Contrasting Western Visions: [In/Out]sider Perspectives on Native American Representation in Fools Crow and Comanche Moon
REDEN. Revista Española de Estudios Norteamericanos · 14.05.2026 · 7 (2)
DOI: 10.37536/reden.2026.7.3140 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift REDEN. Revista Española de Estudios Norteamericanos, online erschienen am 14.05.2026. Verfasst von Adrian Arana-Armesto. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper examines the contrasting representations that McCarthy and McMurtry portray of Native American communities in Comanche Moon (1997) and Fools Crow (1986) respectively. Hence, this analysis focuses on how each writer's background and heritage influences their narrative style and cultural representation. Unlike Welch, who is a Native American author, McMurtry is a descendant of Texas Rangers and, therefore, he is an outsider to Indigenous communities. However, his narrative challenges core American myths, such as Manifest Destiny and the cowboy myth, through his portrayal of the Texas Rangers as hedonists and irresponsible. Nevertheless, in his effort to demystify the West, the author paradoxically contributes to the cultural hegemony. This is so because he strengthens stereotypes of Native Americans as brutal or hostile individuals. In contrast, James Welch, a Native American writer who has heritage from the Blackfeet community, provides an insider viewpoint. Therefore, in his work, the author portrays cultural, spiritual, and historical aspects of this community. Fools Crow highlights the experiences of the Blackfeet tribe amid the decadence of the Old West ruled by oppression and a colonial process. The author represents in his work the impact of brutal colonisation as a consequence of expansionism, which carries land loss and cultural annihilation. Therefore, I interpret Welch's literary work as a means of safeguarding cultural values and subverting dominant and hegemonic narratives that have traditionally silenced Indigenous voices. Consequently, this paper claims that his work deconstructs binarisms and advocates for third spaces, as he promotes a more complex comprehension of Native American histories and identities in American literature. Finally, this comparative analysis highlights the significance of literature and, particularly, of Native American storytelling in questioning hegemonic historical narratives. Hence, this work situates both writers within broader discussions of American identity and mythology.
Zitieren
APA
Arana-Armesto, A. (2026). Contrasting Western Visions: [In/Out]sider Perspectives on Native American Representation in Fools Crow and Comanche Moon. REDEN. Revista Española de Estudios Norteamericanos, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.37536/reden.2026.7.3140
Vancouver
Arana-Armesto A. Contrasting Western Visions: [In/Out]sider Perspectives on Native American Representation in Fools Crow and Comanche Moon. REDEN. Revista Española de Estudios Norteamericanos. 2026;7(2). doi:10.37536/reden.2026.7.3140
BibTeX
@article{AranaArmesto2026,
author = {Arana-Armesto, Adrian},
title = {Contrasting Western Visions: [In/Out]sider Perspectives on Native American Representation in Fools Crow and Comanche Moon},
journal = {REDEN. Revista Española de Estudios Norteamericanos},
year = {2026},
volume = {7},
number = {2},
doi = {10.37536/reden.2026.7.3140}
}
EUVIMED