EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Rahimi's Goldilocks Dilemma: Finding the "Just Right" Age of Tradition

James M. Handwerk

Texas A&M Law Review · 2026-05 · 13 (4) · 1543-1570

DOI: 10.37419/lr.v13.i4.7 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Texas A&M Law Review, 2026-05. Verfasst von James M. Handwerk.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Although its edges are obscured with unresolved tension, the Supreme Court’s recent sortie into Second Amendment interpretation sparked a new era of historical scrutiny. Some question whether the various difficulties present in the new framework render the doctrine unworkable. Rahimi’s Goldilocks Dilemma examines the interpretive obstacles posed by the text, history, and tradition framework, which was brought to light in New York State Pistol & Rifle Ass’n v. Bruen and United States v. Rahimi. Particularly, this Comment focuses on the role that pre-ratification history plays in finding “relevant” historical analogs. Pre-ratification history, as defined by this Comment, includes both English common law and American colonial history before the ratification of the Bill of Rights. Now, most recently, Rahimi revealed some of Bruen’s unresolved ambiguities—especially regarding the temporal reach of relevant historical analogs. Rahimi’s Goldilocks Dilemma argues that pre-ratification history often fails to illuminate the scope of the Second Amendment and, instead, contributes to obscuring the amendment’s meaning by invoking the very traditions that the founding generation fought a war to reject. Many of the analogs are not only directly contradictory to the U.S. Constitution, but they were also expressly repudiated by the Founders themselves. This is shown by a careful reading of the Supreme Court’s evolving doctrine—utilizing the federal felon-in-possession statute and the “common use” doctrine—which leads to the only reasonable conclusion that historical legal principles must be filtered through the lens of originalism. In other words, courts must consider whether these principles actually survived to become the Founders’ law. Blindly incorporating pre-ratification history fails to uncover the true meaning of the Second Amendment and often directly contradicts its underlying principles. What’s more, it will usually even fail to satisfy the broadest application of the “relevant historical analog” test from Rahimi. Instead, focusing on the meaning of the Second Amendment at the time of the founding ensures that America’s constitutional rights are not defined by the shackles of an antiquated legal order but by the principles enshrined at the founding of the United States.

Zitieren

APA

Handwerk, J. M. (2026). Rahimi's Goldilocks Dilemma: Finding the "Just Right" Age of Tradition. Texas A&M Law Review, 13(4), 1543-1570. https://doi.org/10.37419/lr.v13.i4.7

Vancouver

Handwerk JM. Rahimi's Goldilocks Dilemma: Finding the "Just Right" Age of Tradition. Texas A&M Law Review. 2026;13(4):1543-1570. doi:10.37419/lr.v13.i4.7

BibTeX
@article{Handwerk2026,
  author = {Handwerk, James M.},
  title = {Rahimi's Goldilocks Dilemma: Finding the "Just Right" Age of Tradition},
  journal = {Texas A&M Law Review},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {13},
  number = {4},
  pages = {1543--1570},
  doi = {10.37419/lr.v13.i4.7}
}
Kostenlos starten →