the principle of ne bis in idem. The central issue is not merely whether the principle of ne bis in idem applies, but rather the limits of assessing causa petendi when a new lawsuit seeks the annulment of an agreement and introduces evidence designated as P-20, while the parties, subject matter of the dispute, legal relationship, and events constituting the breach of contract remain closely connected to the previous case. This study employs doctrinal (normative) legal research, combining statutory, case, and conceptual approaches to examine relevant academic literature and judicial decisions. The findings indicate that the panel of judges did not consider the subsequent lawsuit to be barred by the principle of ne bis in idem, reasoning that the shift from a claim based on breach of contract to a request for annulment of the agreement constituted a different causa petendi. To the extent that this reasoning relies on changes in the relief sought and the legal grounds invoked, it reflects a formalistic approach, as both cases arise from the same legal events and the right to seek annulment of the agreement had existed since the breach occurred. Nevertheless, the outcome of the decision may be justified to a limited extent because evidence P-20 demonstrates relevant factual developments following the previous judgment. This approach broadens opportunities for substantive justice for the plaintiff but may undermine legal certainty in the absence of clearly defined assessment criteria. This study recommends that the assessment of causa petendi be based on the substantive equivalence of the underlying legal events and developments in material facts rather than the formal construction of the statement of facts and relief sought. It further recommends a more consistent application of judicial precedents.
Zitieren
APA
Mustofa, M. F., & Anggriawan, T. P. (2026). Juridical Analysis of a New Lawsuit Involving the Same Subject Matter of Dispute Based on the Principle of Ne Bis in Idem. Justice Voice, 5(2), 361-372. https://doi.org/10.37893/jv.v5i2.1456
Vancouver
Mustofa MF, Anggriawan TP. Juridical Analysis of a New Lawsuit Involving the Same Subject Matter of Dispute Based on the Principle of Ne Bis in Idem. Justice Voice. 2026;5(2):361-372. doi:10.37893/jv.v5i2.1456
BibTeX
@article{Mustofa2026,
author = {Mustofa, Moh. Fauzan and Anggriawan, Teddy Prima},
title = {Juridical Analysis of a New Lawsuit Involving the Same Subject Matter of Dispute Based on the Principle of Ne Bis in Idem},
journal = {Justice Voice},
year = {2026},
volume = {5},
number = {2},
pages = {361--372},
doi = {10.37893/jv.v5i2.1456}
}
EUVIMED