Complementarity over competition in grammatical exhaustification
Semantics and Linguistic Theory · 31.12.2025 · 741-759
DOI: 10.3765/pat35y10 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Semantics and Linguistic Theory, online erschienen am 31.12.2025. Verfasst von Adèle Hénot-Mortier.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
"Hurford" Disjunctions, which display entailing disjuncts, are generally odd (Hurford 1974). Yet, they improve when the disjuncts are scalemates and the weaker one comes first (Singh 2008a i.a.). This suggests that a silent, local, incrementally constrained strengthening of the weaker disjunct can alleviate infelicity (Fox & Spector 2018 i.a.). Interestingly, when a similar strengthening is overtly realized via only, the same disjunctions can be rescued when the weaker disjunct comes second (Singh 2008a). To explain this difference, we assume the existence of a covert presuppositional exhaustifier (pex, Bassi, Del Pinal & Sauerland 2021), and "incrementalize" an independently motivated constraint on question answering (Doron & Wehbe 2024). pex is then banned from the second disjunct of Hurford Disjunctions due to its presupposition trivializing a local, incremental question raised by the first disjunct. We show only’s presupposition does not lead to that sort of trivialization. The constrained distribution of (c)overt exhaustifiers in Hurford Disjunctions is thus not driven by pragmatic competition (as previously argued by Singh 2008a), but instead is explained by the fact such exhaustifiers fulfill subtly distinct conversational goals. This reasoning is shown to extend to variants of the basic Hurford Disjunctions, as well as to "scalar" Sobel Sequences.
Zitieren
APA
Hénot-Mortier, A. (2025). Complementarity over competition in grammatical exhaustification. Semantics and Linguistic Theory, 741-759. https://doi.org/10.3765/pat35y10
Vancouver
Hénot-Mortier A. Complementarity over competition in grammatical exhaustification. Semantics and Linguistic Theory. 2025:741-759. doi:10.3765/pat35y10
BibTeX
@article{HnotMortier2025,
author = {Hénot-Mortier, Adèle},
title = {Complementarity over competition in grammatical exhaustification},
journal = {Semantics and Linguistic Theory},
year = {2025},
pages = {741--759},
doi = {10.3765/pat35y10}
}
EUVIMED