Animus and Heightened Scrutiny: A Way Out of the ‘Dead End’
Texas A&M Law Review Arguendo · 2026
DOI: 10.37419/lr.v14.arg.2 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Texas A&M Law Review Arguendo, 2026. Verfasst von Steve Sanders.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Laws or government actions that are grounded in animus rather than proper public purposes violate the Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection. This principle arises from four canonical cases decided by the Supreme Court between 1973 and 2013. These cases remain good law. Yet in the past decade the Roberts Court has given scant attention to the animus doctrine, and lower courts appear to be in a muddle about how to use it. As a result, the animus doctrine has reached what one prominent scholar calls a “dead end.” The animus cases are often described as exhibiting a more skeptical, more demanding form of rational basis review. This Article seeks to reinvigorate the animus doctrine by demonstrating that it is best understood not as a sui generis branch of rational basis but rather as a form of heightened scrutiny. It is not dispositive that the canonical animus cases incorporate the terminology of rational basis; the important thing is how this terminology is operationalized: animus review is demonstrably heightened in method. Courts understand and are familiar with the rhythm and doctrinal moves of heightened scrutiny. The heightened-in-method model this Article describes would preserve animus as a distinct constitutional wrong while rescuing the doctrine from its current status as an underutilized curiosity.
Zitieren
APA
Sanders, S. (2026). Animus and Heightened Scrutiny: A Way Out of the ‘Dead End’. Texas A&M Law Review Arguendo. https://doi.org/10.37419/lr.v14.arg.2
Vancouver
Sanders S. Animus and Heightened Scrutiny: A Way Out of the ‘Dead End’. Texas A&M Law Review Arguendo. 2026. doi:10.37419/lr.v14.arg.2
BibTeX
@article{Sanders2026,
author = {Sanders, Steve},
title = {Animus and Heightened Scrutiny: A Way Out of the ‘Dead End’},
journal = {Texas A&M Law Review Arguendo},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.37419/lr.v14.arg.2}
}
EUVIMED