Cromwell’s Revolution—Mineral Law After the Texas Supreme Court’s Adventure in Formalism
Texas A&M Journal of Property Law · 2026-11 · 13 (1) · 1-82
DOI: 10.37419/jpl.v13.i1.1 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Texas A&M Journal of Property Law, 2026-11. Verfasst von Joseph Schremmer.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In Cromwell v. Anadarko E&P Onshore, the Texas Supreme Court decided an arcane issue of oil and gas law, namely whether drilling and production must be conducted by the lessee to continue the lessee’s oil and gas lease. Disapproving of earlier cases holding the opposite, the Cromwell court held that any production operations on the leased premises will sustain a lease, even those conducted by the lessee’s cotenant operator without the lessee’s participation. The court rested its holding on the literal meaning of the subject oil and gas leases, a rationale that it believed provides “legal certainty and predictability” in an area of law that “requires bright lines and sharp corners.” On its face, Cromwell seems merely to tidy up a messy doctrinal area that previous case law rendered needlessly complicated. Upon closer examination, however, Cromwell is no minor course correction. Rather, it marks a shift in Texas’s mineral law jurisprudence toward more formalistic treatment of relations between cotenants and parties to a lease. Placing Cromwell in historical context with the long line of cases it overruled requiring cotenant lessees to participate in operations to sustain their leases, this Article argues that Cromwell sacrificed other legal virtues in its pursuit of “certainty and predictability.” Even though it achieved a just result for the parties to the case, to arrive at this result, Cromwell dispensed with a doctrine that previous courts had employed to encourage cooperation among operating and nonoperating cotenants and mineral owners. Furthermore, the opinion embraced a hyperliteral method of interpreting oil and gas leases and cast doubt on traditional methods that were more sensitive to the context in which leases function. While tantalizingly simple, Cromwell’s formalistic view of the law seems to flatten more than clarify mineral law. A flatter, less nuanced mineral law might prove more complicated to administer justly in the long run.
Zitieren
APA
Schremmer, J. (2026). Cromwell’s Revolution—Mineral Law After the Texas Supreme Court’s Adventure in Formalism. Texas A&M Journal of Property Law, 13(1), 1-82. https://doi.org/10.37419/jpl.v13.i1.1
Vancouver
Schremmer J. Cromwell’s Revolution—Mineral Law After the Texas Supreme Court’s Adventure in Formalism. Texas A&M Journal of Property Law. 2026;13(1):1-82. doi:10.37419/jpl.v13.i1.1
BibTeX
@article{Schremmer2026,
author = {Schremmer, Joseph},
title = {Cromwell’s Revolution—Mineral Law After the Texas Supreme Court’s Adventure in Formalism},
journal = {Texas A&M Journal of Property Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {13},
number = {1},
pages = {1--82},
doi = {10.37419/jpl.v13.i1.1}
}
EUVIMED