When identity meets rationality: The arousal of motivated System 2 reasoning
Health Psychology Research · 04.05.2026 · 14 (2) · 0326
DOI: 10.36922/hpr.0326 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Health Psychology Research, online erschienen am 04.05.2026. Verfasst von Hongyang Liu und 4 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
Classical dual-process theories assume that fast, intuitive System 1 often produces bias, whereas slow, deliberative System 2 corrects it. Evidence on motivated reasoning suggests a refinement: when beliefs are tied to identity, deliberation can intensify rather than reduce bias (motivated System 2 reasoning; MS2R).
Objective
To synthesize theory and evidence on when and why analytic reasoning amplifies identity-consistent judgments, and to highlight implications for health-related beliefs and misinformation.
Methods
Focused narrative review integrating findings from political, science-communication, and health literatures, including high-powered replications and resource-rational/approximate Bayesian models, to organize MS2R mechanisms, boundary conditions, and countermeasures. Identity-congruent evaluation of information is robust across domains (e.g., climate risk, vaccination, gun policy), whereas the strong claim that greater cognitive ability uniformly amplifies bias receives mixed support. We organized five proximate mechanisms that can yield MS2R: confirmation bias/motivated skepticism, cognitive dissonance rationalization, identity-protective cognition, expressive responding/instrumental rationality, and bounded resource-rational selective trust. MS2R is most likely when identity stakes are high, evidence is ambiguous, accuracy incentives are weak, affective threat gates processing, audiences are salient, and information ecologies encourage selective trust. In health psychology, these dynamics help explain the persistence of vaccine hesitancy and health misinformation despite deliberation. We outlined countermeasures that realign deliberation toward accuracy, including accuracy prompts/incentives, identity-safe and value-concordant framing (including self-affirmation), structured symmetric scrutiny, probabilistic forecasting with feedback, prebunking, and interventions that recalibrate source reliability.
Conclusion
System 2 is not inherently corrective: when identity stakes dominate, deliberation can intensify bias. Health interventions should reduce threat, align values, and incentivize accuracy to curb misinformation.
Zitieren
APA
Liu, H., Kvintova, J., Dockalova, J., Vachova, L., & Plevova, I. (2026). When identity meets rationality: The arousal of motivated System 2 reasoning. Health Psychology Research, 14(2), 0326. https://doi.org/10.36922/hpr.0326
Vancouver
Liu H, Kvintova J, Dockalova J, Vachova L, Plevova I. When identity meets rationality: The arousal of motivated System 2 reasoning. Health Psychology Research. 2026;14(2):0326. doi:10.36922/hpr.0326
BibTeX
@article{Liu2026,
author = {Liu, Hongyang and Kvintova, Jana and Dockalova, Justyna and Vachova, Lucie and Plevova, Irena},
title = {When identity meets rationality: The arousal of motivated System 2 reasoning},
journal = {Health Psychology Research},
year = {2026},
volume = {14},
number = {2},
pages = {0326},
doi = {10.36922/hpr.0326}
}
EUVIMED