BETTERING THE AESTHETIC FUNCTIONALITY IN TRADEMARKS: REVIEWING THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
Journal of Intellectual Property Rights Law · 2026
DOI: 10.37591/jiprl.v9i2.2152 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Intellectual Property Rights Law, 2026. Verfasst von Neha Dahiya.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper analyzes the doctrine of aesthetic functionality in trademark law, which is a contentious and unevenly enforced principle that dictates when a product's aesthetic attributes should forfeit trademark protection to maintain equitable competition. Aesthetic functionality is an extension of utilitarian functionality. It protects features that are valued for their visual or sensory appeal rather than their ability to identify the source. As trademarks have evolved to include unconventional forms such as colors, shapes, and scents, the doctrine's ambiguous and inconsistent application by courts has resulted in considerable legal uncertainty. The paper delineates the historical evolution of aesthetic functionality through a doctrinal and descriptive analysis of case laws and academic commentaries, assesses its theoretical underpinnings, and critically examines the principal judicial and scholarly initiatives aimed at refining its scope. The paper, based on prominent scholars highlights the doctrine's primary deficiency as its lack of uniformity and coherence. It combines a number of proposed reforms, such as the traderight idea, consumer motivation tests, competitive need standards, cognitive functionality frameworks, and empirical market analyses, to create a composite framework for consistent use by the courts. This framework focuses on three main goals: keeping competition in the market, keeping the purpose of trademarks to identify sources, and encouraging new ideas that are both creative and useful. The study concludes that aesthetic functionality is an essential tool to prevent perpetual monopolies over ornamental features; however, it necessitates legislative clarification and empirical validation to guarantee coherence and predictability. In the end, the paper calls for a "multi-factor, evidence-based, and legislatively codified standard" that strikes a balance between competition, creativity, and consumer protection in modern trademark law.
Zitieren
APA
Dahiya, N. (2026). BETTERING THE AESTHETIC FUNCTIONALITY IN TRADEMARKS: REVIEWING THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS. Journal of Intellectual Property Rights Law. https://doi.org/10.37591/jiprl.v9i2.2152
Vancouver
Dahiya N. BETTERING THE AESTHETIC FUNCTIONALITY IN TRADEMARKS: REVIEWING THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS. Journal of Intellectual Property Rights Law. 2026. doi:10.37591/jiprl.v9i2.2152
BibTeX
@article{Dahiya2026,
author = {Dahiya, Neha},
title = {BETTERING THE AESTHETIC FUNCTIONALITY IN TRADEMARKS: REVIEWING THE PROPOSED AMENDMENTS},
journal = {Journal of Intellectual Property Rights Law},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.37591/jiprl.v9i2.2152}
}
EUVIMED