Waterloo Sparkling Water and the Natural Zone of Expansion: How Trademark Rights Can Bubble Over
Texas A&M Law Review · 2026-05 · 13 (4) · 1613-1636
DOI: 10.37419/lr.v13.i4.9 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Texas A&M Law Review, 2026-05. Verfasst von Amari K. Wilson.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
As markets expand and competitors adapt, trademark owners are forced to broaden the scope of the goods or services that are offered under their marks. But what happens when a business decides to venture into other industries in the future? How far should its initial trademark protection extend? The natural zone of expansion doctrine—as it applies to trade—seeks to answer these questions. In Waterloo Sparkling Water Corp., Waterloo had existing senior trademark rights to its mark for sparkling water beverages, but the district court declined to extend protection for the mark’s use in connection with alcoholic seltzers. While there are several approaches to evaluate the natural zone of expansion, the district court diverged from common applications and produced a questionable result that had lasting ramifications for Waterloo. Understanding that this area of law calls for congruity, this Note aims to synthesize existing methods by proposing a new three-factor test for courts to use when evaluating the natural zone of expansion for a mark’s goods: (1) whether there is a large gap between the mark’s existing goods and its subsequently expanded goods; (2) whether similar companies have made a similar expansion; and (3) whether consumers would reasonably assume that the trademark owner would sell the expanded goods. In particular, the test considers the relationship between the goods and their respective markets, consumers, and branding; the importance of industry trends; and the role of public perception. This proposed analysis incorporates the main principles and motivations of trademark law to help determine how far a trademark owner’s rights can bubble into protection for expanded products.
Zitieren
APA
Wilson, A. K. (2026). Waterloo Sparkling Water and the Natural Zone of Expansion: How Trademark Rights Can Bubble Over. Texas A&M Law Review, 13(4), 1613-1636. https://doi.org/10.37419/lr.v13.i4.9
Vancouver
Wilson AK. Waterloo Sparkling Water and the Natural Zone of Expansion: How Trademark Rights Can Bubble Over. Texas A&M Law Review. 2026;13(4):1613-1636. doi:10.37419/lr.v13.i4.9
BibTeX
@article{Wilson2026,
author = {Wilson, Amari K.},
title = {Waterloo Sparkling Water and the Natural Zone of Expansion: How Trademark Rights Can Bubble Over},
journal = {Texas A&M Law Review},
year = {2026},
volume = {13},
number = {4},
pages = {1613--1636},
doi = {10.37419/lr.v13.i4.9}
}
EUVIMED